TL;DR
This paper introduces PRIMMUS, a novel workflow combining intracellular staining, Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting (FACS), and mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics. PRIMMUS allows for the detailed proteomic and phosphoproteomic analysis of specific cell cycle phases, including distinct mitotic subphases, in asynchronously growing cells, overcoming limitations of previous methods. This approach provides unprecedented resolution for studying cell cycle regulation and identifies new insights into protein dynamics during mitosis.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the precise molecular events that drive cell division is fundamental to biology. The cell cycle is a tightly regulated process involving dynamic changes in protein abundance and post-translational modifications (PTMs), particularly phosphorylation. However, studying these changes during mitosis is challenging due to the short duration of each subphase (prophase, prometaphase, metaphase, anaphase, telophase) and the inherent variability in cell cycle progression. Traditional methods for synchronizing cells can introduce artifacts, and analyzing mixed cell populations dilutes signals from specific phases. While mass spectrometry has advanced proteomic analysis, obtaining high-resolution data for specific, transient cell cycle stages, especially within mitosis, has remained a significant hurdle. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method to precisely isolate and proteomically analyze distinct cell cycle phases, including mitotic subphases, from asynchronously growing cells.
Methods
The core innovation presented is the PRIMMUS (PRoteomic analysis of Intracellular iMMUnolabelled cell Subsets) workflow. This method integrates several key steps:
- Fixation and Permeabilization Optimization: The authors meticulously optimized formaldehyde fixation and methanol permeabilization protocols to ensure efficient intracellular antigen staining while minimizing protein loss and chemical modifications that could interfere with MS analysis.
- Intracellular Immunostaining: Cells are stained with specific antibodies targeting intracellular markers that define different cell cycle phases (e.g., DNA content via DAPI, histone H3 phosphorylation for mitosis).
- FACS Sorting: Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting (FACS) is used to physically separate cells into highly pure populations based on their fluorescence signals from the immunostaining. This allows for the isolation of specific cell cycle phases (G1, S, G2, M) and even distinct mitotic subphases (prophase, prometaphase, anaphase) with high efficiency.
- Mass Spectrometry (MS)-Based Proteomics: The sorted cell populations are then subjected to standard MS-based proteomic workflows (including SILAC or TMT labeling for quantitative analysis) to measure protein abundance and phosphorylation changes.
This combination allows for the analysis of specific cell populations that would be difficult or impossible to isolate using other methods, especially for transient mitotic stages.
Datasets
The study utilized the following cell lines for their experiments:
- NB4 cells: A human leukemia cell line, used extensively for both proteomic and phosphoproteomic analyses, including cell cycle phase separation.
- LLC-Pk1 cells: A porcine cell line, used for experiments involving TPX2 mutants and spindle phenotypes.
- U2OS cells: A human osteosarcoma cell line, used for validation of RRM2 degradation.
- HeLa cells: A human cervical cancer cell line, used for RRM2 depletion and overexpression experiments.
The proteomic data generated in this study are publicly available via the ProteomeXchange repository (identifier PXD007787) and the Encyclopedia of Proteome Dynamics (EPD).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the Gap: PRIMMUS effectively bridges the gap between high-resolution cell cycle analysis (like flow cytometry) and deep proteomic profiling, enabling the study of molecular events in specific, transient cell cycle stages.
- Mitotic Subphase Resolution: The ability to isolate and analyze distinct mitotic subphases (prophase, prometaphase, anaphase) is a significant advancement, offering a much finer view of the dynamic proteome during cell division than previously possible.
- Artifact Mitigation: By optimizing fixation and permeabilization, and by using an unperturbed cell cycle approach (rather than chemical arrests), PRIMMUS minimizes artifacts that can confound proteomic analyses.
- "Early Risers" of Mitosis: The identification of a set of 115 "early riser" phosphorylation sites that increase in G2 phase, preceding full mitosis, suggests a coordinated preparation for mitotic entry.
- TPX2 Phosphorylation's Role: The study highlights the functional importance of TPX2 phosphorylation at S738, showing that mutations at this site impair spindle assembly, suggesting a regulatory role in mitotic progression.
- RRM2 Degradation Timing: The finding that RRM2, an essential enzyme for DNA synthesis, is degraded during prometaphase, a stage not typically associated with its degradation, challenges existing models and suggests a novel regulatory mechanism.
Key Results
- Optimized Protocol: The study successfully optimized fixation (0.5% FA) and permeabilization (methanol) for MS-based proteomics, minimizing protein loss and modifications.
- High Purity Sorting: FACS sorting achieved high purity for G1, S, G2, and M phase populations, and importantly, for mitotic subphases (prophase, prometaphase, anaphase).
- Proteome-Wide Changes: PRIMMUS enabled the first proteome-wide analysis of protein abundance remodeling across mitotic subphases, revealing that only ~1.5% of quantified proteins significantly decrease in abundance.
- "Early Riser" Phosphorylation Sites: 115 phosphorylation sites were identified as "early risers," showing increased phosphorylation in G2 phase. These sites are enriched in nuclear proteins and are associated with the CDK consensus motif.
- TPX2 S738 Function: Phosphodefective (S738A) and phosphomimetic (S738D) TPX2 mutants showed defects in bipolar spindle assembly, indicating a functional role for S738 phosphorylation in mitotic progression.
- RRM2 Degradation: RRM2 levels were found to decrease significantly during prometaphase, a process sensitive to MLN-4924 (an SCF complex inhibitor), suggesting a proteasomal degradation pathway.
- Sensitivity Advantage: PRIMMUS demonstrated a five-fold sensitivity gain in detecting cell cycle-regulated protein abundance changes compared to centrifugal elutriation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Cell Type Specificity: While validated in NB4 and U2OS cells, the generalizability of the PRIMMUS approach to all cell types, especially primary cells, may require further validation.
- Mitotic Subphase Resolution: While prophase, prometaphase, and anaphase were well-resolved, telophase and cytokinesis were not effectively captured, partly due to the gating strategy.
- Antibody-Derived Peptides: Although addressed by the method, the presence of antibody-derived peptides in M-phase fractions is a potential consideration for MS analysis.
- Future Work: The authors suggest expanding the analysis to include more detailed phosphoproteomic studies across all cell cycle phases, exploring protein interaction partners using MS-based techniques, and applying PRIMMUS to other cell types, including primary cells. Further investigation into the precise mechanisms and functional consequences of RRM2 degradation and TPX2 phosphorylation is also warranted.
Summary updated