Prominent Josephson tunneling between twisted single copper oxide planes of Bi2Sr2-xLaxCuO6+y

Heng Wang, Yuying Zhu, Zhonghua Bai, Zechao Wang, Shuxu Hu, Hong-Yi Xie, Xiao Hu, Jian Cui, Miaoling Huang, Jianhao Chen, Ying Ding, Lin Zhao, Xinyan Li, Qinghua Zhang, Lin Gu, Xingjiang Zhou, Jing Zhu, Ding Zhang, Qi‐Kun XueNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Josephson tunneling in twisted cuprate junctions provides a litmus test for pairing symmetry, which is fundamental for understanding the microscopic mechanism of high-temperature superconductivity. This issue is rekindled by experimental advances in van der Waals stacking and the proposal of an emergent d+id-wave state. So far, experiments on Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2</sub>CaCu<sub>2</sub>O<sub>8+x</sub> (Bi-2212) with double CuO<sub>2</sub> planes have yielded controversial results. Here, we investigate junctions made of Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2-x</sub>La<sub>x</sub>CuO<sub>6+y</sub> (Bi-2201) with single CuO<sub>2</sub> planes. Our on-site cold stacking technique ensures uncompromised crystalline quality and stoichiometry at the interface. Junctions with carefully calibrated twist angles around 45° show strong Josephson tunneling and conventional temperature dependence. Furthermore, we observe standard Fraunhofer diffraction patterns and integer Fiske steps in a junction with a twist angle of 45.0±0.2°. Together, these results pose strong constraints on d or d+id-wave pairing and suggest an indispensable isotropic pairing component.

Introduction

A central mystery in physics is the "pairing symmetry" of high-temperature superconductors. While conventional superconductors exhibit isotropic "s-wave" symmetry, cuprates are widely believed to follow a "d-wave" symmetry, characterized by a four-leaf clover-like order parameter. A definitive test for this is the c-axis twisted junction: if two d-wave superconductors are twisted 45° relative to each other, the superconducting current (Josephson current) should theoretically vanish. Previous studies using double-layer Bi-2212 were hampered by structural complexity and interface degradation. This research settles the debate by utilizing single-layer Bi-2201 and a superior fabrication method.

Fabrication and Interface Quality

To maintain the integrity of the atomic-scale interface, the authors employed an "on-site cold stacking" technique. By performing exfoliation and stacking at -50°C in a controlled environment, they prevented the oxygen loss and degradation typical of room-temperature processing. Bi-2201 was specifically chosen because it contains only a single copper-oxide ($CuO_2$) plane per unit cell, eliminating the bonding/antibonding complexities found in double-layer materials.

Fabrication process and atomic-scale characterization of twisted Bi-2201 junctions.

High-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) confirmed that the $CuO_2$ planes remained stoichiometric and crystalline right up to the twisted interface, ensuring that the observed transport properties were intrinsic to the junction.

Transport Characteristics and Pairing Symmetry

The most significant finding is that the Josephson current does not disappear at a 45° twist angle. Instead, junctions with twist angles of 45.0 ± 0.2° showed robust superconducting tunneling. This persistence of the critical current ($I_c$) is a "smoking gun" indicating that pure d-wave symmetry cannot fully describe the system; an isotropic (s-wave-like) pairing component must be present.

Transport measurements across various twist angles showing robust Josephson tunneling and conventional temperature dependence.

As shown in the transport data, the critical current follows a conventional Ambegaokar-Baratoff-like saturation at low temperatures. This contradicts the non-monotonic behavior predicted for more exotic superconducting states like the $d+id$ state. Furthermore, the observation of standard Fraunhofer diffraction patterns and integer Fiske steps points toward conventional 2e Cooper pair tunneling, rather than the 4e co-tunneling proposed in some theoretical models.

Conclusion

By utilizing single-layer cuprates and high-precision cold stacking, this work demonstrates that prominent Josephson tunneling at 45° is an intrinsic property of twisted cuprate interfaces. These results suggest that an isotropic pairing component is indispensable in high-$T_c$ superconductors, posing significant constraints on existing theoretical models of pairing symmetry. Future work may explore whether this component arises from interface symmetry breaking or intrinsic structural distortions like supermodulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Josephson tunneling in twisted cuprate junctions provides a litmus test for the pairing symmetry, which is fundamental for understanding the microscopic mechanism of high temperature superconductivity. This issue is rekindled by experimental advances in van der Waals stacking and the proposal of an emergent d+id-wave. So far, all experiments have been carried out on Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2</sub>CaCu<sub>2</sub>O<sub>8+x</sub> (Bi-2212) with double CuO<sub>2</sub> planes but show controversial results. Here, we investigate junctions made of Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2-x</sub>La<sub>x</sub>CuO<sub>6+y</sub> (Bi-2201) with single CuO<sub>2</sub> planes. Our on-site cold stacking technique ensures uncompromised crystalline quality and stoichiometry at the interface. Junctions with carefully calibrated twist angles around 45° show strong Josephson tunneling and conventional temperature dependence. Furthermore, we observe standard Fraunhofer diffraction patterns and integer Fiske steps in a junction with a twist angle of 45.0±0.2°. Together, these results pose strong constraints on the d or d+id-wave pairing and suggest an indispensable isotropic pairing component.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023prominent,
  author = {Heng Wang and Yuying Zhu and Zhonghua Bai and Zechao Wang and Shuxu Hu and Hong-Yi Xie and Xiao Hu and Jian Cui and Miaoling Huang and Jianhao Chen and Ying Ding and Lin Zhao and Xinyan Li and Qinghua Zhang and Lin Gu and Xingjiang Zhou and Jing Zhu and Ding Zhang and Qi‐Kun Xue},
  title = {{Prominent Josephson tunneling between twisted single copper oxide planes of Bi2Sr2-xLaxCuO6+y}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-40525-1},
}
Figure