Program Committee

Tor M. Aamodt, David H. Albonesi, Cornell Asanovic, Berkeley Austin, Rajeev Balasubramonian, Richard Belgard, Pradip Bose, David Brooks, Harvard Carmean, Derek Chiou, U Austin, Robert P. Colwell, Thomas M. Conte, Georgia Tech, Chita R. Das, Michel Dubois, Evelyn Duesterwald, Lieven Eeckhout, Boris Grot, Nikos Hardavellas, Juanita Hoe, Wen‐mei Hwu, Engin İpek, Rochester Daniel Jimenez, U San, A. H. Kim, Konrad Lai, Gabriel H. Loh, Ahmed Louri, Nsf Arizona, Scott Mahlke, Srilatha Manne, Andreas Moshovos, Toronto Mudge, Yale N. Patt, Milos Prvulović, Moinuddin K. Qureshi, Ronny Ronen, Yanos Sazeides, Michael Schlansker, H Labs, André Seznec, Michael Shebanow, Burton Smith, Jared C. Smolens, Viji Srinivasan, Chris Wilkerson, Yuanyuan Zhou, Craig Zilles2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This document lists the members of the Program Committee for an academic conference. It serves as a record of the individuals responsible for reviewing and selecting research papers for presentation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

This document addresses the need for a structured and transparent process in academic conferences for selecting high-quality research to be presented. The Program Committee is a crucial component of this process, as its members are tasked with the expert evaluation of submitted papers. The existence of this list signifies the organizational effort behind ensuring a rigorous and fair review process, which is fundamental to the advancement of scientific knowledge.

Methods

The "methods" employed by the Program Committee are primarily those of peer review. This typically involves:

  • Paper Assignment: Submissions are assigned to committee members based on their expertise.
  • Reviewing: Members critically evaluate papers against criteria such as novelty, technical soundness, clarity, and relevance.
  • Discussion and Deliberation: Committee members discuss their reviews, often in an online forum or during a dedicated meeting, to reach a consensus on paper acceptance or rejection.
  • Decision Making: Based on the reviews and discussions, the committee makes final decisions on which papers will be accepted for the conference.

The novelty here lies not in a specific technical algorithm, but in the collective application of expert judgment and established academic review practices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This document lists individuals, not research findings or experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Expertise Distribution: The diverse affiliations of the committee members (universities, research labs, industry) suggest a broad range of expertise being brought to bear on paper selection. This is crucial for covering the multifaceted nature of modern computer science research.
  • Community Involvement: The sheer number of individuals involved highlights the significant community effort required to run a successful academic conference.
  • Quality Control: The Program Committee acts as a vital gatekeeper, ensuring that only high-quality, relevant, and impactful research is presented, thereby maintaining the academic integrity and value of the conference.

Key Results

The primary "result" of the Program Committee's work is the curated set of accepted papers for the conference. While specific quantitative results (like acceptance rates or impact metrics) are not detailed in this document, the existence of a Program Committee implies a successful outcome in terms of organizing the review process.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: This document itself is a static list and does not detail the review process's effectiveness, potential biases, or the workload distribution among committee members. The effectiveness of the review process is inherently dependent on the diligence and expertise of the individuals listed.
  • Future Work: Future work related to Program Committees often focuses on improving the review process itself. This could include exploring more efficient review assignment algorithms, developing better tools for reviewer collaboration, mitigating reviewer fatigue, and ensuring greater diversity and inclusion within the committee membership.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{aamodt2012program,
  author = {Tor M. Aamodt and David H. Albonesi and Cornell Asanovic and Berkeley Austin and Rajeev Balasubramonian and Richard Belgard and Pradip Bose and David Brooks and Harvard Carmean and Derek Chiou and U Austin and Robert P. Colwell and Thomas M. Conte and Georgia Tech and Chita R. Das and Michel Dubois and Evelyn Duesterwald and Lieven Eeckhout and Boris Grot and Nikos Hardavellas and Juanita Hoe and Wen‐mei Hwu and Engin İpek and Rochester Daniel Jimenez and U San and A. H. Kim and Konrad Lai and Gabriel H. Loh and Ahmed Louri and Nsf Arizona and Scott Mahlke and Srilatha Manne and Andreas Moshovos and Toronto Mudge and Yale N. Patt and Milos Prvulović and Moinuddin K. Qureshi and Ronny Ronen and Yanos Sazeides and Michael Schlansker and H Labs and André Seznec and Michael Shebanow and Burton Smith and Jared C. Smolens and Viji Srinivasan and Chris Wilkerson and Yuanyuan Zhou and Craig Zilles},
  title = {{Program Committee}},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1109/micro.2012.8},
}
Figure