Protocol for a Randomized Crossover Trial to Evaluate the Effect of Soft Brace and Rigid Orthosis on Performance and Readiness to Return to Sport Six Months Post-ACL-Reconstruction

Sonja Jahnke, Caren Cruysen, Robert Prill, Fabian Kittmann, Nicola Pflug, Justin Amadeus Albert, Tibor de Camargo, Bert Arnrich, Aleksandra Królikowska, Anna Kołcz, Paweł Reichert, Łukasz Oleksy, Sven Michel, Sebastian Kopf, Michael Wagner, Sven Scheffler, Roland BeckerHealthcare 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study protocol outlines a randomized crossover trial investigating the impact of soft braces and rigid orthoses on the functional performance and readiness to return to sport for individuals six months post-ACL reconstruction. By combining biomechanical assessments with muscle activity analysis, the research aims to clarify the role of these devices in restoring knee stability and inform rehabilitation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) tears are common, and while reconstruction surgery (ACLR) is effective, a significant percentage of patients experience re-rupture or long-term functional deficits, including knee instability and osteoarthritis. A major challenge in ACLR rehabilitation is determining when an athlete is truly ready to return to sport (RTS). Current RTS criteria are not standardized, and there's a lack of consensus on the effectiveness of prophylactic knee bracing. Furthermore, understanding how muscle activation patterns, particularly in the gluteus medius and semitendinosus, contribute to functional stability and dynamic knee valgus (DKV) after ACLR is crucial for optimizing recovery and preventing re-injury. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive evaluation of orthotic devices' influence on performance and the underlying biomechanical factors contributing to successful RTS.

Methods

The study employs a randomized, prospective, single-blind, three-group crossover design. Twenty-eight patients, six months post-primary unilateral ACLR using an autologous hamstring tendon graft, will participate. The core of the assessment is the modified "Back in Action" (BIA) test battery, which includes a series of functional tests:

  • Stability Tests: Double-leg and single-leg balance tests.
  • Jumps: Double-leg and single-leg countermovement jumps (CMJ), drop jumps, and single-leg landings.
  • Jump Coordination: Speedy jump tests and quick feet tests.
  • Isometric Strength Test: Hip abductor strength measurement.

Crucially, these tests will be performed under three conditions in a randomized order: wearing a rigid knee orthosis, wearing a soft knee brace, and with no aid.

To capture biomechanical data, the study utilizes:

  • Surface Electromyography (sEMG): To measure the muscle activation of the gluteus medius and semitendinosus on both the reconstructed and unaffected legs.
  • 3D Force Plates (Bertec): To record forces and moments during landing and jumping.
  • Microsoft Azure Kinect DK: A marker-less motion capture system to analyze knee and hip joint kinematics, specifically focusing on dynamic knee valgus (DKV) during landing.

Patient-reported outcomes will also be collected using standardized questionnaires (IKDC, ACL-RSI, Tegner Activity Scale).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on collecting new data from participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Orthotic Devices: A Double-Edged Sword? The study directly tackles the question of whether braces and orthoses truly aid or potentially hinder functional performance post-ACLR. The crossover design allows for within-subject comparisons, which is powerful for isolating the effect of the devices.
  • Beyond Hop Tests: A Comprehensive Functional Battery: The use of the BIA test battery, which goes beyond traditional hop tests, provides a more holistic assessment of functional recovery, incorporating stability, jumping, and coordination.
  • Muscle Activation as a Key Indicator: Investigating the activation patterns of the gluteus medius and semitendinosus is critical. These muscles play vital roles in hip and knee stability, and their altered function post-ACLR could be a significant factor in residual deficits and re-injury risk.
  • Feedforward and Feedback Mechanisms: The study aims to draw conclusions about how athletes utilize feedforward (anticipatory) and feedback (reactive) control strategies during functional tasks, and how orthotic devices might influence these. This is a sophisticated aspect of motor control relevant to rehabilitation.
  • Dynamic Knee Valgus (DKV) as a Red Flag: The focus on DKV during landing is important, as it's a known risk factor for ACL injuries. Understanding how muscle activation and orthotics affect DKV is key to injury prevention.

Key Results

As this is a protocol, no results are presented. The paper outlines the planned methodology and expected outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Single-Blind Design: While statistical analysts are blinded, participants and assessors are not, which could introduce some bias.
  • Sample Size: A sample size of 28 is relatively small, though it's justified by the expectation of a large effect size and the crossover design.
  • Timing of Assessment: The assessment is conducted six months post-ACLR. While this is a common RTS timeframe, recovery can vary, and earlier or later assessments might yield different insights.
  • Focus on Specific Muscles: While gluteus medius and semitendinosus are critical, other muscles also contribute to knee stability.

Future Work:

  • Longitudinal Studies: Following these patients beyond six months could reveal long-term effects of orthotic use and the sustainability of functional improvements.
  • Different Graft Types: The study focuses on hamstring grafts; future research could explore differences with patellar tendon or allograft reconstructions.
  • Injury Prevention Programs: If the study identifies specific biomechanical deficits or benefits from orthotics, this could inform the development of more targeted injury prevention programs.
  • Psychological Impact: While mentioned as a consideration, a deeper dive into the psychological impact of wearing orthotics on an athlete's confidence and willingness to perform could be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

A randomized crossover trial was designed to investigate the influence of muscle activation and strength on functional stability/control of the knee joint, to determine whether bilateral imbalances still occur six months after successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), and to analyze whether the use of orthotic devices changes the activity onset of these muscles. Furthermore, conclusions on the feedforward and feedback mechanisms are highlighted. Therefore, twenty-eight patients will take part in a modified Back in Action (BIA) test battery at an average of six months after a primary unilateral ACLR, which used an autologous ipsilateral semitendinosus tendon graft. This includes double-leg and single-leg stability tests, double-leg and single-leg countermovement jumps, double-leg and single-leg drop jumps, a speedy jump test, and a quick feet test. During the tests, gluteus medius and semitendinosus muscle activity are analyzed using surface electromyography (sEMG). Motion analysis is conducted using Microsoft Azure DK and 3D force plates. The tests are performed while wearing knee rigid orthosis, soft brace, and with no aid, in random order. Additionally, the range of hip and knee motion and hip abductor muscle strength under isometric conditions are measured. Furthermore, patient-rated outcomes will be assessed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jahnke2023protocol,
  author = {Sonja Jahnke and Caren Cruysen and Robert Prill and Fabian Kittmann and Nicola Pflug and Justin Amadeus Albert and Tibor de Camargo and Bert Arnrich and Aleksandra Królikowska and Anna Kołcz and Paweł Reichert and Łukasz Oleksy and Sven Michel and Sebastian Kopf and Michael Wagner and Sven Scheffler and Roland Becker},
  title = {{Protocol for a Randomized Crossover Trial to Evaluate the Effect of Soft Brace and Rigid Orthosis on Performance and Readiness to Return to Sport Six Months Post-ACL-Reconstruction}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare11040513},
}
Figure