Progress Report on EMBED: A Pragmatic Trial of User-Centered Clinical Decision Support to Implement EMergency Department-Initiated BuprenorphinE for Opioid Use Disorder

Edward R. Melnick, Bidisha Nath, Osama M. Ahmed, Cynthia Brandt, David Chartash, James Dziura, Erik P. Hess, Wesley C. Holland, Jason Hoppe, Molly M. Jeffery, Liliya Katsovich, Fangyong Li, Charles Lu, Kaitlin R. Maciejewski, Matthew Maleska, Jodi A Mao, Shara Martel, Sean S. Michael, Hyung Paek, Mehul D. Patel, Timothy F Platts-Mills, Haseena Rajeevan, Jessica M. Ray, Rachel M. Skains, William E. Soares, Ashley Deutsch, Yauheni Solad, Gail D’OnofrioJournal of Psychiatry and Brain Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

The opioid epidemic continues to be a major public health crisis, and the Emergency Department (ED) is a critical point of contact for individuals with Opioid Use Disorder (OUD). This paper reports on the EMBED project, which developed and is testing a user-centered Clinical Decision Support (CDS) system to facilitate the initiation of buprenorphine (BUP) in the ED. Early results suggest this intervention can increase BUP prescribing and physician adoption, potentially shifting the paradigm towards earlier OUD treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The opioid epidemic in the United States is a devastating public health issue, with millions affected by Opioid Use Disorder (OUD) and tens of thousands dying annually. Emergency Departments (EDs) are a crucial access point for these individuals, yet the adoption of evidence-based treatments like buprenorphine (BUP) initiation in the ED has been slow. This slow adoption is attributed to several barriers, including physician unfamiliarity with the BUP care algorithm, the perception that the workflow is too complex and disruptive, and the poor usability of current electronic health records (EHRs) which hinders the streamlining of new practices. The EMBED project aims to overcome these barriers by developing and implementing a user-centered CDS tool designed to integrate seamlessly into the ED workflow and support clinicians in initiating BUP.

Methods

The EMBED project employed a multi-phase approach. The initial planning phase focused on user-centered design of the CDS prototype, involving extensive observations and interviews with ED physicians to understand their needs and identify varying levels of familiarity and support required for BUP initiation. This led to the development of a flexible design offering direct care pathways and optional decision support modules.

The implementation phase involves a pragmatic, group, parallel, cluster-randomized trial across five healthcare systems with 20 ED sites. This design was chosen to balance the rigor of controlled studies with the generalizability of real-world practice, allowing for a shorter study period and better control for temporal trends and clinical quality improvement (CQI) initiatives. The unit of randomization is the ED, with sites allocated 1:1 to either the intervention (CDS integrated into EHR) or control (usual care) arms.

A key methodological component is the development and validation of an EHR-based computable phenotype. This algorithm uses structured data elements within the EHR to identify potentially eligible patients (discharged, non-pregnant ED patients with suspected OUD not currently receiving MOUD), enabling passive data extraction for study analyses.

The intervention itself is the user-centered CDS tool, coupled with brief, just-in-time user training. The CDS guides clinicians through assessing OUD, withdrawal severity, and patient readiness, and then automates EHR activities such as documentation, orders, prescriptions, and referrals.

Datasets

The study primarily utilizes data extracted from Electronic Health Records (EHRs) within the participating healthcare systems. A key element is the development of an EHR-based computable phenotype, which was derived and validated using physician chart review as a reference standard. This phenotype allows for the identification of eligible patients based on existing EHR data, rather than requiring the creation of new datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • User-centered design is crucial for adoption: The EMBED project emphasizes that simply having an evidence-based practice isn't enough; the tool must be designed with the end-user (clinicians) in mind to overcome adoption barriers. Flexibility and direct pathways are key.
  • EHR integration is a significant hurdle: The usability and integration of CDS tools within existing EHR systems are critical for successful implementation. The project highlights the challenges and pragmatic solutions developed for integrating the CDS across different EHR vendors.
  • Automated workflows reduce clerical burden: By automating documentation, orders, and referrals, the CDS aims to alleviate the perceived clerical burden associated with BUP initiation, a major deterrent for clinicians.
  • Addressing regulatory complexities: The intervention provides separate pathways for clinicians with and without an X-waiver (required to prescribe BUP), accommodating the 72-hour rule and increasing flexibility for all clinicians.
  • Pragmatic trials are essential for real-world impact: The study's pragmatic design aims to increase the generalizability of findings, acknowledging that real-world practice is influenced by various factors beyond the intervention itself.

Key Results

  • Pilot Study Findings: A pilot study in a single ED showed a significant increase in ED-initiated BUP and naloxone prescribing, and a doubling of the number of unique physicians adopting the practice. The rate of BUP initiation increased from 2.8% to 7.0% (p=0.02).
  • EHR Phenotype Validation: The EHR-based computable phenotype demonstrated high validity in identifying eligible ED patients with presumed OUD, with positive predictive values (PPVs) of 0.96 and 0.95 in internal and external validation phases, respectively.
  • Trial Launch: The pragmatic trial has launched across 20 EDs in 5 healthcare systems, with ongoing data collection and analysis planned.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pragmatic Trial Limitations: The authors acknowledge that pragmatic trials, while increasing generalizability, may trade off some strength of causal inference compared to more rigorously controlled studies. They are tracking CQI initiatives to better control for their potential impact on outcomes.
  • Clinician Attitudes: The study does not directly address clinician attitudes towards OUD and MOUD. While the authors believe that the availability and ease of use of the CDS will indirectly influence these attitudes, it's not a direct intervention.
  • Scalability and Technical Challenges: While the intervention is designed to be integrated with common EHR platforms, the need for local customization and the limitations of current standards-based messaging present ongoing technical challenges for widespread scalability. Future work may involve exploring alternative, more scalable implementation approaches, such as native EHR tools.
  • Addressing Stigma: The authors suggest that future implementation efforts should systematically address the stigma associated with OUD, as it remains a significant barrier to treatment.

The project anticipates that findings from the ongoing multi-center trial will provide compelling evidence for the effectiveness of user-centered CDS in improving ED-initiated BUP rates, ultimately accelerating a shift towards early identification and treatment of OUD.

Summary updated

Abstract

Clinicaltrials.gov # NCT03658642.
BibTeX
@article{melnick2020progress,
  author = {Edward R. Melnick and Bidisha Nath and Osama M. Ahmed and Cynthia Brandt and David Chartash and James Dziura and Erik P. Hess and Wesley C. Holland and Jason Hoppe and Molly M. Jeffery and Liliya Katsovich and Fangyong Li and Charles Lu and Kaitlin R. Maciejewski and Matthew Maleska and Jodi A Mao and Shara Martel and Sean S. Michael and Hyung Paek and Mehul D. Patel and Timothy F Platts-Mills and Haseena Rajeevan and Jessica M. Ray and Rachel M. Skains and William E. Soares and Ashley Deutsch and Yauheni Solad and Gail D’Onofrio},
  title = {{Progress Report on EMBED: A Pragmatic Trial of User-Centered Clinical Decision Support to Implement EMergency Department-Initiated BuprenorphinE for Opioid Use Disorder}},
  journal = {Journal of Psychiatry and Brain Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.20900/jpbs.20200003},
}
Figure