Protecting quantum entanglement between error-corrected logical qubits

Weizhou Cai, Xianghao Mu, Weiting Wang, Jie Zhou, Yuwei Ma, Xiaoxuan Pan, Ziyue Hua, Xinyu Liu, Guangming Xue, Haifeng Yu, Haiyan Wang, Yipu Song, Chang‐Ling Zou, Luyan SunarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Entanglement represents one of the most important conceptual advances in physics during the last century and is also one of the most essential resources in quantum information science. However, entanglement is fragile and its potential advantages in applications are hindered by decoherence in practice. Here, we experimentally realize entangled logical qubits (ELQ) with a bosonic quantum module by encoding quantum information into spatially separated microwave modes. The entanglement is protected by repetitive quantum error correction, and the coherence time of the purified ELQ via error detection is improved by 45% compared with the unprotected ELQ and exceeds that of the entangled physical qubits. In addition, violation of the Bell inequality by logical qubits is demonstrated for the first time with the measured Bell signal B=2.250±0.019 after purification, surpassing the classical bound by 13 standard deviations. The protected ELQ could be applied in future explorations of quantum foundations and applications of quantum networks.

Introduction

Quantum entanglement is the backbone of quantum computing and secure communication, but it is notoriously fragile. In real-world environments, qubits constantly interact with their surroundings, leading to decoherence—a process where quantum information leaks out and entanglement vanishes. To build a scalable quantum computer, researchers utilize logical qubits. Unlike a single physical qubit (such as an individual atom or photon), a logical qubit is encoded across a larger system to allow for Quantum Error Correction (QEC). While QEC has been shown to protect single logical qubits, maintaining entanglement between two logical qubits during active correction remains a significant challenge. This work addresses that challenge by demonstrating high-fidelity entangled states between two spatially separated logical modules protected by constant noise suppression.

Experimental Platform and Methods

The research team utilized a hardware-efficient circuit Quantum Electrodynamics (cQED) platform. The setup consists of two 3D coaxial microwave cavities, which serve as storage for the logical qubits, connected by a central bus resonator and auxiliary transmon qubits for control and entanglement generation.

Conceptual illustration of logical qubit entanglement and the experimental cQED setup.

Instead of using multiple physical qubits to form one logical qubit, the researchers employed bosonic binomial codes. This approach encodes information into the number of photons (Fock states) within the microwave cavities. Specifically, they used even-parity states for the logical basis, allowing the system to detect the most common error: the loss of a single photon, which flips the parity to odd. They implemented repetitive, autonomous error correction (AQEC). When a photon is lost, the system detects the parity change and uses a control qubit to "reset" the logical state back to the correct subspace without requiring complex external computing. To further enhance performance, an error-detection strategy called purification was used, post-selecting data from trials where no uncorrectable errors were detected.

Key Results

The experimental results demonstrate that the overhead of error correction can successfully protect quantum correlations. One of the most significant findings was that the purified logical entanglement lasted longer than the entanglement between raw physical qubits, proving that QEC can indeed surpass the "physical limit."

Bell signal measurements showing violation of the classical bound (B > 2) for logical qubits.

Major milestones achieved include:

  • Coherence Improvement: The coherence time of the purified entangled logical qubits (ELQ) improved by 45% compared to unprotected qubits.
  • First Logical Bell Violation: The team measured a Bell signal of $B = 2.250 \pm 0.019$ after purification. This surpasses the classical limit of 2 by 13 standard deviations, providing definitive proof of protected entanglement at the logical level.
  • Entanglement Lifetime: The "negativity" (a measure of entanglement) remained above zero for significantly longer with QEC, extending the entanglement lifetime from approximately 75 $\mu$s to over 100 $\mu$s.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While this experiment represents a major milestone, several hurdles remain for large-scale implementation. Currently, the fully corrected states (without post-selection) are still limited by the infidelities of the recovery operations. Reaching a true "break-even" point where correction is always superior to no correction will require faster and more precise hardware. Additionally, future work must extend these techniques to multipartite entanglement involving three or more logical qubits and develop fully fault-tolerant state preparation methods to ensure errors do not propagate during the initial creation of the entangled state. This research paves the way for robust quantum networks and the continued exploration of quantum foundations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Entanglement represents one of the most important conceptual advances in physics during the last century and is also one of the most essential resources in quantum information science. However, entanglement is fragile and its potential advantages in applications are hindered by decoherence in practice. Here, we experimentally realize entangled logical qubits (ELQ) with a bosonic quantum module by encoding quantum information into spatially separated microwave modes. The entanglement is protected by repetitive quantum error correction, and the coherence time of the purified ELQ via error detection is improved by 45$\%$ compared with the unprotected ELQ and exceeds that of the entangled physical qubits. In addition, violation of the Bell inequality by logical qubits is demonstrated for the first time with the measured Bell signal B=2.250$\pm$0.019 after purification, surpassing the classical bound by 13 standard deviations. The protected ELQ could be applied in future explorations of quantum foundations and applications of quantum networks.
BibTeX
@misc{cai2023protecting,
  author = {Weizhou Cai and Xianghao Mu and Weiting Wang and Jie Zhou and Yuwei Ma and Xiaoxuan Pan and Ziyue Hua and Xinyu Liu and Guangming Xue and Haifeng Yu and Haiyan Wang and Yipu Song and Chang‐Ling Zou and Luyan Sun},
  title = {{Protecting quantum entanglement between error-corrected logical qubits}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.13027},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.13027},
}
Figure