Prognostic factors in patients with thyroid carcinoma: a competing-risks analysis

Junhu Wang, Lisong Heng, Jie Yang, Feng Tian, Xiaojun Liang, xinwen wangResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Traditional Cox proportional-hazards models are the standard for identifying prognostic factors in oncology, yet they often fail to account for "competing risks"—events like death from non-cancer causes that prevent the primary event of interest. In thyroid carcinoma, where survival is often prolonged, these competing risks are significant. This study analyzed 38,444 patients from the SEER database using three multivariate models: Cox regression, cause-specific hazard (CS), and subdistribution hazard (SD). Results identified age, histology, stage, and metastasis as consistent risk factors. Notably, the competing-risks models revealed that traditional Cox models might overestimate the impact of race while underestimating the significance of tumor size. These findings suggest that competing-risks analysis provides a more accurate framework for clinical risk stratification in thyroid cancer.

Introduction

Predicting survival outcomes for thyroid carcinoma is complex due to the disease's generally favorable prognosis and long clinical course. In such scenarios, patients are statistically likely to die from causes unrelated to their cancer (e.g., cardiovascular disease) before the cancer itself becomes terminal. Standard statistical tools, such as the Cox proportional-hazards model, treat these "competing" deaths as censored data, which can lead to biased results and an overestimation of cancer-specific mortality. This study aims to refine prognostic accuracy by applying competing-risks models to a large-scale patient cohort.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database, identifying 38,444 eligible patients diagnosed with thyroid carcinoma between 2010 and 2015. The cohort included various histological types: Papillary (PTC), Follicular (FTC), Medullary (MTC), and Anaplastic (ATC).

To identify prognostic factors, three statistical approaches were compared:

  1. Cox Regression Analysis: The standard model for survival data.
  2. Cause-Specific (CS) Hazard Function: Measures the "force" of a specific cause of death.
  3. Subdistribution (SD) Hazard Function: Estimates the actual probability of an event in a real-world setting where multiple risks coexist. This model is often preferred for clinical decision-making.

Results

The analysis highlighted several factors that consistently influenced prognosis across all three models.

Consistent Risk Factors

  • Demographics and Social Factors: Increasing age was a primary risk factor. Conversely, being female and being married were identified as protective factors.
  • Histology: Compared to Papillary carcinoma, Anaplastic (ATC) was the most aggressive, followed by Medullary (MTC) and Follicular (FTC).
  • Clinical Staging: Higher AJCC-6 stages (II, III, and IV) and the presence of liver or lung metastases were strong predictors of mortality.
  • Treatment and Staging Quality: Lack of surgery and radioiodine therapy were significant risks. Interestingly, having regional lymph nodes examined—regardless of the findings—was a protective factor, likely serving as a proxy for thorough surgical care.

Discrepancies in Traditional Modeling

The study found that competing-risks models corrected several biases inherent in the Cox model:

  • Race: While the Cox model suggested that being Black was a significant risk factor (HR 1.25), this significance disappeared in the CS and SD models, suggesting the initial finding was an artifact of non-cancer-related mortality risks.
  • Tumor Size: The Cox model failed to find statistical significance for tumor sizes >1 cm. However, both competing-risks models (CS and SD) identified larger tumor size as a highly significant risk factor (p < 0.01).

Discussion and Conclusion

By accounting for deaths due to other causes (DOC), which represented nearly half of the total mortality in this cohort, the researchers demonstrated that competing-risks models provide a more nuanced view of thyroid cancer prognosis. The subdistribution hazard (SD) model, in particular, offers a more conservative and likely more accurate estimation of risk.

These findings underscore the importance of using appropriate statistical methods when dealing with high-survival cancers. The identified factors—including the protective effects of marriage and thorough lymph node examination—provide a more robust evidence base for treatment planning and patient counseling. Future work should validate these results using the AJCC 8th edition staging and incorporate more granular treatment data, such as targeted molecular therapies.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background: </bold>Cox proportional-hazards models are widely used to describe survival trends and identify prognostic factors for thyroid carcinoma, but the prognostic model is not accurate enough. This study therefore used a competing-risks model to identify the significant prognostic factors for different types of thyroid carcinoma.<bold>Methods: </bold>We identified 38,444 eligible patients in the SEER (Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Result) database. The potential prognostic factors for thyroid carcinoma were analyzed by Cox regression analysis, cause-specific hazard function (CS) analysis, and subdistribution hazard function (SD).<bold>Results: </bold>Cox regression analysis, CS analysis and SD analysis found identifying age, being unmarried, no regional lymph nodes examined, AJCC-6 II, III, IV vs I , having follicular, medullary, anaplastic vs Papillary carcinomas, no surgery, no radioiodine, liver metastasis, and lung metastasis as the significant risk factors for thyroid carcinoma, while being female was protective factor. However, the results from the three multivariate models for being black, tumor size &gt;1 cm, and brain metastasis were inconsistent.<bold>Conclusion: </bold>In addition to finding that age, pathological type, tumor size, AJCC-6 stage, surgery status, radioiodine status, metastasis as common factors affected the prognosis, we also found that women, being unmarried and had their regional lymph nodes examined can improve the prognosis of thyroid cancer. The discovery of these factors will provide evidences for the prevention and treatment of thyroid cancer.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020prognostic,
  author = {Junhu Wang and Lisong Heng and Jie Yang and Feng Tian and Xiaojun Liang and xinwen wang},
  title = {{Prognostic factors in patients with thyroid carcinoma: a competing-risks analysis}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-19798/v2},
}
Figure