Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Natural Language Reasoning and Structured Explanations (NLRSE)

Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Greg Durrett, Peter Jansen, Danilo Neves Ribeiro, Jason WeiACL 2023

TL;DR

This document presents the proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Natural Language Reasoning and Structured Explanations (NLRSE), held at ACL 2023. The workshop brought together researchers to explore how structured explanations can enhance natural language reasoning in AI, addressing the "black box" nature of large language models and bridging classical AI, explainable ML, and cognitive science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid advancement of large pre-trained Transformer language models (LLMs) has expanded the capabilities of Natural Language Processing (NLP). However, a significant challenge remains in understanding why these models arrive at their answers, particularly for tasks requiring complex natural language reasoning. Traditional question-answering datasets have evolved from simple extraction to multi-hop reasoning, but the interpretability of LLM reasoning processes is still lacking. This workshop aims to bridge this gap by focusing on structured explanations, which can provide a more transparent and verifiable path for LLMs to mimic human reasoning. The workshop seeks to foster a common ground for methods that blend explainable AI, classical AI techniques (like theorem proving), and insights from cognitive science to tackle reasoning problems in natural language.

Methods

The workshop proceedings showcase a variety of approaches to natural language reasoning and structured explanations. While the proceedings themselves are a collection of papers and not a single research paper with a unified methodology, the presented works explore several key themes:

  • Knowledge Graph Augmentation: Several papers investigate how to integrate knowledge graphs with language models to improve reasoning capabilities, particularly for complex question answering.
  • Prompt-based Few-Shot Learning: Techniques are explored to generate commonsense explanations using prompt-based methods, enabling LLMs to learn from limited examples.
  • Saliency Map Verbalization: This involves comparing different methods for translating feature importance representations (saliency maps) into natural language explanations.
  • Planning for Semantic Parsing: The use of planning techniques is investigated to enhance the semantic parsing of instructional texts.
  • Reasoning Circuits: This approach focuses on generating multi-hop questions with structured rationales, aiming to improve reasoning.
  • Knowledge-Augmented Prompting: Methods for zero-shot knowledge graph question answering are explored by augmenting language model prompts with knowledge.
  • In-context Learning: The ability of LLMs to learn reasoning concepts from demonstrations provided in context is examined.
  • Effect Graph Extraction: Research into extracting "effect graphs" to generate explanations for causal relationships.
  • Role of Explanations in Finetuning and Prompting: Investigating how explanations can be leveraged to improve the reasoning skills of LLMs through finetuning and prompting.
  • Deductive Additivity for Proof Planning: Applying deductive additivity principles to plan natural language proofs.
  • Synthetic Dataset Generation: Creating synthetic datasets to evaluate complex compositional knowledge in natural language inference.

Datasets

The workshop proceedings feature research that utilizes and, in some cases, introduces new datasets for evaluating natural language reasoning and explanation generation. While a comprehensive list of all datasets used across all papers is not provided in the introductory sections, the following are mentioned or implied:

  • SQuAD: Mentioned as a precursor to more complex question-answering datasets.
  • HotpotQA: A multi-hop reasoning dataset.
  • StrategyQA: Another dataset for multi-hop reasoning.
  • Code Prompts: Used in the paper "Exploring the Curious Case of Code Prompts."
  • Instructional Texts: Used in the paper "Using Planning to Improve Semantic Parsing of Instructional Texts."
  • Knowledge Graphs: Utilized in papers focusing on knowledge-augmented models.
  • Synthetic Datasets: The paper "Synthetic Dataset for Evaluating Complex Compositional Knowledge for Natural Language Inference" introduces a newly created benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Black Box" Problem is Critical: The workshop highlights the growing concern that while LLMs are powerful, their internal reasoning processes are opaque, hindering trust and debugging.
  • Structured Explanations are Key: There's a strong consensus that providing structured, step-by-step explanations is crucial for making LLM reasoning more transparent and reliable.
  • Interdisciplinary Approach is Necessary: Effective natural language reasoning and explanation generation will likely require drawing from diverse fields like classical AI, cognitive science, and explainable machine learning.
  • Prompting is a Powerful Tool: Prompt engineering and few-shot learning are emerging as effective ways to elicit reasoning and explanations from LLMs without extensive retraining.
  • Beyond Textual Answers: The focus is shifting from just generating correct answers to generating understandable and verifiable reasoning paths.
  • Evaluation is Challenging: Developing robust evaluation metrics for the quality and faithfulness of generated explanations remains an open research question.

Key Results

The proceedings contain 12 papers, with 4 presented as oral presentations and the rest as archival or non-archival submissions. Specific quantitative results are detailed within each individual paper, which are not summarized here. However, the overall trend indicates progress in:

  • Improving performance on complex reasoning tasks by integrating external knowledge or structured reasoning mechanisms.
  • Generating more coherent and interpretable explanations for LLM outputs.
  • Demonstrating the potential of LLMs to learn reasoning patterns through in-context learning and prompting.

Limitations and Future Work

The introductory sections of the proceedings highlight several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Understanding LLM Reasoning: A fundamental limitation is the ongoing difficulty in fully understanding and controlling the reasoning processes within LLMs.
  • Bridging Different Traditions: Establishing a truly common ground between classical AI, explainable ML, and cognitive science is a significant ongoing challenge.
  • Evaluation of Explanations: Developing comprehensive and reliable methods for evaluating the quality, faithfulness, and usefulness of generated explanations is a critical area for future work.
  • Scalability and Generalization: Ensuring that reasoning and explanation techniques scale to more complex tasks and generalize across different domains remains an important research goal.
  • Human-AI Collaboration: Future work will likely focus on how structured explanations can facilitate better collaboration between humans and AI systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mishra2023proceedings,
  author = {Bhavana Dalvi Mishra and Greg Durrett and Peter Jansen and Danilo Neves Ribeiro and Jason Wei},
  title = {{Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Natural Language Reasoning and Structured Explanations (NLRSE)}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure