Abstract
Higher meat and protein intakes have been associated with increased body weight in adults, but studies evaluating body composition in adolescents are scarce. This study investigated the prospective associations of meat intake at age 10 with body composition at age 15 using data from the GINIplus and LISAplus birth cohorts (N = 1,610). In males, higher poultry intake was associated with higher fat mass index (FMI) [$β = 0.278, p = 0.046$], while higher red and total meat intakes were associated with higher fat-free mass index (FFMI) [$β = 0.333, p = 0.022$ and $β = 0.386, p = 0.007$, respectively]. These associations were significantly weaker in females, suggesting that the impact of meat consumption on body composition is sex-specific.
Introduction
While high meat intake is often linked to weight gain, "weight" alone does not distinguish between fat mass (adiposity) and fat-free mass (muscle and bone). This distinction is vital during adolescence, a period of rapid physiological change. This study aimed to determine if specific types of meat consumed in late childhood predict the quality of weight gain in adolescence.
Methods
The study followed 1,610 participants from the GINIplus and LISAplus German birth cohorts. Dietary intake was assessed at age 10 using Food Frequency Questionnaires (FFQs), adjusted for total energy intake. At age 15, body composition was measured via Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) to calculate Fat Mass Index (FMI) and Fat-Free Mass Index (FFMI).
Key Findings
The research revealed significant sexual dimorphism in how meat affects body composition.
Results in Males
In boys, different meat types had diverging effects:
- Red and Total Meat: Higher intake at age 10 was prospectively associated with higher FFMI (lean mass) at age 15. Specifically, protein from red meat was strongly linked to increased lean tissue [$β = 0.356, p = 0.014$].
- Poultry: Conversely, higher poultry intake was associated with an increase in FMI (fat mass).
Results in Females
In girls, the associations were generally weaker. Most initial correlations disappeared after adjusting for baseline weight and other confounders, indicating that meat intake may be a less dominant driver of body composition changes in females during this developmental window.
Discussion
The findings suggest that red meat may have an anabolic effect in boys, possibly due to its high concentration of essential amino acids supporting muscle development during puberty. The "poultry paradox"—where white meat is linked to higher fat mass—warrants further investigation into preparation methods (e.g., frying) or fatty acid profiles. The sex differences likely stem from varying hormonal environments and growth patterns between boys and girls.
Conclusion
Public health guidelines should consider that not all meats affect adolescent development equally. While red meat may support lean mass development in boys, poultry intake was linked to higher adiposity. Future research using more precise measures like DEXA is needed to confirm these longitudinal trends.
Summary updated