Abstract
We study in detail the ability of the nominal configuration of the IceCube neutrino telescope (with 80 strings) to probe the parameter space of the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (CMSSM) favoured by current collider and cosmological data. Adopting conservative assumptions about the galactic halo model and the expected experiment performance, we find that IceCube has a probability between 2% and 12% of achieving a $5\sigma$ detection of dark matter annihilation in the Sun, depending on the choice of priors for the scalar and gaugino masses and on the astrophysical assumptions. We identify the most important annihilation channels in the CMSSM parameter space and demonstrate that assuming a single annihilation channel can lead to large systematic errors. Furthermore, we find that ~66% of the CMSSM parameter space violates the equilibrium condition between capture and annihilation in the Sun. Finally, we conclude that if IceCube detects a neutrino flux while direct detection experiments do not find a signal above a spin-independent cross section $\sigma_{SI}^p > 5 \times 10^{-9}$ pb, the CMSSM will be strongly disfavoured.
Introduction
The search for Dark Matter often focuses on Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs). One of the most promising avenues for indirect detection is the observation of high-energy neutrinos produced by WIMP annihilation in the center of the Sun. As WIMPs from the galactic halo pass through the Sun, they can lose energy through scattering with solar nuclei, become gravitationally trapped, and eventually accumulate in the solar core.
This paper provides a rigorous statistical assessment of the IceCube neutrino telescope’s potential to discover dark matter within the framework of the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (CMSSM). By replacing simplified "grid scans" with a robust Bayesian statistical framework, the study determines how much of the favored CMSSM space IceCube can realistically probe.
Methodology
The researchers employed a sophisticated Bayesian inference approach to scan the 8-dimensional parameter space of the CMSSM and the Standard Model.
Scanning and Physics Tools
To explore the complex and fragmented likelihood surfaces of the CMSSM, the authors used MultiNest, a nested sampling algorithm implemented in the SuperBayeS code. This approach is significantly more efficient than traditional Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. The statistical framework was linked with DarkSUSY to calculate dark matter properties and WimpSim to simulate neutrino production and propagation—including three-flavor oscillations—from the Sun to the Earth.
Statistical Priors
To ensure the results were robust and not merely artifacts of initial assumptions, the study compared two types of priors:
- Log Priors: These favor lower mass scales.
- Flat Priors: These provide a different weighting across the mass spectrum.
The CMSSM was further constrained using then-current data from WMAP (relic density), LEP (Higgs and sparticle mass limits), B-physics observables, and the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon.
Key Insights: Beyond Simplified Assumptions
The "Single Channel" Fallacy
Experimental analyses often simplify the WIMP annihilation process by assuming particles annihilate into a single pair of final-state particles, such as $b\bar{b}$ or $W^+W^-$. However, this research demonstrates that in the CMSSM, the signal is almost always a mixture of channels. Assuming a single channel when the reality is a mixture can lead to systematic errors in the inferred annihilation cross-section by a factor of up to 40. The study identified the $W^+W^-$ final state as the "least biased" single-channel approximation, though it remains imperfect.
The Equilibrium Condition
A standard assumption in indirect detection is that the rate of WIMP capture in the Sun equals the rate of annihilation (equilibrium). The authors found that approximately 66% of the CMSSM parameter space violates this condition. Consequently, the expected neutrino signal is often much weaker than equilibrium-based models suggest, particularly in regions where the capture rate is low.
Results and Discovery Potential
Discovery Probability
Under the nominal 80-string configuration of IceCube, the probability of a $5\sigma$ discovery varies based on the statistical priors used:
- Log Priors: 1.7% to 4.4% probability.
- Flat Priors: Up to 12.5% probability.
The Focus Point Region
IceCube is most sensitive to the "focus point" region of the CMSSM, characterized by high scalar and gaugino masses. This is a significant finding because much of this region lies beyond the reach of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), making neutrino telescopes a vital complementary tool for discovery.
Cross-Correlation with Direct Detection
The paper proposes a powerful method for model testing through cross-correlation. If IceCube detects a high-significance neutrino flux from the Sun, but direct detection experiments (searching for WIMP-nucleus recoils) fail to find a signal above a spin-independent cross-section of $\sigma_{SI}^p \gtrsim 7 \times 10^{-9}$ pb, the CMSSM would be essentially ruled out under standard astrophysical assumptions.
Limitations and Future Outlook
The primary limitation of the nominal IceCube configuration is its energy threshold (~50 GeV), which makes it less sensitive to regions like the "stau-coannihilation" or "h-pole" regions where the neutrino spectrum is "soft."
The authors highlight the DeepCore extension—a denser sub-array within IceCube—as a critical development. By lowering the energy threshold to approximately 10 GeV, DeepCore significantly boosts the probability of detecting WIMPs that annihilate into $b\bar{b}$ pairs, effectively opening up larger portions of the CMSSM parameter space for exploration.
Summary updated