Proper time is stochastic time in 2d quantum gravity

J. Ambjørn, R. Loll, Y. Watabiki, W. Westra, Stefan ZohrenarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We show that proper time, when defined in the quantum theory of 2d gravity, becomes identical to the stochastic time associated with the stochastic quantization of space. This observation was first made by Kawai and collaborators in the context of 2d Euclidean quantum gravity, but the relation is even simpler and more transparent in the context of 2d gravity formulated in the framework of CDT (causal dynamical triangulations).

Introduction

In the quest for a theory of quantum gravity, "time" is a notoriously difficult concept. In standard quantum mechanics, time is an external parameter; in general relativity, it is part of the dynamical fabric of space-time itself. When quantizing gravity, defining a consistent notion of time evolution becomes a major hurdle. This paper demonstrates a deep mathematical equivalence in 2D quantum gravity: the "proper time" used to measure the evolution of geometry is identical to the "stochastic time" found in the statistical quantization of space.

The authors focus on a simplified "toy model"—two-dimensional quantum gravity. Specifically, they examine how to handle "topology changes," such as when a single universe branches off into "baby universes." While previous Euclidean models struggled with these transitions, this work utilizes Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT) to provide a transparent look at how time behaves when space itself is allowed to fluctuate and branch.

Methodology

The researchers employ several sophisticated theoretical frameworks to bridge geometry and statistical field theory:

  • Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT): A method of regularizing the path integral of gravity by summing over "triangulated" geometries that respect a global time foliation, thereby preserving causality.
  • String Field Theory (SFT): Often referred to as "third quantization," this allows for the creation and annihilation of entire universes, represented by operators acting on a vacuum.
  • Stochastic Quantization: A technique where a quantum system is viewed as the equilibrium limit of a statistical system evolving under a Langevin equation—a differential equation characterized by a noise term.
  • Matrix Models: A Hermitian matrix model with a cubic potential is used to extract non-perturbative information, showing that the large-$N$ limit maps directly to the continuum physics of 2D gravity.
A 2D triangulation representing a discrete geometry in the CDT framework.

Theoretical Insights

The core contribution of this research is the identification of time equivalence. The geometric "proper time"—the distance between spatial slices—is mathematically indistinguishable from the "stochastic time" used in the Langevin equation. This suggests that the quantum evolution of space-time can be viewed as a random walk in the space of geometries.

The Role of Baby Universes

By relaxing the strict causality of CDT to allow for branching (but not re-merging) of space, the authors introduce a coupling constant $g_s$. This branching acts like a "drift force" in the stochastic model. The inclusion of branching points adds a simple potential term ($-g_s l^2$) to the Hamiltonian. Remarkably, this single term captures the complex dynamics of universes splitting.

A diagram illustrating the branching of a single universe into baby universes, representing a topology change.

Matrix Model Synergy

The paper shows that the Dyson-Schwinger equations derived from string field theory are identical to those of a standard matrix model. This allows the application of well-known matrix tools to solve quantum gravity problems.

Results

The authors achieve several key analytical results:

  1. Analytical Solutions: Explicit, closed-form expressions are derived for the disk amplitude (the probability of a universe vanishing into the vacuum) and the propagator (the evolution of a universe of length $l_1$ into length $l_2$ over time $t$).
  2. Infinite Universe Size: A surprising qualitative result is that once topology changes (branching) are allowed, the "average size" of the universe becomes infinite. In strictly causal models, the universe has a finite average size related to the cosmological constant; branching changes this behavior drastically.
  3. Non-Perturbative Definition: By appealing to stochastic quantization, the authors provide a stable, non-perturbative definition of the theory, even when the underlying potential is "unbounded from below," a common source of mathematical instability in these models.

Discussion and Future Work

While these results provide a "rich structure" for study, they are currently limited to 2D gravity. Our universe is 4D, and while 4D CDT has shown interesting infrared behavior (like de Sitter space), the stochastic time equivalence is much harder to prove in higher dimensions.

Furthermore, the "Generalized CDT" model discussed here allows universes to split but forbids them from re-joining to keep the mathematics tractable. A fully realized theory would need to handle arbitrary merging and splitting (all genus expansions) more robustly. Finally, the physical "source" of the stochastic noise in a gravitational context remains a deep, open question: is the universe's evolution fundamentally noisy, or is this mapping a mathematical coincidence?

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that proper time, when defined in the quantum theory of 2d gravity, becomes identical to the stochastic time associated with the stochastic quantization of space. This observation was first made by Kawai and collaborators in the context of 2d Euclidean quantum gravity, but the relation is even simpler and more transparent in he context of 2d gravity formulated in the framework of CDT (causal dynamical triangulations).
BibTeX
@misc{ambjrn2009proper,
  author = {J. Ambjørn and R. Loll and Y. Watabiki and W. Westra and Stefan Zohren},
  title = {{Proper time is stochastic time in 2d quantum gravity}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0911.4211},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0911.4211},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure