Proper constituent gluon mass as the final piece to construct hybrid mesons

Zi-Xuan Ma, Qi Huang, Liming Wang, Xiaohuang Hu, Y. T. Tan, J. He, Hongxia Huang, Huang, Hong-XiaarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: In this letter, we propose that a proper constituent gluon mass $m_g$=450 MeV can be applied to identify the hybrids composed of quarks and gluons. By investigating the spectra and decay widths of the light hybrids $(q\bar{q}g)$ with $J^P=1^{-+}$, we find the $π_1(1600)$ and $η_1(1855)$ may not be explained as $1^{-+}$ hybrids, simultaneously, and the $η_1(1855)$ observed by BESIII may not be a hybrid. In addition, we predict an existence of a hybrid $η_1(1640)$, which can be verified by searching the $a_1(1260)π$ channel. Moreover, we suggest the $K_1(1270)\bar{K}$ and $K_1(1270)π$ as the golden channels to search for an isospin-0 and an isospin-$\frac{1}{2}$ hybrids, respectively.

Introduction

In the standard model of particle physics, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) describes how quarks and gluons interact. While most observed hadrons are either mesons (a quark and an antiquark) or baryons (three quarks), QCD theoretically allows for "hybrids"—particles where the gluon itself acts as a structural component rather than just a force carrier. Identifying these states is a major goal of modern hadron physics, but the lack of a consistent constituent gluon mass ($m_g$) has long hindered accurate modeling.

Methodology: The Three-Body Hybrid Model

The researchers treated the hybrid meson as a three-body system consisting of a quark, an antiquark, and a constituent gluon ($q\bar{q}g$). Key technical aspects of the study include:

  • Hamiltonian Construction: A potential model was employed including color confinement, One-Gluon Exchange (OGE), and Goldstone Boson Exchange (GBE).
  • Gauss Expansion Method (GEM): This was used to solve the complex three-body Schrödinger equation to find the mass spectra.
  • Decay Width Calculations: Beyond predicting masses, the authors calculated how these particles would decay into other mesons using a transition operator derived from the quark-gluon vertex.
  • Confinement Variations: Three different types of confinement potentials (screened, linear, and square) were tested to ensure the robustness of ground-state predictions.

Key Results: Mass Spectra and the 450 MeV Gluon Mass

The central finding of this work is that setting the constituent gluon mass to $m_g \approx 450$ MeV allows the model to align with both lattice QCD calculations and experimental observations. This value acts as a "universal" parameter that stabilizes ground-state predictions across different confinement models.

Mass spectrum comparison for light hybrids.

As shown in the mass spectrum, the predicted mass for the ground-state isospin-1 hybrid matches the experimental $\pi_1(1600)$ very well. However, the model reveals a conflict regarding the $\eta_1(1855)$ observed by BESIII. The predicted mass for the corresponding $s\bar{s}g$ state is significantly higher than the experimental band, suggesting that the $\eta_1(1855)$ might actually be a different kind of exotic state, such as a tetraquark or a molecular state.

Golden Channels and Experimental Predictions

The study predicts the existence of a new hybrid, the $\eta_1(1640)$, which has yet to be experimentally confirmed. To assist experimentalists at facilities like BESIII or GlueX, the authors calculated partial decay widths to identify "golden channels" for discovery.

Predicted decay widths for hybrid states across different confinement models.

According to the decay analysis:

  • $\eta_1(1640)$: Can be verified by searching the $a_1(1260)\pi$ channel.
  • Isospin-0 Hybrids: The $K_1(1270)\bar{K}$ channel is identified as a primary search target due to its large predicted width.
  • Isospin-1/2 Hybrids: The $K_1(1270)\pi$ channel is suggested as the golden channel for these states.

Conclusion

By establishing $m_g = 450$ MeV as a proper constituent gluon mass, this research provides a clearer roadmap for identifying hybrid mesons. While the $\pi_1(1600)$ is strongly supported as a hybrid candidate, the discrepancy with $\eta_1(1855)$ and the prediction of $\eta_1(1640)$ highlight the need for continued experimental investigation into these exotic states of matter.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this letter, we propose that a proper constituent gluon mass $m_g$=450 MeV can be applied to identify the hybrids composed of quarks and gluons. By investigating the spectra and decay widths of the light hybrids $(q\bar{q}g)$ with $J^P=1^{-+}$, we find the $π_1(1600)$ and $η_1(1855)$ may not be explained as $1^{-+}$ hybrids, simultaneously, and the $η_1(1855)$ observed by BESIII may not be a hybrid. In addition, we predict an existence of a hybrid $η_1(1640)$, which can be verified by searching the $a_1(1260)π$ channel. Moreover, we suggest the $K_1(1270)\bar{K}$ and $K_1(1270)π$ as the golden channels to search for an isospin-0 and an isospin-$\frac{1}{2}$ hybrids, respectively.
BibTeX
@misc{ma2025proper,
  author = {Zi-Xuan Ma and Qi Huang and Liming Wang and Xiaohuang Hu and Y. T. Tan and J. He and Hongxia Huang and Huang, Hong-Xia},
  title = {{Proper constituent gluon mass as the final piece to construct hybrid mesons}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2504.05818},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.05818},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure