Production of the Neurotoxin BMAA by a Marine Cyanobacterium

Sandra Anne Banack, Holly E. Johnson, Ran Cheng, Paul Alan CoxMarine 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the first detection of the potent neurotoxin $\beta$-methylamino-L-alanine (BMAA) in a free-living marine cyanobacterium species of the genus Nostoc. Using a battery of five analytical techniques, the researchers unequivocally confirmed BMAA production, suggesting a new potential route for human exposure and raising concerns about biomagnification in marine food webs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the growing concern surrounding cyanobacterial toxins and their potential impact on human health, particularly neurodegenerative diseases. While various cyanotoxins are known, $\beta$-methylamino-L-alanine (BMAA) has gained significant attention due to its association with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/Parkinsonism Dementia Complex (ALS/PDC) in Guam. Previously, BMAA was primarily linked to endosymbiotic cyanobacteria found in cycad roots. This study investigates whether BMAA is also produced by free-living marine cyanobacteria, which could expand the known sources of this neurotoxin and its potential for widespread environmental contamination and human exposure. The problem is to identify and confirm the presence of BMAA in a marine cyanobacterium, thereby broadening our understanding of its ecological distribution and potential health implications.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged analytical approach to definitively detect and quantify BMAA in laboratory cultures of a marine Nostoc sp. (strain CCMED-01). The key techniques used were:

  • Fluorescence Microscopy: Used to confirm the identity and morphology of the cyanobacterial culture as Nostoc.
  • High-Performance Liquid Chromatography with Fluorescence Detection (HPLC-FD): Used to detect and quantify free BMAA and total BMAA (free + protein-bound) in the samples. This method involved pre-column derivatization with a fluorescent tag (AQC) for enhanced sensitivity.
  • Ultra-Performance Liquid Chromatography with UV Detection (UPLC-UV): A faster and more sensitive chromatographic technique that also utilized AQC derivatization for BMAA detection.
  • Amino Acid Analyzer (AAA): This method used post-column derivatization with ninhydrin and is commonly employed in clinical settings for amino acid analysis. It provided an independent confirmation of BMAA's presence by analyzing its elution profile.
  • Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (LC/MS) and Triple Quadrupole LC/MS/MS: These advanced mass spectrometry techniques were crucial for verifying the molecular weight and fragmentation patterns of BMAA. LC/MS provided the mass of the derivatized BMAA, while LC/MS/MS allowed for detailed analysis of its fragmentation products, offering a high degree of confidence in its identification.

The use of five distinct analytical methods, each with different separation principles and detection mechanisms, was a deliberate strategy to provide "unequivocal demonstration" of BMAA's presence and minimize the possibility of false positives due to coelution or other analytical artifacts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized laboratory cultures of a marine Nostoc sp. (strain CCMED-01) and synthetic BMAA standards for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Marine Cyanobacteria as a Source of BMAA: The most significant insight is the discovery that a free-living marine Nostoc species can produce the neurotoxin BMAA. This expands the known ecological niche of BMAA production beyond terrestrial cycad symbionts.
  • Ubiquity of BMAA Production: The finding suggests that BMAA production might be more widespread among cyanobacteria than previously thought, potentially occurring in various aquatic environments.
  • Potential for Marine Food Web Contamination: The paper highlights the possibility of BMAA biomagnification in marine ecosystems, similar to what has been observed in terrestrial food chains. This is because BMAA can be incorporated into proteins, allowing it to accumulate and increase in concentration at higher trophic levels.
  • New Route for Human Exposure: The presence of BMAA in marine environments opens up a new pathway for human exposure, not just through traditional diets but potentially through consumption of seafood or even recreational water activities.
  • Relevance to Neurodegenerative Diseases: Given BMAA's known neurotoxicity, particularly its selective killing of motor neurons, its presence in marine ecosystems raises concerns about its potential contribution to sporadic cases of motor neuron diseases, especially in genetically vulnerable individuals.

Key Results

  • Unequivocal Detection of BMAA: The study successfully detected BMAA in the marine Nostoc sp. (CCMED-01) using five different analytical methods (HPLC-FD, UPLC-UV, AAA, LC/MS, and LC/MS/MS).
  • Quantification of BMAA:
    • HPLC-FD detected free BMAA at 7 µg/g and total BMAA at 10 µg/g in the marine Nostoc samples.
  • UPLC-UV detected BMAA at 25 µg/g.
  • Confirmation of Identity: LC/MS and LC/MS/MS provided strong evidence for BMAA's identity by confirming its molecular weight and fragmentation patterns, matching those of a synthetic standard.
  • Variation in Concentration: The study noted some variation in BMAA concentration in samples tested at different times, which was attributed to the dynamic nature of nitrogenase activity in marine cyanobacteria.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focused on a single strain of marine Nostoc. Further research is needed to determine if other marine cyanobacterial species also produce BMAA.
  • The study detected BMAA in laboratory cultures. Field studies are required to confirm its presence and concentration in natural marine environments.
  • While the potential for biomagnification is raised, this study did not directly investigate it in marine food webs.
  • Future Work:
    • Investigate the prevalence of BMAA production in other marine cyanobacterial species.
  • Conduct field studies to assess BMAA levels in marine ecosystems and its potential for biomagnification.
  • Explore the role of marine cyanobacteria in human exposure to BMAA, particularly in regions with high seafood consumption.
  • Further research into the link between BMAA exposure and gene/environment interactions in neurodegenerative diseases.
  • The authors suggest it is prudent to begin assembling baseline data on the presence of BMAA in water supplies and human diets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diverse species of cyanobacteria have recently been discovered to produce the neurotoxic non-protein amino acid beta-methylamino-L-alanine (BMAA). In Guam, BMAA has been studied as a possible environmental toxin in the diets of indigenous Chamorro people known to have high levels of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/ Parkinsonism Dementia Complex (ALS/PDC). BMAA has been found to accumulate in brain tissues of patients with progressive neurodegenerative illness in North America. In Guam, BMAA was found to be produced by endosymbiotic cyanobacteria of the genus Nostoc which live in specialized cycad roots. We here report detection of BMAA in laboratory cultures of a free-living marine species of Nostoc. We successfully detected BMAA in this marine species of Nostoc with five different methods: HPLC-FD, UPLC-UV, Amino Acid Analyzer, LC/MS, and Triple Quadrupole LC/MS/MS. This consensus of five different analytical methods unequivocally demonstrates the presence of BMAA in this marine cyanobacterium. Since protein-associated BMAA can accumulate in increasing levels within food chains, it is possible that biomagnification of BMAA could occur in marine ecosystems similar to the biomagnification of BMAA in terrestrial ecosystems. Production of BMAA by marine cyanobacteria may represent another route of human exposure to BMAA. Since BMAA at low concentrations causes the death of motor neurons, low levels of BMAA exposure may trigger motor neuron disease in genetically vulnerable individuals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{banack2007production,
  author = {Sandra Anne Banack and Holly E. Johnson and Ran Cheng and Paul Alan Cox},
  title = {{Production of the Neurotoxin BMAA by a Marine Cyanobacterium}},
  booktitle = {Marine},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.3390/md504180},
}
Figure