Proteomic Analysis of Ubiquitinated Proteins in Rice (Oryza sativa) After Treatment With Pathogen-Associated Molecular Pattern (PAMP) Elicitors

Xiaolin Chen, Xin Xie, Liye Wu, Caiyun Liu, Lirong Zeng, Xueping Zhou, Feng Luo, Guo‐Liang Wang, Wende LiuFrontiers in Plant Science 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides the first comprehensive quantitative proteomic analysis of ubiquitination in rice seedlings upon treatment with pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) like chitin and flg22. They identified thousands of ubiquitinated proteins and revealed how ubiquitination dynamically regulates key defense pathways, including hormone signaling and the phenylpropanoid metabolism, offering a valuable resource for understanding plant immunity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plants have sophisticated defense systems to combat pathogens, with pattern-triggered immunity (PTI) being a crucial first line of defense. PTI is initiated when plant receptors recognize conserved microbial molecules called PAMPs. While the importance of protein ubiquitination in regulating cellular processes, including plant immunity, is well-established, a global understanding of how ubiquitination changes in response to PAMPs in a major crop like rice has been lacking. Specifically, researchers wanted to know which proteins are ubiquitinated, how their ubiquitination levels change upon PAMP perception, and what cellular processes are affected by these changes. This knowledge gap hinders a complete understanding of the intricate regulatory network governing plant defense.

Methods

The researchers employed a label-free quantitative proteomic approach. Rice seedlings were treated with either chitin or flg22 (PAMPs) or a control (water) for various time points. Protein extracts were then subjected to:

  • Trypsin Digestion and Affinity Enrichment: Proteins were digested into peptides, and then peptides containing the di-Gly-Lys remnant motif (a hallmark of ubiquitination) were specifically enriched using an anti-K-ε-GG antibody. This step is crucial for isolating ubiquitinated peptides from the vast background of non-ubiquitinated peptides.
  • Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS): The enriched peptides were analyzed using high-resolution mass spectrometry to identify and quantify ubiquitinated peptides.
  • Bioinformatic Analysis: The identified ubiquitinated proteins and their sites were annotated using Gene Ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) databases to understand their functions and pathways. Protein-protein interaction networks were also constructed.
  • Western Blot Analysis: This was used to confirm the overall ubiquitination levels at different time points and to validate the induction of defense responses.

Datasets

The study utilized rice (Japonica cultivar Nipponbare) seedlings as the biological system. The proteomic data generated in this study has been deposited in the integrated proteome resources (iProX) with the project ID IPX0001089000.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitination is a Dynamic Regulator of PTI: The study reveals that PAMP perception triggers widespread and dynamic changes in protein ubiquitination, indicating that ubiquitination is not just a static modification but a key player in actively modulating defense responses.
  • Chitin and Flg22 Elicit Similar, Yet Distinct, Ubiquitination Patterns: While both chitin and flg22 treatments resulted in largely overlapping changes in ubiquitination, suggesting a common downstream signaling cascade, there were also specific differences observed, particularly in E3 ligases, ROS production, and hormone pathways. This highlights the nuanced nature of PAMP perception.
  • Phenylpropanoid Pathway is Heavily Regulated by Ubiquitination: A significant finding is the widespread increase in ubiquitination of enzymes in the phenylpropanoid metabolic pathway. This pathway is critical for producing defense compounds and antioxidants, suggesting that ubiquitination plays a role in either boosting or fine-tuning the production of these essential molecules during defense.
  • Hormone Signaling is Fine-Tuned by Ubiquitination: The study identified changes in ubiquitination of proteins involved in various hormone signaling pathways (BR, auxin, ABA, JA, ET, cytokinin). This suggests that ubiquitination acts as a crucial switch to coordinate hormone responses for optimal defense.
  • Ubiquitination System Itself is Regulated: Even components of the ubiquitination machinery itself, such as E3 ligases and ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes, showed altered ubiquitination levels, indicating a complex feedback and regulatory loop within the system.

Key Results

  • Identification of a Large Ubiquitome: The study identified a total of 2,882 lysine ubiquitination (Kub) sites in 1,376 proteins in rice seedlings.
  • Differential Ubiquitination:
    • In chitin-treated samples, 144 ubiquitination sites in 121 proteins increased, and 167 sites in 162 proteins decreased.
  • In flg22-treated samples, 151 ubiquitination sites in 118 proteins increased, and 179 sites in 166 proteins decreased.
  • Overlap in Responses: 63 sites in 49 proteins and 64 sites in 64 proteins showed increased and decreased ubiquitination, respectively, in both chitin- and flg22-treated samples.
  • Functional Categories Affected: Ubiquitination changes were observed in proteins involved in the ubiquitin system, protein transportation, ligand recognition, membrane trafficking, redox reactions, hormone signaling, and the phenylpropanoid metabolic pathway.
  • Phenylpropanoid Pathway Enzymes: Many enzymes in this pathway, including OsPAL1, OsPAL2, OsPAL5, OsPAL7, Os4CL3, OsC4HL, OsCHS1, OsCOMT1, and OsF5H, showed significantly increased ubiquitination.
  • Hormone Signaling Proteins: Six proteins in the brassinosteroid signaling pathway showed significantly higher ubiquitination. Auxin and GA signaling pathways showed repressed ubiquitination of key proteins like OsCYP2 and OsGID2.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time Point Specificity: The study focused on a specific time point (3 hours post-treatment) for detailed proteomic analysis. Further investigation into early and later time points would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the temporal dynamics of ubiquitination during PTI.
  • Functional Validation: While the study identifies numerous ubiquitination targets, direct functional validation of the role of ubiquitination for each identified protein in defense responses would be a logical next step.
  • Specific Ubiquitination Types: The study focused on lysine ubiquitination. Exploring other types of ubiquitination (e.g., K48 vs. K63 linkages) and their specific roles in defense would be valuable.
  • Elicitor-Specific Mechanisms: While similarities were observed, further research is needed to elucidate the precise mechanisms underlying the observed differences in ubiquitination between chitin and flg22 treatments.

The authors suggest that the identified ubiquitination targets provide a valuable resource for future research aimed at understanding how the ubiquitination system fine-tunes plant defense responses to pathogen attack.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reversible protein ubiquitination plays essential roles in regulating cellular processes. Although many reports have described the functions of ubiquitination in plant defense responses, few have focused on global changes in the ubiquitome. To better understand the regulatory roles of ubiquitination in rice pattern-triggered immunity (PTI), we investigated the ubiquitome of rice seedlings after treatment with two pathogen-associated molecular patterns, the fungal-derived chitin or the bacterial-derived flg22, using label-free quantitative proteomics. In chitin-treated samples, 144 and 167 lysine-ubiquitination sites in 121 and 162 proteins showed increased and decreased ubiquitination, respectively. In flg22-treated samples, 151 and 179 lysine-ubiquitination sites in 118 and 166 proteins showed increased and decreased ubiquitination, respectively. Bioinformatic analyses indicated diverse regulatory roles of these proteins. The ubiquitination levels of many proteins involved in the ubiquitination system, protein transportation, ligand recognition, membrane trafficking, and redox reactions were significantly changed in response to the elicitor treatments. Notably, the ubiquitination levels of many enzymes in the phenylpropanoid metabolic pathway were up-regulated, indicating that this pathway is tightly regulated by ubiquitination during rice PTI. Additionally, the ubiquitination levels of some key components in plant hormone signaling pathways were up- or down-regulated, suggesting that ubiquitination may fine-tune hormone pathways for defense responses. Our results demonstrated that ubiquitination, by targeting a wide range of proteins for degradation or stabilization, has a widespread role in modulating PTI in rice. The large pool of ubiquitination targets will serve as a valuable resource for understanding how the ubiquitination system regulates defense responses to pathogen attack.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2018proteomic,
  author = {Xiaolin Chen and Xin Xie and Liye Wu and Caiyun Liu and Lirong Zeng and Xueping Zhou and Feng Luo and Guo‐Liang Wang and Wende Liu},
  title = {{Proteomic Analysis of Ubiquitinated Proteins in Rice (Oryza sativa) After Treatment With Pathogen-Associated Molecular Pattern (PAMP) Elicitors}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2018.01064},
}
Figure