Prophages in Enterococcal Isolates from Renal Transplant Recipients: Renal Failure Etiologies Promote Selection of Strains

Agnieszka Daca, Tomasz Jarzembowski, Jacek M. Witkowski, Ewa Bryl, Leszek Rutkowski, Alicja Dębska‐ŚlizieńBioMed Research International 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the specific etiology of end-stage renal disease in transplant recipients influences the types of Enterococcus faecalis prophages and the expression of the aggregation substance (ASA) gene. These factors, in turn, appear to select for specific enterococcal strains with altered virulence potential, highlighting a complex interplay between host condition and bacterial adaptation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Enterococcus faecalis, a common commensal bacterium, is increasingly recognized as a significant nosocomial pathogen, particularly in immunocompromised individuals like renal transplant recipients (RTx). Identifying high-risk strains among these patients is challenging, as the distinction between commensal and pathogenic strains, and the factors driving this transition, remain unclear. While virulence traits like adherence and biofilm formation are known to be important, the role of bacteriophages (prophages integrated into the bacterial genome) in enterococcal colonization and pathogenicity is a newer area of investigation. This paper aims to explore how different causes of end-stage renal failure in RTx patients might influence the presence of specific prophages and the expression of the aggregation substance (ASA) gene, a known adherence factor, in E. faecalis isolates.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Prophage Detection: Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) was used to screen for the presence of three specific prophage sequences (ppl, pp4, and pp7) in E. faecalis isolates. This is a standard molecular biology technique for detecting specific DNA sequences.
  • ASA Gene Expression: A novel method, FLOW-FISH (Flow Cytometry-Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization) utilizing a linear locked nucleic acid (LNA) probe, was used to quantify the expression of the ASA gene. This technique allows for the direct measurement of mRNA levels within individual bacterial cells, offering a more precise assessment of gene activity than traditional methods.
  • Biofilm Formation: The ability of the E. faecalis strains to form biofilms was assessed using the crystal violet staining method, a common and straightforward technique for quantifying biofilm biomass.

Datasets

The study utilized two main groups of Enterococcus faecalis isolates:

  • Renal Transplant Recipients (RTx): 19 isolates were collected from the urine and feces of RTx patients hospitalized at the Medical University of Gdańsk. These patients had various causes of end-stage renal failure.
  • Healthy Volunteers: 18 E. faecalis isolates were collected from the urine and feces of healthy individuals, serving as a control group.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing clinical and healthy isolates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prophages as Evolutionary Tools: The paper reinforces the idea that prophages are not just passive genetic passengers but active players in bacterial evolution, potentially conferring new traits that enhance colonization and pathogenicity.
  • Host Condition Selects for Bacterial Traits: The core insight is that the specific underlying cause of renal failure in RTx patients acts as a selective pressure, influencing which E. faecalis strains, characterized by their prophage content and ASA expression, are more likely to colonize.
  • Immunosuppression Favors Prophage-Rich Strains: Immunocompromised RTx patients showed a higher prevalence of prophages in their fecal isolates compared to healthy individuals, suggesting that immunosuppression might create an environment where prophage-carrying strains have a competitive advantage.
  • ADPKD and Unique ASA Expression: Patients with Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease (ADPKD) exhibited a distinct pattern of ASA gene expression, with high levels in planktonic cells but low levels in biofilms, suggesting a complex regulatory response to this specific kidney condition.

Key Results

  • Increased Prophage Prevalence in RTx: Prophages were found more frequently in fecal isolates from immunocompromised RTx patients than in those from healthy volunteers.
  • Prophage Composition Varies by Renal Etiology: The specific types of prophages (ppl, pp4, pp7) present in E. faecalis isolates differed based on the cause of renal failure. For instance, patients with nephritis showed increased levels of ppl and pp4, while ADPKD patients had a higher prevalence of pp7.
  • ASA Gene Expression Differences: A significant difference in ASA gene expression was observed between RTx patients with different renal dysfunctions and healthy individuals. Notably, ADPKD patients showed a roughly threefold higher ASA expression in planktonic cultures compared to other renal failure groups.
  • Biofilm Formation Patterns: Isolates from ADPKD patients tended to form less biofilm compared to other renal disease groups and even healthy controls, suggesting a potential trade-off or specific adaptation strategy.
  • Prophage Profiles Differentiate Groups: The composition of prophages varied significantly across different groups, including healthy volunteers, RTx patients with UTI, and RTx patients without UTI, indicating distinct colonization patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size: The study involved a relatively small number of RTx patients (19) and healthy volunteers (18), which may limit the generalizability of the findings.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study identifies associations between renal etiology, prophage presence, and ASA expression, it does not definitively establish causation. Further in vivo studies are needed to confirm these relationships.
  • In Vitro Focus: The biofilm formation and other virulence assessments were conducted in vitro. The clinical relevance of these findings in the complex in vivo environment of transplant recipients requires further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that strains with low ASA expression in biofilm and/or a pp1(+) pp7(+) phenotype should be considered high-risk strains. Further in vivo analysis is recommended to validate this conclusion and to fully understand the clinical implications of these findings. Investigating the functional impact of specific prophages on E. faecalis virulence in the context of immunosuppression is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

Infections caused by commensal bacteria may be fatal for the patients under immunosuppressive therapy. This results also from difficulty in identification of high risk strains. Enterococcal infections are increasingly frequent but despite many studies on virulence traits, the difference between commensal and pathogenic strains remains unclear. Prophages are newly described as important elements in competition between strains during colonization, as well as pathogenicity of the strains. Here we evaluate a difference in presence of pp4, pp1, and pp7 prophages and ASA (aggregation substance) gene expression in enterococcal isolates from renal transplant recipients (RTx) with different etiology of the end-stage renal failure. Prophages sequence was screened by PCR in strains of Enterococcus faecalis isolated from urine and feces of 19 RTx hospitalized at Medical University of Gdansk and 18 healthy volunteers. FLOW-FISH method with use of linear locked nucleic acid (LNA) probe was used to assess the ASA gene expression. Additionally, ability of biofilm formation was screened by crystal violet staining method. Presence of prophages was more frequent in fecal isolates from immunocompromised patients than in isolates from healthy volunteers. Additionally, both composition of prophages and ASA gene expression were related to the etiology of renal disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daca2014prophages,
  author = {Agnieszka Daca and Tomasz Jarzembowski and Jacek M. Witkowski and Ewa Bryl and Leszek Rutkowski and Alicja Dębska‐Ślizień},
  title = {{Prophages in Enterococcal Isolates from Renal Transplant Recipients: Renal Failure Etiologies Promote Selection of Strains}},
  booktitle = {BioMed Research International},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1155/2014/514689},
}
Figure