PROSPECTS FOR MEASURING THE MASS OF BLACK HOLES AT HIGH REDSHIFTS WITH RESOLVED KINEMATICS USING GRAVITATIONAL LENSING

Yashar HezavehThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how future telescopes like ALMA can use gravitational lensing to measure the masses of supermassive black holes (SMBHs) in distant galaxies, a feat currently impossible. By leveraging the magnification of lensed galaxies, they show that a significant fraction of these distant SMBHs could be accurately weighed, providing crucial insights into how the SMBH-galaxy relationship evolves over cosmic time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The relationship between the mass of a supermassive black hole (SMBH) at the center of a galaxy and the properties of its host galaxy (like its stellar velocity dispersion, often denoted as $\sigma$) is remarkably tight in the local universe. This correlation suggests a co-evolutionary process, but understanding how this relationship formed and evolved over cosmic history is a major challenge. The most reliable method for measuring SMBH masses locally is by analyzing the resolved kinematics (motion) of gas or stars very close to the black hole. However, this requires extremely high angular resolution, making it impossible for distant galaxies where the SMBH's "sphere of influence" is tiny. Current methods for distant galaxies rely on less direct "virial" techniques, which are limited to active galactic nuclei (AGNs) with broad emission lines and cannot be applied to typical galaxies. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating if new, powerful telescopes can overcome the distance limitation.

Methods

The authors propose using strong gravitational lensing as a natural "cosmic telescope." Gravitational lensing bends light from background sources, magnifying their apparent size and allowing us to see finer details than would otherwise be possible. They combine this with the capabilities of upcoming instruments like the Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) and thirty-meter class optical telescopes, which will offer milli-arcsecond resolution.

Their approach involves:

  • Simulating Lensed Galaxies: They create mock data cubes of gas emission within a source galaxy, then simulate how this emission would appear when lensed by a foreground galaxy.
  • Modeling Gas Kinematics: The simulated gas is modeled with two circular rings, mimicking observed structures in galaxies. The motion of this gas is calculated based on the combined gravitational pull of the galaxy's dark matter, stars, and the central SMBH.
  • Predicting ALMA Observations: They generate synthetic ALMA visibilities (the raw data collected by the telescope) from these simulated lensed cubes, accounting for ALMA's expected resolution and sensitivity.
  • Fisher Information Analysis: To estimate the precision of SMBH mass measurements, they employ the Fisher information formalism. This statistical tool allows them to calculate the expected uncertainties and detection significances for the SMBH mass and other model parameters (like the galaxy's central velocity dispersion) from the simulated ALMA data.
  • Probability Estimation: They run numerous simulations with varying lensing configurations (ellipticity, orientation) to determine the fraction of lensed galaxies that would provide sufficient magnification to resolve the inner gas kinematics and thus enable a reliable SMBH mass measurement.

Datasets

The paper does not use observational datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies entirely on simulated data cubes of lensed galaxies. These simulations are informed by observational properties of galaxies and gas, such as the CO gas flux in Arp 220 and typical velocity dispersions of lensing galaxies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lensing as a Game Changer: Gravitational lensing is not just a curiosity; it's a powerful tool that can overcome the fundamental resolution limitations imposed by distance for studying SMBH physics.
  • ALMA's Potential: ALMA's high angular resolution, combined with lensing, can resolve gas structures as small as 25-50 parsecs in galaxies at redshifts up to z=6. This is crucial because it's within or very near the sphere of influence for SMBHs of $10^8 M_{\odot}$ and above.
  • Beyond AGNs: This method opens the door to measuring SMBH masses in typical galaxies at high redshifts, not just the bright AGNs that dominate current distant SMBH mass samples.
  • Statistical Significance: Even if only a small percentage (15-20%) of strongly lensed galaxies are suitable for these measurements, the sheer number of strong lenses expected from upcoming surveys means we could build a statistically significant sample to study the evolution of the SMBH-galaxy relation.
  • Lens Model Robustness: The study suggests that even with uncertainties in the lensing galaxy's parameters, the SMBH mass measurement significance is not drastically reduced, especially when realistic extended source structures are included in the models.

Key Results

  • With ALMA's milli-arcsecond resolution and gravitational lensing, it's possible to resolve gas kinematics within 25 pc and 50 pc of the central SMBH in approximately 15% and 20% of strongly lensed galaxies, respectively.
  • This resolution allows for the dynamical measurement of SMBH masses $\geq 10^8 M_{\odot}$ at redshifts $z \sim 1-6$.
  • The study estimates that the "yield factor" (the fraction of strongly lensed galaxies suitable for SMBH mass measurements) is around $\eta \sim 0.1$, independent of lens orientation and ellipticity.
  • Monte Carlo simulations indicate that SMBH masses can be detected with high significance (e.g., $\sigma \geq 3$) for gas rings with inclination angles $\geq 15^\circ$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gas Brightness: The method relies on the presence of moderately bright molecular gas at these small radii. If the gas is too faint, measurements will not be possible. This is identified as the largest source of uncertainty.
  • Inclination Angle: While the detection sensitivity doesn't strongly depend on inclination angle above $15^\circ$, lower inclination angles would limit the ability to resolve the velocity gradient.
  • Dynamical Coldness: The paper acknowledges that some galaxies may not be dynamically "cold," which could limit the application of this method.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that resolving velocity gradients at larger radii (beyond the sphere of influence) might also yield robust SMBH mass measurements, potentially allowing for the study of even lower-mass SMBHs at high redshifts. They also highlight that the capabilities of thirty-meter class optical telescopes, in addition to ALMA, will be crucial for these future studies. The paper also implicitly points to the need for robust target selection strategies for these high-resolution follow-up observations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Application of the most robust method of measuring black hole masses, spatially resolved kinematics of gas and stars, is presently limited to nearby galaxies. The Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) and thirty meter class telescopes (the Thirty Meter Telescope, the Giant Magellan Telescope, and the European Extremely Large Telescope) with milli-arcsecond resolution are expected to extend such measurements to larger distances. Here, we study the possibility of exploiting the angular magnification provided by strong gravitational lensing to measure black hole masses at high redshifts (z~ 1-6), using resolved gas kinematics with these instruments. We show that in ~15% and ~20% of strongly lensed galaxies, the inner 25 and 50 pc could be resolved, allowing the mass of ~$10^8 M_{\odot}$ black holes to be dynamically measured with ALMA, if moderately bright molecular gas is present at these small radii. Given the large number of strong lenses discovered in current millimeter surveys and future optical surveys, this fraction could constitute a statistically significant population for studying the evolution of the M-$\sigma$ relation at high redshifts.
BibTeX
@article{hezaveh2014prospects,
  author = {Yashar Hezaveh},
  title = {{PROSPECTS FOR MEASURING THE MASS OF BLACK HOLES AT HIGH REDSHIFTS WITH RESOLVED KINEMATICS USING GRAVITATIONAL LENSING}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1088/2041-8205/791/2/l41},
}
Figure