Proof of concept for multiple nerve transfers to a single target muscle

Matthias Luft, Johanna Klepetko, Silvia Muceli, Jaime Ibáñez, Vlad Tereshenko, Christopher Festin, Gregor Laengle, Olga Politikou, Udo Maierhofer, Dario Farina, Oskar C. Aszmann, Konstantin D. BergmeistereLife 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel rat model for surgically transferring multiple donor nerves to a single target muscle. This proof-of-concept study demonstrates the feasibility and effectiveness of this approach, paving the way for future research into enhanced prosthetic control and improved treatment for nerve injuries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Peripheral nerve injuries, neuromas, and phantom limb pain can significantly impair quality of life and limb function. Nerve transfers, where a healthy nerve is rerouted to reinnervate a damaged muscle, offer a promising solution by bypassing slow nerve regeneration. Currently, these procedures typically involve transferring a single donor nerve to a single target muscle. However, the authors propose that transferring multiple donor nerves to one muscle could offer significant advantages, such as increasing the number of usable signals for myoelectric prosthetics and potentially improving outcomes for complex nerve damage or neuroma treatment. The critical gap identified is the lack of an experimental model to study the neurophysiological effects and feasibility of such multiple nerve transfers in a controlled setting.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel surgical model in Sprague-Dawley rats to investigate double nerve transfers (DNT) to a single target muscle. The primary target was the long head of the biceps brachii.

  • Surgical Model: They compared two groups:
  • Single Nerve Transfer (SNT): The ulnar nerve (UN) was transferred to the biceps' long head.
  • Double Nerve Transfer (DNT): Both the UN and the anterior interosseus nerve (AIN) were transferred to the biceps' long head.
  • Crucially, the original motor branch to the biceps' long head was transected before the transfers to ensure reinnervation solely by the transferred nerves.
  • Evaluation Techniques: Twelve weeks post-surgery, the animals were assessed using a multi-faceted approach:
  • Behavioral Evaluation: A standardized grooming test was used to assess functional recovery.
  • Retrograde Labeling: Fluorescent tracers (Fluoro-Gold, Fast-Blue, Fluoro-Ruby) were injected into the target muscle to identify and count the reinnervating motor neurons in the spinal cord. This allowed for quantification of the extent of reinnervation from each donor nerve.
  • Neuromuscular Analyses: Nerve lengths were measured, and the motor entry point was examined for signs of reinnervation or neuroma formation. Muscle response to nerve crush and neurotomy was also assessed.
  • Structural Analysis: Muscle mass of the reinnervated biceps was compared to the contralateral (untreated) side and to control groups.

Datasets

The study did not involve training machine learning models. The primary "datasets" generated and analyzed were:

  • Muscle Mass Data: Measured in milligrams for treated and untreated biceps muscles. This data has been deposited in Dryad.
  • Retrograde Labeling Data: Motor neuron counts from spinal cord sections. This data has also been deposited in Dryad.

The study utilized a rat model, and the data collected served to validate the novel surgical technique and assess its functional and structural outcomes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feasibility of Multiple Nerve Transfers: The core finding is that it is indeed possible to successfully transfer two distinct peripheral nerves (UN and AIN) to a single target muscle (biceps' long head) and achieve functional reinnervation.
  • Enhanced Reinnervation Potential: The DNT group showed a statistically significant increase in the number of reinnervating motor neurons compared to the SNT group, suggesting a greater capacity for muscle reinnervation.
  • Muscle Mass Recovery: While SNT resulted in a decrease in muscle mass compared to the contralateral side, DNT led to near-complete recovery of muscle mass, indicating superior functional restoration.
  • Minimal Animal Burden: The procedures were well-tolerated by the animals, with no signs of significant pain, auto-mutilation, or functional deficits in daily activities. This is crucial for the ethical and practical application of such models.
  • Model Versatility: The developed model is robust and amenable to standard neurophysiological and structural analyses, making it a valuable tool for future research in this area.

Key Results

  • Successful Reinnervation: All nerves successfully reinnervated the target muscle 12 weeks post-surgery, with no aberrant reinnervation observed.
  • Behavioral Performance: Animals in both SNT and DNT groups achieved maximum scores on a grooming test, indicating good functional recovery.
  • Motor Neuron Count: DNT resulted in a higher number of reinnervating motor neurons (80.07±28.15) compared to SNT (50.67±15.67), and both were comparable to untreated controls (67.14±2.34).
  • Muscle Mass:
    • SNT led to a statistically significant decrease in muscle mass (-57.87 mg) compared to the untreated side.
  • DNT showed no statistically significant change in muscle mass compared to the untreated side, recovering to 98.83% of the contralateral side.
  • Muscle mass in the DNT group was significantly larger than in the SNT group (303.01±7.76 mg vs. 245.57±8.29 mg).
  • Surgery Time: DNT procedures took longer (78±20 min) than SNT (49±13 min).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rat Model Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the clinical translatability of rat models requires validation in larger animal models. A significant limitation is the inability to assess voluntary motor activity in rats, which is crucial for understanding human functional outcomes.
  • Mixed Nerve Use: The use of the ulnar nerve, which contains both sensory and motor fibers, is a potential limitation. The authors suggest that "pure" motor nerves, like the AIN, might be preferable for optimal outcomes, but the UN was chosen due to anatomical considerations in rats.
  • Future Directions:
    • Further investigation into the optimal donor-to-recipient ratio for maximizing outcomes.
  • Exploration of DNT for applications beyond basic reconstruction, such as enhancing neuromuscular interfacing for bionic prosthetics and improving TMR (Targeted Muscle Reinnervation) strategies.
  • Continued EMG analysis and validation are needed to fully understand the neurophysiological changes associated with multiple nerve transfers.
  • The model's scalability to other target muscles and its potential for treating conditions like phantom limb pain warrant further study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Surgical nerve transfers are used to efficiently treat peripheral nerve injuries, neuromas, phantom limb pain, or improve bionic prosthetic control. Commonly, one donor nerve is transferred to one target muscle. However, the transfer of multiple nerves onto a single target muscle may increase the number of muscle signals for myoelectric prosthetic control and facilitate the treatment of multiple neuromas. Currently, no experimental models are available. This study describes a novel experimental model to investigate the neurophysiological effects of peripheral double nerve transfers to a common target muscle. In 62 male Sprague-Dawley rats, the ulnar nerve of the antebrachium alone (n=30) or together with the anterior interosseus nerve (n=32) was transferred to reinnervate the long head of the biceps brachii. Before neurotization, the motor branch to the biceps' long head was transected at the motor entry point. Twelve weeks after surgery, muscle response to neurotomy, behavioral testing, retrograde labeling, and structural analyses were performed to assess reinnervation. These analyses indicated that all nerves successfully reinnervated the target muscle. No aberrant reinnervation was observed by the originally innervating nerve. Our observations suggest a minimal burden for the animal with no signs of functional deficit in daily activities or auto-mutilation in both procedures. Furthermore, standard neurophysiological analyses for nerve and muscle regeneration were applicable. This newly developed nerve transfer model allows for the reliable and standardized investigation of neural and functional changes following the transfer of multiple donor nerves to one target muscle.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luft2021proof,
  author = {Matthias Luft and Johanna Klepetko and Silvia Muceli and Jaime Ibáñez and Vlad Tereshenko and Christopher Festin and Gregor Laengle and Olga Politikou and Udo Maierhofer and Dario Farina and Oskar C. Aszmann and Konstantin D. Bergmeister},
  title = {{Proof of concept for multiple nerve transfers to a single target muscle}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.71312},
}
Figure