TL;DR
This paper details the successful development of a continuous-flow hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) process for converting wet algae biomass into a biocrude oil. The system efficiently processes high-solids algae slurries, and subsequent hydrotreating and gasification steps create upgradeable fuel components and clean water for nutrient recycling, paving the way for scalable algae-based biofuel production.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The production of biofuels from algae holds significant promise due to algae's rapid growth rates and ability to be cultivated on non-arable land. However, a major hurdle has been the energy-intensive process of drying wet algae biomass before thermochemical conversion. Hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) offers a solution by processing wet biomass directly, but previous research has largely been limited to batch reactors, which are not ideal for industrial scale-up. Furthermore, the resulting biocrude often contains significant amounts of oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur, requiring further upgrading. The aqueous byproduct from HTL also contains valuable nutrients that could be recycled, but its composition needs to be managed. This paper addresses the need for a continuous-flow HTL process that can handle high-solids algae, produce an upgradeable biocrude, and effectively manage the byproducts for a more sustainable and economically viable biofuel production pathway.
Methods
The researchers developed and utilized a continuous-flow reactor system for their experiments. This system, originally designed for catalytic hydrothermal gasification (CHG), was adapted for HTL. Key components included a high-pressure pump feeding system, a stirred tank preheater, and a tubular catalytic reactor. For HTL, the catalyst bed was omitted, and the system was reconfigured to allow for the separation of the biocrude oil and the aqueous byproduct.
Following HTL, the produced biocrude underwent catalytic hydrotreating (HT) in a separate bench-scale, fixed-bed catalytic reactor system. This process aimed to remove heteroatoms (oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur) and upgrade the biocrude into hydrocarbon fuel components.
The aqueous byproduct from HTL was then subjected to catalytic hydrothermal gasification (CHG) in a continuous-flow reactor. This step aimed to clean up the water by converting dissolved organic components into fuel gas and to recover valuable nutrients for potential recycling.
A critical aspect of the methodology was the ability to recover the biocrude by gravity separation without the need for solvents, which simplifies the process and avoids potential contamination of the product.
Datasets
The study utilized four different types of algae feedstocks:
- Lipid Extracted Algae (LEA) from Solix.
- NB238 product from Texas A&M University.
- Two types of algae from Cellana, produced using their patented ALDUO™ system: one harvested after high growth (low lipid = AGLL) and one harvested after stressed, low-growth conditions (high lipid = AGHL).
These algae were all Nannochloropsis sp. and were provided by partners of the National Alliance for Advanced Biofuels & Bioproducts (NAABB). Feedstock analyses, including carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur, ash content, density, pH, and dry solid content, were performed and are presented in Table 2.
Key Insights and Ideas
- High-Solids Processing: The continuous-flow HTL system successfully processed algae slurries with high dry solids concentrations (up to 35 wt.%) without significant issues, a key advantage over previous batch studies.
- Solvent-Free Biocrude Recovery: Gravity separation of the biocrude without solvents simplifies the process and provides a more accurate yield and composition analysis.
- Upgradeable Biocrude: Catalytic hydrotreating effectively removed heteroatoms (oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur) from the biocrude, producing a product that is largely hydrocarbon-based and suitable for blending into diesel fuel.
- Nutrient and Energy Recovery from Aqueous Phase: Catalytic hydrothermal gasification of the aqueous byproduct efficiently converted dissolved organics into fuel gas and significantly reduced the chemical oxygen demand (COD), making the water suitable for nutrient recycling to algae cultivation ponds.
- Ammonia in Gas Product: A novel finding was the significant presence of ammonia in the gas product from CHG, which was not reported in previous studies, suggesting a new avenue for nitrogen recovery.
- Low Mineral Precipitation: The algae feedstocks had low ash content, leading to minimal mineral precipitation and eliminating the need for mineral blowdown during processing.
Key Results
- HTL Yield: High carbon conversion to gravity-separable biocrude product was achieved at 350 °C and 20 MPa. Biocrude yields ranged from approximately 38 wt.% to 63.6 wt.% (dry, ash-free basis) depending on the algae feedstock.
- Biocrude Composition: The biocrude was primarily composed of hydrocarbons (around 77-79 wt.% carbon, 10-10.6 wt.% hydrogen, and 5.3-8 wt.% oxygen). Nitrogen content was significant (4-4.7 wt.%), and sulfur content was around 0.3-0.5 wt.%.
- Hydrotreating Effectiveness: Hydrotreating reduced oxygen content to very low levels (<0.05-1.8 wt.%), nitrogen to <0.05-0.25 wt.%, and sulfur to <50 ppm. The hydrotreated oil had properties suitable for blending into diesel fuel, with approximately 80-85% falling within the diesel range based on simulated distillation.
- CHG Efficiency: Catalytic hydrothermal gasification of the aqueous byproduct reduced COD by 98.8-99.8%, indicating effective removal of organic contaminants. The gas product was primarily methane (59-66 vol.%) and carbon dioxide (28-42 vol.%).
- Nutrient Balance: Nitrogen was largely recovered in the aqueous effluent and gas product, with some also present in the oil. Phosphorus was primarily recovered in precipitated solids.
Limitations and Future Work
- Ammonia Analysis: The ammonia analysis in the gas product was approximate and requires further detailed analysis to confirm.
- Nitrogen Balance: While nitrogen balances were closer than phosphorus, they still showed some over-reporting in products, suggesting potential for refinement in analytical methods or understanding of nitrogen partitioning.
- Chloride Management: The presence of high chloride concentrations in algae grown in marine environments warrants further investigation into chloride management and potential corrosion assessment, although no corrosion was observed in these tests.
- Process Scale-Up: While the bench-scale continuous-flow systems were developed, further process development is needed to scale up the technology for industrial demonstration.
- Economic Assessment: While an economic assessment was mentioned as being made based on the data, detailed economic figures are not presented in this paper.
- Nutrient Recycle Optimization: Further work is needed to optimize the recovery and recycle of nutrients (P, N, K) from the byproducts, which is crucial for improving process cost savings and sustainability.
- Catalyst Development: Optimization of liquefaction and gasification process variables and demonstrating the effectiveness of separation techniques to remove precipitated nutrients before catalyst poisoning are areas for future research.
Summary updated