Progress in Activation of Small Molecules Promoted by Frustrated Lewis Pairs

Zhenbei Zhang, Wei Sun, Zhishan CaoChinese 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Frustrated Lewis Pairs (FLPs) are a revolutionary concept in chemistry that allows for the activation of small, inert molecules like hydrogen, CO2, and olefins using main group elements, bypassing the need for traditional transition metals. This review highlights the diverse structures and reactivity of FLPs, showcasing their remarkable progress in catalyzing a wide range of organic transformations and opening new avenues for sustainable synthesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, activating small, stable molecules like hydrogen (H2) or carbon dioxide (CO2) for chemical reactions has largely relied on transition metals. These metals, while effective, can be expensive, toxic, and their use can lead to complex reaction mixtures. The challenge has been to find alternative, more sustainable, and potentially greener methods for activating these fundamental building blocks. The concept of "frustrated Lewis pairs" (FLPs) emerged as a groundbreaking solution, demonstrating that a Lewis acid and a Lewis base, when sterically hindered from forming a traditional adduct, can cooperatively activate small molecules. This paper reviews the significant progress made in understanding and utilizing FLPs for a variety of small molecule activations, offering a metal-free alternative for many important chemical processes.

Methods

This paper is a review, so it doesn't present new experimental methods. Instead, it synthesizes and discusses the findings from numerous research groups that have employed a variety of techniques to study FLPs. These include:

  • Synthesis and Characterization: Developing and synthesizing novel FLP systems, often involving bulky phosphines or amines as Lewis bases and highly electrophilic boranes (like B(C6F5)3) as Lewis acids. Characterization techniques like NMR (¹H, ¹³C, ¹⁹F, ³¹P, ¹¹B), X-ray crystallography, and neutron diffraction are crucial for determining the structures of FLPs and their activated products.
  • Spectroscopic and Computational Studies: Using techniques like solid-state NMR and computational methods (e.g., DFT) to understand the interactions between FLPs and small molecules, elucidate reaction mechanisms, and determine activation barriers.
  • Catalytic Studies: Applying FLP systems to catalyze a wide range of organic reactions, including hydrogenation, CO2 fixation, olefin and alkyne activation, ring-opening reactions, and hydrosilylation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a review article summarizing existing research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Frustration" is Key: The core idea is that steric hindrance prevents the Lewis acid and base from forming a stable adduct. This "frustration" is what allows them to cooperatively attack and activate small molecules.
  • Metal-Free Activation: FLPs offer a powerful way to activate small molecules without relying on transition metals, paving the way for more sustainable and environmentally friendly chemical processes.
  • Versatility in Small Molecule Activation: FLPs have demonstrated remarkable ability to activate a diverse range of small molecules, including H2, CO2, CO, olefins, alkynes, ethers, silanes, and even N2O.
  • Structural Diversity: FLPs can be designed as either intermolecular (separate Lewis acid and base molecules) or intramolecular (both functionalities within the same molecule) systems, offering tunable reactivity.
  • Beyond Hydrogen: While initial breakthroughs focused on H2 activation, FLPs have proven effective in a much broader scope of reactions, including CO2 capture and conversion, which is crucial for climate change mitigation.
  • Main Group Element Powerhouse: The success of FLPs has reignited interest in the catalytic potential of main group elements, challenging the long-held dominance of transition metals in small molecule activation.

Key Results

The review highlights numerous successful applications of FLPs:

  • Hydrogen Activation: FLPs can activate H2 at room temperature and pressure, leading to the formation of hydridoborate salts. This has been demonstrated with various phosphine/borane and amine/borane combinations.
  • CO2 Activation and Conversion: FLPs can reversibly bind CO2, forming adducts that can be further transformed. This has led to catalytic systems for the reduction of CO2 to methanol or methane, and for the synthesis of cyclic carbonates.
  • Olefin and Alkyne Activation: FLPs can promote the addition of H2 across double and triple bonds, and also facilitate hydroboration reactions.
  • Ring-Opening Reactions: FLPs can catalyze the ring-opening of cyclic ethers (like THF), lactones, and even cyclopropanes, leading to valuable functionalized products.
  • Hydrosilylation: FLPs are effective catalysts for the hydrosilylation of various functional groups, including carbonyls, imines, nitriles, and nitro compounds, offering a metal-free alternative to traditional methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope and Selectivity: While FLPs have shown broad applicability, achieving high selectivity and efficiency for all substrates and reactions remains an ongoing challenge. The steric and electronic properties of both the Lewis acid and base components are critical for fine-tuning reactivity.
  • Catalyst Stability and Turnover: The long-term stability and recyclability of FLP catalysts in some applications need further investigation.
  • Mechanistic Understanding: While significant progress has been made, a deeper understanding of the precise mechanisms of FLP-mediated reactions, especially for complex transformations, is still needed.
  • Future Directions: The authors envision FLPs playing an increasingly important role in:
  • Sustainable Synthesis: Developing greener and more efficient catalytic processes for the synthesis of fine chemicals and pharmaceuticals.
  • Natural Product Synthesis: Utilizing FLPs for the selective activation and functionalization of complex molecules.
  • Biomimetic Chemistry: Designing FLP systems that mimic enzymatic processes for small molecule activation.
  • Materials Science: Exploring the use of FLPs in the synthesis of novel materials.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018progress,
  author = {Zhenbei Zhang and Wei Sun and Zhishan Cao},
  title = {{Progress in Activation of Small Molecules Promoted by Frustrated Lewis Pairs}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.6023/cjoc201801003},
}
Figure