Prospects for constraining the Yukawa gravity with pulsars around Sagittarius A*

Yiming Dong, Lijing Shao, Zexin Hu, Xueli Miao, Ziming WangJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how precisely timing pulsars near Sagittarius A (Sgr A), a supermassive black hole, can constrain theories of gravity beyond Einstein's General Relativity, specifically Yukawa gravity. By simulating realistic pulsar timing data, the study predicts that such observations could significantly improve current limits on the strength and range of this alternative gravitational interaction, potentially limiting the mass of the hypothetical graviton.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

General Relativity (GR) has passed numerous stringent tests, but phenomena like dark matter and dark energy suggest it might be incomplete. Modified gravity theories, such as those involving massive gravitons (Yukawa gravity), offer potential solutions. Yukawa gravity introduces a short-range modification to the standard inverse-square law of gravity, characterized by a strength parameter ($\alpha$) and a range parameter ($\Lambda$). Testing this theory requires observations across a wide range of length scales. While previous tests have been conducted using planetary orbits, geophysical experiments, and even stars around Sgr A, there's a gap in our ability to probe Yukawa gravity at intermediate to large scales (10¹-10⁴ AU) and in strong gravitational fields. This paper proposes using pulsars orbiting Sgr A as a novel probe to fill this gap, leveraging their extreme stability and the unique environment around a supermassive black hole.

Methods

The core of this research lies in numerical simulations of pulsar timing. The authors developed a timing model that incorporates the first post-Newtonian (PN) corrections to GR, along with the modified gravitational potential from Yukawa gravity. This model is used to generate synthetic "times of arrival" (TOAs) for pulsar signals, mimicking real observational data.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Orbital Dynamics: The acceleration of a pulsar around Sgr A* is calculated using a modified Yukawa potential, accounting for both Newtonian gravity and the Yukawa modification, along with first-order PN corrections.
  • Time Delay Effects: The simulated TOAs account for standard relativistic effects like Römer delay, Shapiro delay, and Einstein delay.
  • Parameter Estimation: To extract constraints on the Yukawa gravity parameters ($\alpha$ and $\Lambda$), the authors employ the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM) and the Derivative Approximation for Likelihoods (DALI) methods. These statistical techniques allow them to estimate the uncertainties in the measured parameters based on the simulated timing data.
  • Realistic Simulation: The simulations use realistic parameters for Sgr A* and a hypothetical pulsar, including a timing accuracy of 100 $\mu$s and 960 TOAs over 20 years, reflecting the capabilities of future telescopes like the Square Kilometre Array (SKA).

Datasets

The paper does not use any pre-existing observational datasets for its primary analysis. Instead, it relies on:

  • Simulated Data: The authors generate synthetic pulsar timing data based on a theoretical model of a pulsar orbiting Sgr A*.
  • Fiducial Parameters: They use a set of parameters for an "S2-like" pulsar, inspired by known stellar orbits around Sgr A, and specific values for Sgr A's mass. These are used to generate the simulated data and to test the parameter estimation methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unique Observational Window: Pulsars around Sgr A* offer a unique opportunity to test Yukawa gravity in a strong-field regime and at length scales (10¹-10⁴ AU) that are difficult to probe with other astrophysical or laboratory experiments.
  • Breaking Degeneracy: The authors propose that when the characteristic length scale of the pulsar-SMBH system is comparable to the range of the Yukawa interaction ($\Lambda$), the degeneracy between the strength ($\alpha$) and range ($\Lambda$) parameters can be broken, allowing for simultaneous measurement of both.
  • Graviton Mass Limits: The study demonstrates that timing pulsars around Sgr A* can provide tighter constraints on the graviton mass ($m_g$) than current methods, potentially reaching $m_g \lesssim 10^{-24}$ eV/c².
  • Pulsar Timing Precision: The high rotational stability of pulsars, combined with advanced timing technology and sensitive telescopes, allows for much higher precision measurements than those achievable with stellar observations, leading to improved gravity tests.

Key Results

The simulations predict that an S2-like pulsar observed for 20 years with a timing accuracy of 100 $\mu$s can achieve the following:

  • Constraints on $\alpha$: For Yukawa interaction ranges $\Lambda$ between 10¹ and 10⁴ AU, the strength parameter $|\alpha|$ can be constrained to be between 10⁻⁸ and 10⁻⁶. This significantly shrinks the parameter space compared to existing experiments.
  • Constraints on $m_g$: The upper limit on the graviton mass can be pushed down to $m_g \lesssim 10^{-24}$ eV/c².
  • Simultaneous Measurement: In cases where $\Lambda$ is comparable to the pulsar's orbital semi-major axis, the study shows the potential to simultaneously measure both $\alpha$ and $\Lambda$ with relative uncertainties of about 1.5% and 0.48%, respectively, for a specific fiducial choice.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pulsar Detection: The primary limitation is the current lack of detected pulsars in the immediate vicinity of Sgr A*. The study assumes the existence of such pulsars, which are predicted by theory and are targets for future telescopes like the SKA.
  • Timing Model Complexity: The current timing model is a simplified version. A more complete model would need to account for additional relativistic effects and environmental factors around Sgr A*, which could further improve constraints.
  • Orbital Parameter Dependence: The precision of the constraints on $\alpha$ and $m_g$ is shown to depend on the pulsar's orbital period and eccentricity. Some combinations, particularly those with high eccentricity and long orbital periods, can lead to "potholes" in the constraint curves due to the absorption of residuals by other model parameters (like the initial rotation number $N_0$).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future observations with next-generation telescopes like the SKA, coupled with improved timing models and the detection of suitable pulsars, will be crucial for realizing these predicted constraints. Deeper understanding of the Sgr A* environment is also needed for more accurate modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The discovery of radio pulsars (PSRs) around the supermassive black hole (SMBH) in our Galactic Center (GC), Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), will have significant implications for tests of gravity. In this paper, we predict restrictions on the parameters of the Yukawa gravity by timing a pulsar around Sgr A* with a variety of orbital parameters. Based on a realistic timing accuracy of the times of arrival (TOAs), σ TOA = 100 μ s, and using a number of 960 TOAs in a 20-yr observation, our numerical simulations show that the PSR-SMBH system will improve current tests of the Yukawa gravity when the range of the Yukawa interaction varies between 10 1 –10 4 AU, and it can limit the graviton mass to be m g ≲ 10 -24 eV/ c 2 .
BibTeX
@article{dong2022prospects,
  author = {Yiming Dong and Lijing Shao and Zexin Hu and Xueli Miao and Ziming Wang},
  title = {{Prospects for constraining the Yukawa gravity with pulsars around Sagittarius A*}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2022/11/051},
}
Figure