Prognostic Role of Demographic, Injury and Claim Factors in Disabling Pain and Mental Health Conditions 12 Months after Compensable Injury

Thi Nguyen, Katharine S. Baker, Liane Ioannou, Behrooz Hassani‐Mahmooei, Stephen J. Gibson, Alex Collie, Jennie Ponsford, Peter Cameron, Belinda J. Gabbe, Melita J. GiummarraInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies key predictors of disabling pain and mental health conditions 12 months after a serious injury. It highlights that early interventions, particularly around medication use and work disability, can help identify individuals at risk and improve their long-term recovery outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Following a serious injury, a significant proportion of individuals experience persistent disabling pain and/or mental health conditions, impacting their quality of life and increasing healthcare costs. Early identification of those at risk of developing these chronic issues is crucial for implementing timely and targeted preventive interventions. However, it's challenging to predict who will develop these long-term problems, especially considering the complex interplay of injury characteristics, individual factors, and the compensation system. This paper aims to address this by identifying prognostic factors available within the first 12 months post-injury that predict disabling pain and mental health conditions at the 12-month mark.

Methods

The study employed a retrospective cohort design, analyzing data from 157 individuals who had sustained a compensable transport or workplace injury and were admitted to a major trauma service. Data was collected from multiple sources: the Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcomes Registry (VOTOR), the Victorian State Trauma Registry (VSTR), and the Compensation Research Database (CRD). Participants completed questionnaires assessing pain and mental health (anxiety, depression, PTSD) at 12 months post-injury. Multivariable logistic regression was used to identify predictors of disabling pain and probable mental health conditions. The analysis considered baseline demographic and injury characteristics, as well as factors related to compensation claims, health services, and medication use at various time points (early post-injury, 3-6 months, and 6-12 months).

Datasets

The study utilized routinely collected data from the following sources:

  • Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcomes Registry (VOTOR): Provided data on orthopaedic injuries.
  • Victorian State Trauma Registry (VSTR): Provided data on major trauma admissions.
  • Compensation Research Database (CRD): Provided data on compensation claims, including benefit types, dates of service/payment, and claim classifications from the Transport Accident Commission (TAC) and WorkSafe Victoria (WSV).
  • Participant Questionnaires: Collected self-reported data on pain, mental health (anxiety, depression, PTSD), and compensation experiences at 12 months post-injury.

No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Compensation Health Effect" is Complex: While compensation schemes are designed to support recovery, the experience of navigating these systems can be a significant stressor. Negative procedural experiences and the need to repeatedly prove disability were associated with poorer outcomes.
  • Early Medication Use is a Red Flag: The use of opioids and psychotropic medications in the early stages (3-6 months) and up to 12 months post-injury emerged as strong predictors for both disabling pain and mental health conditions. This suggests these medications might be used to manage persistent symptoms, indicating a higher risk of long-term issues.
  • Work Disability is a Crucial Indicator: Persistent work disability throughout the first 12 months post-injury was a significant predictor of disabling pain at the 12-month mark. This highlights the interconnectedness of physical health, mental well-being, and the ability to return to work.
  • Impairment Matters, But Not Always Predictively: While individuals with permanent impairment were more likely to report disabling pain and mental health conditions, injury severity itself was more directly linked to pain, not mental health. This suggests that the consequences of the injury (impairment) are more predictive than the initial severity for mental health outcomes.
  • Screening Accuracy Improves Over Time: The accuracy of predicting chronic pain outcomes increased as more data from the compensation claims and treatment history became available, peaking at the 3-6 month post-injury mark. This suggests that a window of opportunity exists for intervention.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: At 12 months post-injury, approximately one-third of participants experienced disabling pain, and one-third had at least one probable mental health condition. Over one-fifth experienced both.
  • Predictors of Disabling Pain: Mental health treatment between 3-6 months post-injury, persistent work disability, and opioid use between 6-12 months post-injury were significant predictors of disabling pain at 12 months.
  • Predictors of Mental Health Conditions: Opioid use between 3-6 months post-injury, work disability, and psychotropic medications between 6-12 months post-injury predicted a mental health condition at 12 months.
  • Predictive Accuracy: The accuracy of predicting chronic pain outcomes improved over time, reaching 76.8% at 3-6 months post-injury. For mental health conditions, accuracy also improved, reaching 72.7% at 6-12 months post-injury.
  • Compensation Experience: Negative procedural experiences in the compensation claim process were associated with higher odds of both disabling pain and mental health conditions. Conversely, positive perceptions of compensation supporting recovery were associated with lower odds.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Generalizability: The study focused on individuals with moderate to severe injuries requiring hospitalization, so findings may not apply to those with minor soft tissue injuries or those in fault-based compensation schemes.
  • Sample Size: The relatively small sample size limited the ability to test the specificity and sensitivity across multiple subsets and to include all potential covariates in the multivariate analyses (e.g., sex).
  • Data Completeness: Compensation claims data may not capture all prescription medications, and additional health services not covered by compensation were not accounted for.
  • Follow-up Period: The follow-up was limited to 12 months, preventing an examination of longer-term outcomes.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Larger, Multisite Studies: Replicating these findings in larger, more diverse cohorts and over extended timeframes is crucial for validating the prediction models.
  • Inclusion of All Predictors: Future studies should aim to include all important predictors of pain and mental health outcomes.
  • Exploration of Different Screening Periods: Investigating optimal screening periods and criteria for different injury severities is recommended.
  • Proactive Interventions: The study strongly advocates for early, time-sensitive, multidisciplinary interventions for individuals identified as at risk to improve recovery and prevent chronic conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Identifying who might develop disabling pain or poor mental health after injury is a high priority so that healthcare providers can provide targeted preventive interventions. This retrospective cohort study aimed to identify predictors of disabling pain or probable mental health conditions at 12 months post-injury. Participants were recruited 12-months after admission to a major trauma service for a compensable transport or workplace injury (<i>n</i> = 157). Injury, compensation claim, health services and medication information were obtained from the Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcome Registry, Victorian State Trauma Registry and Compensation Research Database. Participants completed questionnaires about pain, and mental health (anxiety, depression, posttraumatic stress disorder) at 12 months post-injury. One third had disabling pain, one third had at least one probable mental health condition and more than one in five had both disabling pain and a mental health condition at 12 months post-injury. Multivariable logistic regression found mental health treatment 3-6 months post-injury, persistent work disability and opioid use at 6-12 months predicted disabling pain at 12 months post-injury. The presence of opioid use at 3-6 months, work disability and psychotropic medications at 6-12 months predicted a mental health condition at 12 months post-injury. These factors could be used to identify at risk of developing disabling pain who could benefit from timely interventions to better manage both pain and mental health post-injury. Implications for healthcare and compensation system are discussed.
BibTeX
@article{nguyen2020prognostic,
  author = {Thi Nguyen and Katharine S. Baker and Liane Ioannou and Behrooz Hassani‐Mahmooei and Stephen J. Gibson and Alex Collie and Jennie Ponsford and Peter Cameron and Belinda J. Gabbe and Melita J. Giummarra},
  title = {{Prognostic Role of Demographic, Injury and Claim Factors in Disabling Pain and Mental Health Conditions 12 Months after Compensable Injury}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17197320},
}
Figure