Proteo-Transcriptomic Dynamics of Cellular Response to HIV-1 Infection

Monica Golumbeanu, Sébastien Desfarges, Céline Hernandez, Manfredo Quadroni, Sylvie Rato, Pejman Mohammadi, Amalio Telenti, Niko Beerenwinkel, Angela CiuffiScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive, multi-omics temporal analysis of the host cell's response to HIV-1 infection, revealing dynamic changes in gene expression, protein levels, and phosphorylation over the viral replication cycle. The researchers developed a novel R/Bioconductor package and a user-friendly web application (PEACHi2.0) to catalog these dynamic interactions, uncovering previously unknown host factors involved in HIV replication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how HIV-1 interacts with and manipulates host cells is crucial for developing effective treatments. While previous studies have investigated these interactions, they often relied on single "omics" data types (like just transcriptomics or proteomics) and were limited to a single time point. This approach misses the dynamic, temporal nature of the virus-host interplay throughout the ~24-hour HIV replication cycle. The authors aim to bridge this gap by simultaneously analyzing transcriptomic, proteomic, and phosphoproteomic changes over multiple time points during HIV infection, providing a more holistic view of the cellular response.

Methods

The core of this study involves a multi-omics approach applied to HIV-infected and mock-infected SupT1 CD4+ T cells at five distinct time points during the viral replication cycle.

  • Viral Infection and Intermediate Measurement: SupT1 cells were infected with an HIV-GFP vector. Viral replication was tracked by measuring intermediate products (early/late reverse transcription products, integrated viral DNA), GFP expression, and p24 release over time.
  • Multi-Omics Data Generation:
    • Transcriptomics: RNA-Seq was used to measure gene expression.
  • Proteomics & Phosphoproteomics: SILAC (Stable Isotope Labeling by Amino acids in Cell culture) mass spectrometry was employed to quantify protein and phosphoprotein abundance.
  • Data Analysis & Clustering: A key methodological contribution is the development and application of a Gaussian mixed-effects model, implemented in the R/Bioconductor package TMixClust. This model was used to cluster host genes based on their temporal expression patterns across the different omics levels, identifying distinct "proteo-transcriptomic signatures" of HIV infection.
  • Functional Analysis: Enriched Reactome pathways and curated HIV-specific gene sets were used to understand the biological roles of the identified host genes.
  • Resource Development: A dedicated R/Shiny application, PEACHi2.0, was created to make the data and findings accessible to researchers.

Datasets

The study generated and analyzed the following datasets:

  • Transcriptomic data: RNA-Seq data from mock- and HIV-infected SupT1 cells at 6h, 12h, 18h, 24h, and 30h post-infection.
  • Proteomic data: SILAC-based quantitative proteomics data from mock- and HIV-infected SupT1 cells at 2h, 6h, 12h, 18h, and 24h post-infection.
  • Phosphoproteomic data: SILAC-based quantitative phosphoproteomics data from mock- and HIV-infected SupT1 cells at 2h, 6h, 12h, 18h, and 24h post-infection.

The raw data has been deposited in NCBI's Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) under accession number GSE100587 and on the ProteomeXchange database (PRIDE repository) under accession number PXD005810.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic, Multi-Omics View is Essential: The study strongly emphasizes that a single time point or single omics layer is insufficient to capture the complexity of HIV-host interactions. The temporal dynamics revealed novel insights not apparent in static analyses.
  • Host Response is Multi-faceted: HIV infection triggers coordinated changes across RNA, protein, and phosphorylation levels, affecting diverse cellular processes like signal transduction, metabolism, cell cycle, and immune responses.
  • Novel Host Factors Identified: Beyond confirming known HIV dependency and inhibitory factors, the analysis uncovered a significant number of previously uncharacterized host genes with dynamic expression patterns during infection, suggesting new targets for therapeutic intervention.
  • Protein-Level Modulation Dominates: A striking observation is that many host genes show differential expression at the protein level without significant changes at the RNA level, implying direct post-transcriptional or post-translational regulation by HIV.
  • PEACHi2.0 as a Valuable Resource: The creation of an interactive web application (PEACHi2.0) is a significant contribution, providing a searchable catalog of dynamic host responses that can accelerate future research in HIV-host interactions.

Key Results

  • Proteo-transcriptomic Signature: A signature of 388 host genes was identified as being specifically involved in HIV-1 replication, showing coordinated changes across RNA and protein levels.
  • Gene Overlap: Out of 13,057 detected genes at the RNA level and 3,613 proteins at the protein level, 3,455 genes had measurements at both levels. Only 568 genes had measurements across all three omics levels (RNA, protein, phosphoprotein).
  • Previously Reported Factors: 130 out of 388 (33.5%) identified candidate factors were previously reported in the literature, validating the approach. This included well-known factors like CD4, NFKB1, and CDK9.
  • Novel Factors: The study identified new candidate factors, including DEAD-box helicases, zinc-finger proteins, and kinesins, not previously linked to HIV replication.
  • Differential Expression Patterns:
    • RNA Level: Primarily involved signal transduction pathways.
  • Protein & Phosphoprotein Levels: Enriched in pathways related to immune system, metabolism, cell cycle, and gene expression.
  • Genes Differentially Expressed Across All Three Levels: Four genes (HIST1H1B, LIMA1, TFAP4, and UNG) were found to be differentially expressed at all three omics levels, suggesting critical roles in the HIV life cycle.
  • Phosphoproteomics Limitations: While phosphoproteomics provided insights, a high amount of missing values and noise limited its use for defining proteo-transcriptomic signatures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Time Points: The study acknowledges that the relatively small number of time points (5 per gene) limits the ability to distinguish very fine-grained temporal regulation patterns, especially early vs. late responses. More time points, as used in some previous studies, could provide more robust temporal resolution.
  • GFP vs. HIV: The use of an HIV-GFP vector means that observed changes could be due to either HIV infection or GFP expression, and the study could not fully dissociate these effects.
  • Phosphoproteomics Data Quality: The phosphoproteomic data suffered from missing values and noise, hindering its integration into comprehensive proteo-transcriptomic signatures. The authors suggest alternative techniques like TMT (tandem mass tagging) or combining different proteomic methods for better coverage.
  • Validation Needed: The identified host candidates require further experimental validation and functional analyses to precisely understand their roles and interactions with HIV.
  • Treatment Strategies: The authors suggest that understanding and interfering with these identified host-viral interactions could lead to novel treatment strategies. The PEACHi2.0 platform is highlighted as a valuable tool for selecting candidates for such follow-up studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Throughout the HIV-1 replication cycle, complex host-pathogen interactions take place in the infected cell, leading to the production of new virions. The virus modulates the host cellular machinery in order to support its life cycle, while counteracting intracellular defense mechanisms. We investigated the dynamic host response to HIV-1 infection by systematically measuring transcriptomic, proteomic, and phosphoproteomic expression changes in infected and uninfected SupT1 CD4+ T cells at five time points of the viral replication process. By means of a Gaussian mixed-effects model implemented in the new R/Bioconductor package TMixClust, we clustered host genes based on their temporal expression patterns. We identified a proteo-transcriptomic gene expression signature of 388 host genes specific for HIV-1 replication. Comprehensive functional analyses of these genes confirmed the previously described roles of some of the genes and revealed novel key virus-host interactions affecting multiple molecular processes within the host cell, including signal transduction, metabolism, cell cycle, and immune system. The results of our analysis are accessible through a freely available, dedicated and user-friendly R/Shiny application, called PEACHi2.0. This resource constitutes a catalogue of dynamic host responses to HIV-1 infection that provides a basis for a more comprehensive understanding of virus-host interactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{golumbeanu2019proteo,
  author = {Monica Golumbeanu and Sébastien Desfarges and Céline Hernandez and Manfredo Quadroni and Sylvie Rato and Pejman Mohammadi and Amalio Telenti and Niko Beerenwinkel and Angela Ciuffi},
  title = {{Proteo-Transcriptomic Dynamics of Cellular Response to HIV-1 Infection}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-36135-3},
}
Figure