Progress in self-quenching InP-based single photon detectors

Mark A. Itzler, Xudong Jiang, Bora M. Onat, Krystyna SlomkowskiProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Negative Feedback Avalanche Diodes (NFADs) based on InP technology, which overcome key limitations of traditional Single Photon Avalanche Diodes (SPADs). By integrating thin-film resistors, NFADs achieve rapid self-quenching, enabling higher photon counting rates and paving the way for photon number resolution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single Photon Avalanche Diodes (SPADs) are crucial for detecting single photons, particularly in the near-infrared spectrum (1.0-1.6 µm). However, conventional SPADs suffer from performance bottlenecks: limited photon counting rates and an inability to distinguish between multiple photons arriving simultaneously (photon number resolution). These issues stem from the inherent positive feedback in the avalanche process, which leads to "afterpulsing" (spurious counts after an initial detection) and stochastic avalanche behavior. Existing methods to mitigate these problems, like gated-mode operation or longer hold-off times, are either complex or further limit performance. This paper aims to address these limitations by introducing a novel detector design that inherently self-quenches avalanches more effectively.

Methods

The core innovation is the development of Negative Feedback Avalanche Diodes (NFADs). This is achieved by monolithically integrating thin-film resistors directly with InP-based SPAD structures. This "negative feedback" mechanism rapidly reduces the internal electric field within the avalanche diode after an initial photon detection, thereby quenching the avalanche process. The researchers explored two regimes:

  • Small Negative Feedback: Using feedback resistances in the range of < 100 kΩ. This regime revealed interesting phenomena like persistent current flow after the initial avalanche, characterized by oscillatory behavior and an exponentially distributed duration.
  • Large Negative Feedback: Employing feedback resistances > 500 kΩ. This regime demonstrated rapid and consistent quenching, with evidence suggesting partial discharge of the detector's capacitance.

The devices were fabricated using standard photolithographic techniques, offering flexibility in design and manufacturing.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental characterization of fabricated devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Monolithic Integration is Key: Integrating passive negative feedback elements (thin-film resistors) directly onto the InP SPAD structure is crucial for achieving low parasitic effects and rapid quenching.
  • Two Distinct Operating Regimes: The behavior of NFADs dramatically changes depending on the magnitude of the negative feedback resistance, leading to either persistent current phenomena or rapid, controlled quenching.
  • Persistent Current as a Diagnostic Tool: In the small feedback regime, the observed persistent current, its oscillatory nature, and its exponentially distributed duration provide valuable insights into the fundamental carrier dynamics within the avalanche process. This behavior, while undesirable for practical counting, offers a unique window into device physics.
  • Partial Capacitive Discharge: In the large feedback regime, the rapid quenching and reduced charge flow suggest that the avalanche is quenched before the full depletion capacitance is discharged, leading to significantly lower charge per event.
  • Potential for Photon Number Resolution: The highly deterministic and controlled avalanche behavior in the large feedback regime, coupled with the potential for small, quantized charge flows, opens doors for creating photon number resolving detectors using multi-element NFAD arrays.

Key Results

  • Rapid Quenching: NFADs with large negative feedback (> 500 kΩ) exhibit rapid self-quenching, significantly reducing the duration of avalanche events.
  • Reduced Charge Flow: In the large feedback regime, avalanche events result in significantly lower charge flow, as low as ~3 x 10⁵ carriers per event, compared to conventional SPADs. This is attributed to partial discharge of the detector capacitance.
  • Persistent Current Phenomena: NFADs with small negative feedback (< 100 kΩ) exhibit persistent current flow for durations up to ~120 ns, with oscillatory behavior and an exponentially distributed duration.
  • Improved Performance Potential: The NFAD design offers a path towards overcoming the limitations of SPADs in terms of photon counting rate and photon number resolution.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Persistent Current Undesirability: While informative, the persistent current observed in the small feedback regime is undesirable for practical high-speed photon counting due to increased afterpulsing and optical crosstalk.
  • Trade-off in Feedback Resistance: There's a trade-off between the feedback resistance value: larger resistance leads to faster quenching but can increase the device's "dead time" (re-arming period), potentially limiting counting rates.
  • Further Modeling: The paper mentions that a more in-depth model involving carrier dynamics is reported elsewhere to explain the oscillatory behavior of the persistent current.
  • Arrayed Geometries: The authors suggest that for arrayed NFADs, the single output signal could exhibit quantized current pulses, indicating the number of detectors that have avalanched, enabling photon number resolution and higher counting rates. This implies future work in designing and characterizing such multi-element arrays.

Summary updated

Abstract

The operation of InP-based single photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) in Geiger mode provides great utility for the detection of single photons at near-infrared wavelengths between 1.0 and 1.6 &#956;m. However, SPADs have performance limitations with respect to photon counting rate and the absence of photon number resolution that, at the most fundamental level, can be traced back to the positive feedback inherent in the impact ionization-driven avalanche process. In this paper, we describe the inclusion of negative feedback with best-in-class InP-based single photon avalanche diode (SPAD) structures to form negative feedback avalanche diodes (NFADs) in which many of the present limitations of SPAD operation can be overcome. The use of thin film resistors as monolithic passive negative feedback elements ensures rapid self-quenching with very low parasitic effects. We demonstrate a qualitative difference in the performance of NFADs in the two regimes of small and large negative feedback. With small feedback, we have studied the behavior of the persistent current prior to quenching, for which we have found oscillatory behavior as well as an exponentially distributed duration. For large feedback, we find rapid quenching, accompanied by evidence for a partial discharge of the detector capacitance, leading to charge flows as low as ~3 ×10<sup>5</sup> carriers associated with each avalanche event.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{itzler2010progress,
  author = {Mark A. Itzler and Xudong Jiang and Bora M. Onat and Krystyna Slomkowski},
  title = {{Progress in self-quenching InP-based single photon detectors}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1117/12.843588},
}
Figure