Prognostic significance of the sub-classification of stage pT3a renal tumors by perinephric and sinus fat invasion

Dongsheng Zhu, Jingyuan Cao, Chao Zhi, Tao Guo, Yuhong Li, Zhiqiang Lang, Gang LiOncology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In the current Tumor-Node-Metastasis (TNM) classification system for renal cell carcinoma (RCC), both perinephric fat invasion (PFI) and renal sinus fat invasion (SFI) are categorized as stage pT3a. However, the associated prognoses remain clinically controversial. This study proposes a new sub-classification criterion (Types A, B, and C) based on the pattern of fat invasion to resolve this dispute. Analyzing 127 patients upstaged to pT3a after partial nephrectomy, we found that tumor morphology—specifically the presence of detached nodules (Type C)—is a significant independent predictor of recurrence.

Introduction

Staging is critical for determining the treatment and prognosis of Renal Cell Carcinoma (RCC). Most small tumors (<4cm) are clinically staged as cT1a and treated with partial nephrectomy (PN). However, pathological examination post-surgery occasionally reveals invasion into the perinephric or sinus fat, leading to an "upstaging" to pT3a. Currently, the TNM system treats all such invasions uniformly, despite conflicting data regarding whether the location of invasion (sinus vs. perinephric) affects survival. This study investigates whether the pattern of invasion provides a more reliable prognostic indicator.

Methods and Materials

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 2,765 patients who underwent PN for suspected T1a renal cancer across four institutions between 2001 and 2015. From this cohort, 127 cases (55 with SFI, 72 with PFI) were identified as stage pT3a.

Histological specimens were examined using hematoxylin-eosin (H&E) staining to categorize invasion into three types:

  • Type A: Direct contact between the tumor and adipose tissue after pseudo-capsule invasion.
  • Type B: Tongue-like tumor protrusions into the adipose tissue.
  • Type C: Disconnected tumor nodules distributed within the adipose tissue.
Histological representation of Type C invasion showing detached tumor nodules (arrows) within the perinephric fat.

Results

The study found that the morphological pattern of invasion significantly influenced recurrence rates ($P=0.023$). Type C invasion, characterized by isolated tumor "islands," presented the highest risk:

  • Type A: 5.3% recurrence (3/57 patients)
  • Type B: 13.8% recurrence (4/29 patients)
  • Type C: 24.4% recurrence (10/41 patients)

Kaplan-Meier analysis demonstrated a clear divergence in recurrence-free survival (RFS) between the three groups (Log-rank $P=0.015$). Multivariate Cox regression confirmed that this sub-classification is an independent predictor of recurrence ($P=0.021$), with Type C patients exhibiting a Hazard Ratio of 2.032 compared to Type A.

Kaplan-Meier curves illustrating the significant difference in recurrence-free survival between the proposed Type A, B, and C sub-classifications.

Discussion

The "island effect" seen in Type C invasion likely explains the higher recurrence rates. These detached nodules may be invisible during surgery, leading to incomplete resection during partial nephrectomy. This study suggests that the morphology of fat invasion is a more potent prognostic factor than the anatomical location (SFI vs. PFI).

While limited by its retrospective nature and sample size, these findings advocate for a more nuanced approach to pT3a staging. Future integration of advanced imaging to identify Type C patterns pre-operatively could guide surgeons toward radical nephrectomy in high-risk cases to ensure complete tumor clearance.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the current Tumor-Node-Metastasis (TNM) classification system for renal cell carcinoma (RCC), both perinephric fat invasion (PFI) and renal sinus fat invasion (SFI) are classified at the T3a stage. However, their associated prognoses are clinically controversial. The present study proposes a new sub-classification criterion for pathological T3a (pT3a) RCC with SFI or PFI to resolve this dispute. Data were collected from consecutive records of 2,765 patients with T1a renal cancer, who had undergone partial nephrectomy (PN) between 2001 and 2015 at one of four hospitals. Among these patients, 127 cases were diagnosed with stage pT3a RCC with SFI or PFI, according to final pathological examination. The pathological characteristics, clinical data and follow-up observations were analyzed. Of the 127 patients, with an average follow-up duration of 56 months (range, 15-60 months), 17 cases of tumor recurrence were found. After analysis of the pathological findings, the following new sub-classification criteria was proposed for pT3a RCC with SFI or PFI: i) Type A, renal tumor invades the pseudo-capsule and contacts with the perinephric adipose tissues directly (3 recurrences out of 57 patients); ii) type B, tumor protrudes into the perinephric adipose tissues like a tongue (4 recurrences out of 29 patients); and iii) type C, tumor nodules distribute in perinephric adipose tissues (10 recurrences out of 41 patients). There was statistically significant difference between the three subtypes in terms of recurrence rate (P=0.023). In conclusion, controversies remain in the current TNM classification system for pT3a RCC. The present study added to the available data and found that pT3a RCC with tumor nodules in perinephric adipose or/and with an irregular tumor protruding into adipose tissues showed a higher recurrence rate. Thus, it is recommended that pT3a RCC should be carefully analyzed and should be considered differently to other stages of RCC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2020prognostic,
  author = {Dongsheng Zhu and Jingyuan Cao and Chao Zhi and Tao Guo and Yuhong Li and Zhiqiang Lang and Gang Li},
  title = {{Prognostic significance of the sub-classification of stage pT3a renal tumors by perinephric and sinus fat invasion}},
  booktitle = {Oncology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3892/ol.2020.11281},
}
Figure