Promoting Good Scientific Communication Habits by Leveraging the Community of Practice within a Single Research Group

Félix Langevin Harnois, Jérôme Harrison, Prasun Lala, Ghizlane El Boussaidi, Christian Desrosiers, Catherine Laporte2020 · DOI

Abstract

This paper explores how to transform a research lab into a "Scientific Communication Community of Practice" by embedding structured writing and publishing activities directly into the lab's daily workflow. By moving these services from centralized campus centers into the lab itself, the authors created a self-sustaining model that improved student productivity and reduced the isolation often felt during the writing process. The lead researcher is a professor of electrical engineering at École de technologie supérieure (ÉTS), specializing in medical ultrasound image analysis and biomedical instrumentation, with research applications at the Sainte-Justine Hospital Research Centre.

Introduction

Graduate engineering students are under immense pressure to publish, yet they often lack formal training in scientific communication. While research labs are excellent at teaching technical skills, the "soft" skill of writing is frequently left to informal, disorganized mentoring. This leads to several systemic issues: the "back-loaded" problem where writing is delayed until the end of a project, isolation for students (particularly those using English as a second language), and the failure to share "tribal knowledge" across the lab.

The authors sought to bridge this gap by formalizing "active learning" habits within the existing social structure of a research group, moving away from centralized university services toward a more proximal, lab-integrated approach.

Methods and Participant Profile

The authors conducted an 11-month pilot project at the Imaging and Orthopaedics Research Laboratory (LIO) at ÉTS. Their approach relied on "organic management"—collaborating with lab members rather than imposing a rigid schedule. A Master’s student was selected as a "Lab Ambassador" to lead activities from within, ensuring relevance to the students' actual needs.

Key components included:

  • Workshops: 30-minute "micro-learning" sessions on topics like bibliometrics.
  • Writing Blitzes: 3-hour sessions using the Pomodoro technique to foster "social writing."
  • Journal Clubs: Monthly meetings focused on dissecting the structure and narrative of scientific papers.
  • Writing Support Groups: Small, facilitated groups for peer-reviewing actual drafts.

The participant group (n=12 to 14) represented a diverse range of career goals, with a strong lean toward industry roles in both research and non-research capacities.

Table 1: Career objectives of the study participants, highlighting a strong interest in industry-related roles.

Key Results

The pilot was highly successful, with activities becoming self-sustaining after 11 months. Large group activities attracted an average of 35% of the lab members, a significant turnout for voluntary sessions. Quantitative survey data indicated high perceived value among participants. On a 5-point Likert scale, students rated the activities as a "good use of time" (4.58/5) and felt they "addressed a need in the lab" (4.42/5).

Table 2: Survey results showing high ratings for the activities' utility and relevance to lab needs across different levels of participation.

Furthermore, the perceived difficulty of "Getting feedback" dropped from 3.50 to 3.08, and "Having the opportunity to review scientific writing" dropped from 3.42 to 2.92 (where 1 is easy and 5 is hard), indicating a measurable improvement in student confidence and skill.

Discussion and Insights

The success of the program hinged on several key insights:

  • Proximity is Power: Moving support into the lab's physical or virtual space aligns activities with specific deadlines and culture.
  • Social Writing Reduces Anxiety: The "Writing Blitzes" provided collective motivation and broke the sense of isolation.
  • The Ambassador Model: Peer leadership made the initiative feel lab-driven rather than a top-down administrative requirement.
  • Peer Review as a Learning Tool: Reviewing others' work helped students improve their own writing skills.

While the pilot lab had a strong collaborative culture, future work will explore if this model can succeed in labs with different research cultures and will aim to further structure the Writing Support Groups for consistent feedback quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since then, she has been a professor of electrical engineering at cole de technologie suprieure ( TS), where she teaches undergraduate courses in algorithms, biomedical instrumentation and medical imaging.Her research focuses on medical ultrasound image analysis, and aims to address problems relating to image acquisition, image segmentation and registration, 3D reconstruction, tracking and shape analysis using statistical methods.As an adjunct researcher at Sainte-Justine Hospital Research Centre, she is currently developing applications of ultrasound image analysis for non-invasive follow-up of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and the analysis of tongue motion for the study of speech production.
BibTeX
@misc{harnois2020promoting,
  author = {Félix Langevin Harnois and Jérôme Harrison and Prasun Lala and Ghizlane El Boussaidi and Christian Desrosiers and Catherine Laporte},
  title = {{Promoting Good Scientific Communication Habits by Leveraging the Community of Practice within a Single Research Group}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.18260/1-2--30906},
}
Figure