Protein dynamics enables phosphorylation of buried residues in Cdk2/Cyclin A-bound p27

João Henriques, Kresten Lindorff‐LarsenbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how kinases phosphorylate residues buried within protein structures, a common but mechanistically puzzling phenomenon. Using advanced molecular dynamics simulations, the researchers reveal that transient "breathing" or exposure of these buried sites is crucial for kinase access, and this dynamic process can also couple the modification of one site to the exposure of another.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Protein phosphorylation is a fundamental post-translational modification that regulates a vast array of cellular processes. While many phosphorylation sites are found in flexible, disordered regions of proteins, a significant number are located within the core of folded protein structures, making them seemingly inaccessible to kinases. This raises a critical question: how do kinases gain access to and modify these buried residues? Furthermore, what are the structural and dynamic consequences of phosphorylating such sites, especially when multiple phosphorylation events occur in sequence? The study focuses on the p27 protein, a cell cycle regulator, when bound to its partners Cdk2 and Cyclin A, as a model system to explore these questions.

Methods

The core of this research relies on enhanced sampling molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Specifically, the authors employed parallel-bias metadynamics simulations. This technique is designed to overcome the limitations of standard MD by accelerating the exploration of rare conformational events, such as the transient exposure of buried residues. They defined collective variables (CVs) that specifically capture the interactions and positioning of the key tyrosine residues (Y88 and Y74) within the Cdk2 active site. By biasing these CVs, they could effectively sample the equilibrium between the dominant buried state and the transiently exposed state. The simulations were performed using state-of-the-art physics-based protein models (force fields), including AMBER ff99SB-disp and CHARMM36m.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes the crystal structure of the ternary complex Cdk2/Cyclin A/p27 (PDB entry 1JSU) as the starting point for their simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Exposure is Key: The central idea is that buried phosphorylation sites are not static. Instead, they undergo transient, dynamic "breathing" motions that expose them to the solvent and, consequently, to kinases. This challenges the notion of a purely static, locked structure for kinase accessibility.
  • Coupled Phosphorylation: The phosphorylation of one site (Y88) can directly influence the accessibility of another site (Y74). This suggests a mechanism for sequential phosphorylation events that is orchestrated by protein dynamics rather than just the presence of multiple sites.
  • Role of Neighboring Residues: The study highlights the importance of residues flanking the phosphorylation site, such as F87, in controlling the stability of the buried state and influencing the dynamics of exposure.
  • Fine-Tuning Regulation: The equilibrium between the buried (inhibited) and exposed (potentially active) states of p27 is crucial. Too much time in the buried state would hinder phosphorylation, while too much time in the exposed state could lead to inefficient inhibition.

Key Results

  • Transient Exposure of Y88: Standard MD simulations confirmed that Y88 remains buried in the Cdk2 active site. However, enhanced sampling metadynamics simulations revealed a reversible equilibrium between a dominant buried state and a transiently exposed state for Y88.
  • Y74 Exposure Coupled to Y88 Phosphorylation: Upon phosphorylation of Y88 (leading to its departure from the active site), the Y74 residue becomes more easily exposed. This suggests a dynamic coupling mechanism where the modification of Y88 primes Y74 for potential subsequent modification.
  • Structural Basis for Coupling: The researchers identified the intermolecular β-sheet formed between p27 and Cdk2 as a key structural element mediating this coupling. The disruption of this β-sheet upon Y88 phosphorylation appears to facilitate Y74 exposure.
  • Free Energy Estimates: While quantitative comparisons were challenging due to convergence issues, the estimated free energy difference between bound and exposed states for Y88 was found to be relatively small (≈ 1.7 kcal/mol), consistent with experimental observations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that achieving full convergence in their metadynamics simulations was challenging, which limits the strength of quantitative conclusions drawn from the free-energy landscapes. They suggest that future work could benefit from a more direct integration of experimental data (like NMR chemical shifts or kinetic data) with simulations, although this is hampered by the complexity of forward models. The study also points towards the broader applicability of this "transient exposure" mechanism for regulating phosphorylation of buried residues in other proteins.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Proteins carry out a wide range of functions that are tightly regulated in space and time. Protein phosphorylation is the most common post-translation modification of proteins and plays key roles in the regulation of many biological processes. The finding that many phosphorylated residues are not solvent exposed in the unphosphorylated state opens several questions for understanding the mechanism that underlies phosphorylation and how phosphorylation may affect protein structures. First, since kinases need access to the phosphorylated residue, how do such buried residues become modified? Second, once phosphorylated, what are the structural effects of phosphorylation of buried residues and do they lead to changed conformational dynamics. We have used the ternary complex between p27, Cdk2 and Cyclin A to study these questions using enhanced sampling molecular dynamics simulations. In line with previous NMR and single-molecule fluorescence experiments we observe transient exposure of Tyr88 in p27, even in its unphosphorylated state. Once Tyr88 is phosphorylated, we observe a coupling to a second site, thus making Tyr74 more easily exposed, and thereby the target for a second phosphorylation step. Our observations provide atomic details on how protein dynamics plays a role in modulating multi-site phosphorylation in p27, thus supplementing previous experimental observations. More generally, we discuss how the observed phenomenon of transient exposure of buried residues may play a more general role in regulating protein function. Significance Statement Protein phosphorylation is a common post-translation modification and is carried out by kinases. While many phosphorylation sites are located in disordered regions of proteins or in loops, a surprisingly large number of modification sites are buried inside folded domains. This observation led us to ask the question of how kinases gain access to such buried residues. We used the complex between p27, a regulator of cell cycle progression, and Cyclin-dependent kinase 2/Cyclin A to study this problem. We hypothesized that transient exposure of buried tyrosines in p27 to the solvent would make them accessible to kinases, explaining how buried residues get modified. We provide an atomic-level description of these dynamic processes revealing how protein dynamics plays a role in regulation.
BibTeX
@misc{henriques2020protein,
  author = {João Henriques and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen},
  title = {{Protein dynamics enables phosphorylation of buried residues in Cdk2/Cyclin A-bound p27}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.03.12.989517},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure