Profit Maximization of a Power Plant

Martin Kragelund, John Leth, Rafal Wisniewski, Ulf JönssonEur. J. Control 2012 · DOI

Abstract

This study presents an optimal control strategy designed to maximize the profit of a multi-fuel power plant while strictly adhering to a predefined production schedule. By integrating Pontryagin’s Maximum Principle with a novel iterative feedback/feedforward algorithm, the research demonstrates a significant profit increase—up to 45% in noisy environments—compared to standard discrete optimization methods.

Introduction

In liberalized electricity markets, such as the Nordic "Nord Pool," power plant operators must balance the fulfillment of a strict production plan with the economic realities of varying fuel costs and physical system constraints. The primary challenge lies in optimizing the use of multiple fuel sources:

  • Coal: Low cost but slow response and measurement uncertainty.
  • Gas: High controllability but expensive and lower efficiency in specific boiler types.
  • Oil: High cost, typically limited to start-up phases.

Traditional control systems often prioritize stability (disturbance rejection) over economic efficiency. This paper addresses the need for a controller that maximizes profit while maintaining the required electricity output.

Schematic of a Benson Boiler system with multi-fuel burners.

Methodology

The researchers modeled a 400MW coal-fired plant using a third-order linear dynamic model. The optimization problem was framed using Pontryagin’s Maximum Principle (PMP) to identify the optimal "switching function" ($\sigma(t)$) for fuel selection.

To overcome the computational difficulties of continuous-time optimization and the presence of "singular arcs," a multi-stage approach was implemented:

  1. Initial Guess: A discrete-time version of the problem was solved using quadratic programming.
  2. Iterative Refinement: A feedback/feedforward algorithm refined the initial trajectory. A heuristic was introduced to stabilize the solver by selecting the fuel with the largest switching function value at any given time.
  3. Penalty Functions: The production plan was incorporated as a quadratic penalty term in the objective function to ensure tracking without excessive computational overhead.

Key Results

The proposed strategy was tested using real-world data from Nord Pool and a production plan from Energinet.dk. The results indicate substantial improvements over baseline methods:

  • Economic Performance: The continuous feedback/feedforward strategy achieved a 30% higher profit than discrete optimization. When 5% Gaussian noise was introduced to simulate real-world measurement errors, the profit gain increased to 45%.
  • Tracking Precision: The mean tracking error relative to the production plan was reduced from 14.73 MW to 3.40 MW.
  • Fuel Dynamics: The optimization successfully identified strategic uses for gas to handle rapid ramps where coal was insufficient, while avoiding the use of expensive oil for steady-state production.
Profit trends and corresponding fuel input signals over a 24-hour period.

Conclusion

The integration of PMP-based feedback control allows power plants to navigate market volatility more profitably. By identifying singular arcs and utilizing a robust iterative algorithm, operators can significantly enhance economic output while maintaining high tracking accuracy. Future work will focus on incorporating mechanical switching costs to reduce equipment wear and exploring real-time implementation via pseudo-spectral techniques.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kragelund2012profit,
  author = {Martin Kragelund and John Leth and Rafal Wisniewski and Ulf Jönsson},
  title = {{Profit Maximization of a Power Plant}},
  journal = {Eur. J. Control},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.3166/ejc.18.38-54},
}
Figure