Production of Diverse Beauveriolide Analogs in Closely Related Fungi: a Rare Case of Fungal Chemodiversity

Ying Yin, Bo Chen, Shuangxiu Song, Bing Li, Xiuqing Yang, Chengshu WangmSphere 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a surprising disconnect between fungal relatedness and the chemical diversity of beauveriolides (BVDs) they produce. While a conserved gene cluster drives BVD synthesis across closely related insect-pathogenic fungi, the most closely related species produced the most structurally distinct BVDs, challenging traditional fungal chemotaxonomy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fungal chemotaxonomy, a method for classifying fungi based on their secondary metabolite profiles, relies on the assumption that closely related species produce similar compounds. This is often true because these metabolites are typically synthesized by conserved biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs). However, the extent of chemical diversity within these BGCs and how it relates to fungal speciation has remained an open question. This paper addresses this by investigating the production of beauveriolides (BVDs), a class of cyclodepsipeptides, in three insect-pathogenic fungi: Beauveria bassiana, Beauveria brongniartii, and Cordyceps militaris. The researchers aimed to understand how a conserved BGC leads to diverse BVD analogs and whether this diversity aligns with fungal evolutionary relationships.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genomic Analysis: They identified a conserved four-gene BGC responsible for BVD biosynthesis across the three fungal species. This involved using bioinformatics tools like BLAST to compare gene sequences and identify orthologous relationships.
  • Gene Deletion and Complementation: To confirm the function of specific genes within the BGC, they created null mutants by deleting key genes (e.g., NRPS, PKS components) in B. bassiana and B. brongniartii. They also complemented these mutants with genes from other species to investigate functional interchangeability.
  • Metabolite Profiling: High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) was used to analyze the BVDs produced by wild-type strains and gene deletion mutants. This allowed for the separation and comparison of different BVD analogs.
  • Structure Elucidation: Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, including 2D NMR, was used to determine the precise chemical structures of the identified BVDs.
  • Substrate Feeding Assays: To understand the substrate specificity of the BVD biosynthetic pathway, the researchers fed specific fatty acids (FAs) and amino acids to mutant strains and analyzed the resulting metabolites.
  • Insect Bioassays: To assess the role of BVDs in fungal virulence, they conducted survival assays using fruit flies (Drosophila melanogaster) and wax moth larvae (Galleria mellonella) infected with wild-type and BVD-nonproducing mutant strains.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on analyzing the genomes of the studied fungal species and the metabolites they produce.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chemotaxonomic Incongruence: The most striking finding is that the most closely related fungal species (B. bassiana and B. brongniartii) produced structurally distinct BVD analogs, while the less closely related species (B. brongniartii and C. militaris) produced structurally similar congeners. This directly challenges the premise of fungal chemotaxonomy.
  • Conserved BGC, Diverse Output: A single, conserved four-gene BGC is responsible for BVD biosynthesis across all three species, highlighting the plasticity of BGCs in generating chemical diversity.
  • PKS Substrate Specificity is Key: The polyketide synthase (PKS) component of the BGC appears to be a major determinant of BVD diversity, specifically in its ability to produce different 3-hydroxy fatty acids (HMOA and HMDA) of varying chain lengths.
  • NRPS A-domain Selectivity Matters: While the overall BGC is conserved, the phylogenetic analysis of NRPS A-domains suggests that their specific signatures are more aligned with fungal speciation, indicating a role in determining the specific amino acid incorporation.
  • BVDs and Virulence are Host-Dependent: BVDs contribute to fungal virulence, but this contribution is dependent on the insect species. B. bassiana and B. brongniartii mutants lacking BVD production showed reduced virulence against fruit flies but not wax moth larvae.

Key Results

  • Three insect-pathogenic fungi (B. bassiana, B. brongniartii, and C. militaris) were found to produce beauveriolides (BVDs).
  • A conserved four-gene BGC (besA-D) was identified in all three species, responsible for BVD biosynthesis.
  • B. bassiana produced distinct HMDA-type BVDs (Ba, Ka, Ca), while B. brongniartii and C. militaris predominantly produced HMOA-type BVDs (seven of nine identified in these species).
  • Phylogenetic analysis of NRPS A-domains showed congruence with fungal speciation, suggesting their role in determining amino acid incorporation.
  • Feeding assays revealed that the PKS component can utilize 3-hydroxyoctanoic acid (3-HOA) and 3-hydroxydecanoic acid (3-HDA) but not longer chain fatty acids for BVD biosynthesis.
  • BVD-nonproducing mutants of B. bassiana and B. brongniartii exhibited significantly reduced virulence against Drosophila melanogaster but not against Galleria mellonella larvae.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of D-amino Acid Formation: While an epimerase (E) domain in the NRPS BesA is proposed to be responsible for converting L-amino acids to D-amino acids, the exact mechanism and its specificity remain to be fully elucidated.
  • Role of BesC: The null mutant of the acyltransferase gene besC still produced BVDs, albeit at reduced levels. This suggests a potential complementary role for other acyltransferase genes, which warrants further investigation.
  • Strain-Level Diversity: The study examined specific strains. It remains to be investigated whether different strains within the same species might produce different BVD congeners.
  • Exact Biological Role of BVDs: While a contribution to virulence is shown, the precise biological roles of BVDs in fungal-insect interactions, especially in non-susceptible hosts, require further determination.
  • HGT of BGCs: The study speculates on horizontal gene transfer (HGT) as a mechanism for BGC distribution, but the exact pathways and evolutionary history of the BVD BGC remain to be fully determined.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fungal chemodiversity is well known in part due to the production of diverse analogous compounds by a single biosynthetic gene cluster (BGC). Usually, similar or the same metabolites are produced by closely related fungal species under a given condition, the foundation of fungal chemotaxonomy. Here, we report a rare case of the production of the cyclodepsipeptide beauveriolides (BVDs) in three insect-pathogenic fungi. We found that the more closely related fungi <i>Beauveria bassiana</i> and <i>Beauveria brongniartii</i> produced structurally distinct analogs of BVDs, whereas the less-close relatives <i>B. brongniartii</i> and <i>Cordyceps militaris</i> biosynthesized structurally similar congeners under the same growth condition. It was verified that a conserved BGC containing four genes is responsible for BVD biosynthesis in three fungi, including a polyketide synthase (PKS) for the production of 3-hydroxy fatty acids (FAs) with chain length variations. In contrast to BVD production patterns, phylogenetic analysis of the BGC enzymes or enzyme domains largely resulted in the congruence relationship with fungal speciation. Feeding assays demonstrated that an FA with a chain length of eight carbon atoms was preferentially utilized, whereas an FA with a chain longer than 10 carbon atoms could not be used as a substrate for BVD biosynthesis. Insect survival assays suggested that the contribution of BVDs to fungal virulence might be associated with the susceptibility of insect species. The results of this study enrich the knowledge of fungal secondary metabolic diversity that can question the reliability of fungal chemotaxonomy.<b>IMPORTANCE</b> Fungal chemotaxonomy is an approach to classify fungi based on the fungal production profile of metabolites, especially the secondary metabolites. We found an atypical example that could question the reliability of fungal chemical classifications in this study, i.e., the more closely related entomopathogenic species <i>Beauveria bassiana</i> and <i>Beauveria brongniartii</i> produced structurally different congeners of the cyclodepsipeptide beauveriolides, whereas the rather divergent species <i>B. brongniartii</i> and <i>Cordyceps militaris</i> biosynthesized similar analogs under the same growth condition. The conserved biosynthetic gene cluster (BGC) containing four genes present in each species is responsible for beauveriolide production. In contrast to the compound formation profiles, the phylogenies of biosynthetic enzymes or enzymatic domains show associations with fungal speciation. Dependent on the insect species, production of beauveriolides may contribute to fungal virulence against the susceptible insect hosts. The findings in this study augment the diversity of fungal secondary metabolisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yin2020production,
  author = {Ying Yin and Bo Chen and Shuangxiu Song and Bing Li and Xiuqing Yang and Chengshu Wang},
  title = {{Production of Diverse Beauveriolide Analogs in Closely Related Fungi: a Rare Case of Fungal Chemodiversity}},
  booktitle = {mSphere},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1128/msphere.00667-20},
}
Figure