Problems Faced by Nurses in Providing Quality Care to the Patients

Anjum Khurshid, Asmat ParveenInternational Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study highlights critical challenges faced by nurses in providing quality patient care in Srinagar's associated hospitals, primarily stemming from a lack of equipment, insufficient staffing, and limited opportunities for professional development. Addressing these issues through a multidisciplinary approach, social commitment, and political will is crucial for improving healthcare outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the significant gap between the ideal of high-quality patient care and the reality faced by nurses in healthcare settings. It specifically investigates the problems encountered by nurses in providing quality care within the associated hospitals of Government Medical College, Srinagar. The authors emphasize that nurses are integral to a robust healthcare system, yet they face numerous obstacles that hinder their ability to deliver optimal care. These challenges not only impact patient outcomes but also contribute to nurse burnout and shortages, creating a vicious cycle. The study aims to identify and quantify these problems to inform potential solutions.

Methods

The study employed a descriptive survey design to assess the problems faced by nurses. The target population comprised 415 nurses from four associated hospitals of Government Medical College, Srinagar. A simple random sampling technique was used to select a sample of 96 nurses, with 24 nurses chosen from each hospital. Data was collected using a self-administered questionnaire. This questionnaire had two parts: one for collecting bio-data and the other for gathering information on the problems nurses encountered in providing quality care. The researchers were available to clarify doubts during the questionnaire completion process, and efforts were made to ensure responses were provided directly by the participants.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a self-administered questionnaire as its data collection tool.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resource Scarcity is Paramount: The most frequently cited problem is the lack of essential equipment and supplies, directly impeding nurses' ability to provide effective care. This points to a fundamental issue of resource allocation and management within the healthcare facilities.
  • The Education-Quality Link: A significant finding is the strong correlation between limited opportunities for higher education for nurses and the inability to provide quality care. This suggests that investing in nurses' professional development is not just about career advancement but is directly tied to patient outcomes.
  • Staffing Shortages are Critical: The shortage of nursing professionals is identified as a major contributor to the decline in quality care. This highlights the need for strategic recruitment and retention efforts.
  • Infrastructure Matters: Inadequate physical facilities (infrastructure) also emerged as a notable problem, underscoring the importance of a well-equipped and conducive working environment.
  • Teamwork is Essential: Poor coordination and cooperation among nursing, medical, and other hospital staff were identified as a problem, indicating that interdisciplinary collaboration is vital for seamless patient care.
  • Nursing is Predominantly Female: The data reveals a significant gender disparity, with a vast majority of nurses being female. This observation leads to a call for encouraging male participation in the nursing profession to broaden the talent pool.

Key Results

The study's results reveal several critical issues:

  • Lack of Equipment & Supplies: 88 responses (91.6%) indicated that quality care cannot be provided due to a lack of equipment and supplies.
  • Staff Shortage: 73 responses (76.0%) identified a lack or shortage of nursing professionals as a reason for inadequate quality care.
  • Limited Higher Education Opportunities: 77 responses (80.2%) pointed to less opportunity for higher education as a factor responsible for quality care issues.
  • Infrastructure Deficiencies: 39 responses (40.0%) cited a lack of infrastructure (physical facilities) as a reason for inadequate nursing care.
  • Coordination Issues: 19 responses (19.7%) highlighted a lack of coordination and cooperation among healthcare staff as a problem.
  • Negligence: Only 8 responses (0.08%) attributed poor quality care to negligence of nursing staff.

Regarding professional education, the majority of respondents held General Nursing and Midwifery (GNM) qualifications (67.7%), with a smaller percentage having Post-Basic Nursing (8.3%) or B.Sc. Nursing (10.4%). No respondents held a PhD.

In terms of roles, most nurses were technical nurses (64), with fewer in charge (21) or supervisor (11) roles.

The study also found that 80.02% of respondents were female, suggesting nursing is a female-oriented profession in the region.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the standard of nursing care needs significant improvement. They suggest that a multidisciplinary approach, alongside social and political commitment, is essential to enhance the quality of care provided to healthcare consumers. Future work could focus on implementing and evaluating interventions based on these findings, exploring the specific types of equipment and supplies that are most critically lacking, and investigating strategies to improve interdisciplinary communication and collaboration within hospitals. The call to introduce male nursing also suggests a direction for future initiatives aimed at diversifying the nursing workforce.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Nurses are the unsung heroes that play an integral role in the healthcare industry by providing care to the patients as well as carrying out leadership roles in hospitals, health systems and other organizations. To have a robust healthcare system, the importance of nurses in healthcare should be underlined for attempting to create a better task force for better quality care for all. There are certain problems which the Nurses in the present healthcare system face. This study aims to assess the problems faced by nurses in providing patient care among the associated hospitals of Government Medical College, Srinagar. Methods: A descriptive, study was conducted among 415 Nurses working in the 4 associated hospitals of GMC Srinagar. Simple random sampling was used to select a sample size of 96 nurses, 24 from each hospital. Data was collected using a self administered questionnaire. Results: 88 responses say that quality care cannot be provided because of lack of equipment & suppolies.77 Reponses express that nurses don’t have higher education opportunities, 73 responses express that lack/shortage of nursing professionals is one of the reasons for lack of quality care in hospitals. Lack of infrastructure (physical facilities) is also one of the reasons expressed by 39 respondents for inadequate quality of nursing care. Lack of co-ordination & co-operation among nursing, medical and other workers in hospital is a point for poor quality care that exists in hospitals and it is expressed by 19respondents.8responses say that negligence of nursing staff results in poor quality of care. . Therefore multidisciplinary approach to improve health care to consumers is essential aspect which is to be stressed upon. Besides multidisciplinary approach social commitment along with political commitment is required to improve quality care to health care consumers in hospitals.
BibTeX
@article{khurshid2021problems,
  author = {Anjum Khurshid and Asmat Parveen},
  title = {{Problems Faced by Nurses in Providing Quality Care to the Patients}},
  journal = {International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21275/sr21123232731},
}
Figure