PROTEIN FOLDS IN THE WORM GENOME

Mark Gerstein, Jimmy Lin, Hédi Hegyi1999 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive survey of protein folds within the C. elegans (worm) genome, revealing approximately 250 distinct protein folds. By comparing these folds to those found in yeast and E. coli, the study highlights the evolutionary relationships between these organisms and identifies unique worm-specific folds likely involved in multicellular functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the C. elegans genome was recently sequenced, researchers sought to understand the diversity and distribution of protein structures (folds) within it. This is crucial because protein folds, rather than just amino acid sequences, are often the fundamental units of protein function and evolution. Previous studies had analyzed protein families and sequences, but a large-scale, systematic analysis of protein folds in the worm genome was needed to complement these efforts and provide insights into its unique biological characteristics, especially in the context of multicellularity. The paper also aimed to identify membrane proteins, a class of proteins critical for cellular function but often challenging to predict accurately.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of computational methods to identify protein folds in the worm genome. The primary approach involved pairwise and multiple-sequence comparison methods, specifically using FASTA and PSI-blast. These algorithms compare the amino acid sequences of proteins to known protein structures.

  • PSI-blast was favored for its ability to detect more distant evolutionary relationships, which is crucial for identifying a broader range of folds. Specific parameters were chosen to minimize false positives, a critical concern in large-scale genomic analyses.
  • FASTA was used for simpler pairwise comparisons.
  • For membrane protein identification, they utilized a GES-based hydrophobicity scale to predict transmembrane (TM) segments. A "MinH criteria" was developed, using a cutoff value derived from the distribution of hydrophobicity scores, to distinguish between "sure" and "marginal" membrane proteins.

Datasets

  • SCOP (Structural Classification of Proteins) database: Version 1.39 of SCOP was used as the reference for known protein folds and structural domains.
  • Worm genome: Approximately 19,000 predicted ORFs (Open Reading Frames) from the C. elegans genome were analyzed.
  • Other model organism genomes: Data from yeast (S. cerevisiae) and E. coli were used for comparative analysis.
  • nrdb90: This database was used for training fold templates for PSI-blast.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Folds as evolutionary markers: The study reinforces the idea that protein folds are more conserved than sequences, allowing for the identification of evolutionary relationships even when sequences have diverged significantly.
  • Multicellularity's impact on protein evolution: The identification of 36 "worm-only" folds strongly suggests that multicellularity has driven the evolution of novel protein structures to support complex cellular communication and organismal functions.
  • Domain combinations reveal functional modules: The analysis of frequently co-occurring domain combinations provides clues about how proteins are built and how different functional units are assembled to create complex molecular machinery.
  • Membrane protein prevalence in worms: The significantly higher proportion of certain types of membrane proteins (specifically those with seven transmembrane helices) in the worm genome compared to microbial genomes points to their specialized roles in intercellular communication and signaling in metazoans.

Key Results

  • Approximately 250 protein folds were identified in the worm genome, matching around 8,000 domains within 4,500 ORFs. This represents about 32 matches per fold, involving a quarter of the total worm ORFs.
  • The worm genome shares more folds with yeast (206 folds) than with E. coli (185 folds), consistent with their phylogenetic relatedness.
  • 36 folds appear to be unique to the worm genome when compared to yeast and E. coli, many of which are implicated in multicellular functions.
  • The immunoglobulin (Ig) fold is the most common fold in the worm genome.
  • About 21% (3964 ORFs) of the worm genome are classified as "sure" membrane proteins, with an additional 31% (5849 ORFs) classified as "marginal."
  • A notable peak in the distribution of membrane proteins in the worm genome occurs at seven transmembrane helices, a pattern not observed in microbial genomes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Database dependency: The precise "fold counts" are contingent on the evolving state of structural databases (like SCOP) and gene-prediction methods. The authors acknowledge this by providing a regularly updated analysis online.
  • False positives/negatives: While efforts were made to minimize false positives, the inherent limitations of sequence-based prediction methods mean some assignments might be incorrect, and some folds might be missed.
  • Functional annotation: The paper focuses on structural classification. While some functional implications are discussed (e.g., for unique folds), detailed functional annotation for all identified folds remains a future task.
  • Experimental validation: The identified ORFs with unknown folds are suggested as promising targets for experimental investigation in structural genomics, implying that computational predictions require experimental validation.
  • Further exploration of unique folds: The authors suggest that the 36 unique worm-specific folds are prime candidates for further investigation into their roles in metazoan-specific functions.
  • Membrane protein refinement: The distinction between "sure" and "marginal" membrane proteins highlights the ongoing challenge of accurately predicting membrane protein topology and function, suggesting room for improved prediction algorithms.

Summary updated

Abstract

We survey the protein folds in the worm genome, using pairwise and multiple-sequence comparison methods (i.e. FASTA and PSI-blast). Overall, we find that approximately 250 folds match approximately 8000 domains in approximately 4500 ORFs, about 32 matches per fold involving a quarter of the total worm ORFs. We compare the folds in the worm genome to those in other model organisms, in particular yeast and E. coli, and find that the worm shares more folds with the phylogenetically closer yeast than with E. coli. There appear to be 36 folds unique to the worm compared to these two model organisms, and many of these are obviously implicated in aspects of multicellularity. The most common fold in the worm genome is the immunoglobulin fold, and many of the common folds are repeated in various combinations and permutations in multidomain proteins. In addition, an approach is presented for the identification of "sure" and "marginal" membrane proteins. When applied to the worm genome, this reveals a much greater relative prevalence of proteins with seven transmembrane helices in comparison to the other completely sequenced genomes, which are not of metazoans. Combining these analyses with some other simple filters allows one to identify ORFs that potentially code for soluble proteins of unknown fold, which may be promising targets for experimental investigation in structural genomics. A regularly updated worm fold analysis will be available from bioinfo.mbb.yale.edu/genome/worm.
BibTeX
@misc{gerstein1999protein,
  author = {Mark Gerstein and Jimmy Lin and Hédi Hegyi},
  title = {{PROTEIN FOLDS IN THE WORM GENOME}},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1142/9789814447331\_0004},
}

Loading related content...

Figure