Prokaryotic genome editing based on the subtype I-B-Svi CRISPR-Cas system

Wang‐Yu Tong, De-Xiang Yong, Xin Xu, Cai-Hua Qiu, Yan Zhang, Xingwang Yang, Tingting Xia, Qingyang Liu, Su-Li Cao, Sun Yan, Xue LiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered a compact, single-protein genome editor called SviCas3 derived from a Type I-B CRISPR system in Streptomyces virginiae. Unlike traditional Type I systems that require a bulky multi-protein complex (Cascade) to function, SviCas3 works solo to enable precise, template-based editing with no detected off-target effects, offering a lightweight alternative to the much larger Cas9.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While CRISPR-Cas9 (Type II) has revolutionized biology, it isn't perfect. Its primary protein, SpCas9, is quite large (1,368 amino acids), making it difficult to package into viral vectors for gene therapy. Furthermore, Cas9 is prone to "off-target" effects—cutting DNA at unintended sites—and because it is often derived from human pathogens like Staphylococcus aureus, it can trigger immune responses in patients.

Type I CRISPR systems are the most abundant in nature and could offer alternatives, but they are notoriously complex. Usually, they require a "Cascade" complex (a team of 5-8 different proteins) just to find the DNA target, and then a separate protein (Cas3) to cut it. This paper identifies a rare "minimalist" Type I system where a single, small protein can handle the whole job.

Methods

The authors utilized a combination of bioinformatics, molecular cloning, and comparative microbiology:

  • Bioinformatics: They identified the subtype I-B-Svi CRISPR-Cas system within the genome of Streptomyces virginiae IBL14.
  • System Simplification: They engineered plasmids to express only the SviCas3 protein alongside a guide RNA (g-DNA) and a repair template (t-DNA).
  • Cross-Species Testing: To prove the system's versatility, they moved it out of its native Streptomyces and tested it in two common industrial microbes: Escherichia coli and Corynebacterium glutamicum.
  • Validation: Edits were confirmed using PCR, DNA electrophoresis, and Sanger sequencing.
  • Off-Target Analysis: They used predictive modeling to find the most likely unintended targets in the genome and sequenced those areas to check for "scars" or mutations.

Datasets

The study relied on established genomic databases and newly characterized sequences:

  • Reference Genomes: E. coli str. K-12 substr. MG1655 and C. glutamicum ATCC 13032 (from NCBI).
  • New Data: The authors deposited the operon gene sequences for the Svi CRISPR-Cas system and the target gene sequences used in their S. virginiae experiments into the NCBI database (Accession: KY243071–KY243079).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Solo" Cas3: The most significant "aha" moment is the realization that SviCas3 breaks the rules of Type I CRISPR. It doesn't need the Cascade complex for target recognition or cleavage. This simplifies the toolset from a multi-component machine to a single-component "Swiss Army knife."
  • Miniaturization: SviCas3 is only 771 amino acids long. For comparison, the standard SpCas9 is nearly twice that size. This small footprint is a massive advantage for delivery into cells via Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors, which have very limited "cargo" space.
  • Inherent Precision: The authors suggest that SviCas3 uses a "conformation-capture" mechanism rather than the "induced-fit" mechanism used by Cas9. This makes it much more selective; if the match isn't perfect, the protein simply won't lock on and cut, leading to the zero off-target results observed.
  • No Codon Optimization Needed: Remarkably, the raw bacterial gene worked across different species without being "translated" into the specific genetic dialect (codon usage) of the host, suggesting high biocompatibility.

Key Results

  • Successful Editing: The system achieved successful genome editing in all three tested species.
  • Efficiency: In its native S. virginiae, the editing efficiency was 1.0%, with a homologous recombination efficiency of 92%.
  • Precision: In all trials across all species, zero off-target changes or indels (unintended insertions/deletions) were detected.
  • New PAMs: The team identified three new Protospacer Adjacent Motifs (PAMs)—tac, tcc, and tgc—expanding the range of DNA sequences this tool can target.
  • Versatility: They demonstrated the ability to perform single and double gene deletions, as well as the insertion of large functional genes (like the cat antibiotic resistance gene).

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation noted is Genome Editing Efficiency (GEE) in non-native hosts. While the system worked in E. coli and C. glutamicum, the efficiency was several orders of magnitude lower than in Streptomyces. The authors argue this is due to poor "transformation efficiency" (getting the plasmids into the cells) rather than a failure of the CRISPR system itself.

Future work will likely focus on:

  1. Optimization: Improving the delivery methods to boost efficiency in industrial and clinical strains.
  2. Eukaryotic Application: The authors hint at a "sister article" regarding eukaryotic (human/animal cell) editing. Moving SviCas3 into human therapeutics is the clear next frontier.
  3. Mechanistic Studies: Determining exactly how SviCas3 manages to recognize DNA without the Cascade complex that its "cousins" require.

Summary updated

Abstract

Type I CRISPR-Cas systems are the most common among six types of CRISPR-Cas systems, however, non-self-targeting genome editing based on a single Cas3 of type I CRISPR-Cas systems has not been reported. Here, we present the subtype I-B-Svi CRISPR-Cas system (with three confirmed CRISPRs and a cas gene cluster) and genome editing based on this system found in Streptomyces virginiae IBL14. Importantly, like the animal-derived bacterial protein SpCas9 (1368 amino-acids), the single, compact, non-animal-derived bacterial protein SviCas3 (771 amino-acids) can also direct template-based microbial genome editing through the target cell's own homology-directed repair system, which breaks the view that the genome editing based on type I CRISPR-Cas systems requires a full Cascade. Notably, no off-target changes or indel-formation were detected in the analysis of potential off-target sites. This discovery broadens our understanding of the diversity of type I CRISPR-Cas systems and will facilitate new developments in genome editing tools.
BibTeX
@misc{tong2023prokaryotic,
  author = {Wang‐Yu Tong and De-Xiang Yong and Xin Xu and Cai-Hua Qiu and Yan Zhang and Xingwang Yang and Tingting Xia and Qingyang Liu and Su-Li Cao and Sun Yan and Xue Li},
  title = {{Prokaryotic genome editing based on the subtype I-B-Svi CRISPR-Cas system}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.05093},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.05093},
}
Figure