Probing the radio emission from air showers with polarization measurements

A. Aab, P. Abreu, M. Aglietta, M. Ahlers, E. J. Ahn, I. F. M. Albuquerque, I. Allekotte, J. Allen, P. Allison, A. Almela, J. Alvarez Castillo, Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz, Rafael Alves Batista, M. Ambrosio, A. Aminaei, Luis A. Anchordoqui, S. Andringa, T. Antičić, C. Aramo, F. Arqueros, H. Asorey, P. Assis, J. Aublin, M. Ave, M. Avenier, G. Ávila, Alina Mihaela Badescu, K. B. Barber, R. Bardenet, J. Bäuml, C. Baus, J. J. Beatty, K.-h. Becker, Jose A. Bellido, S. BenZvi, C. Bérat, X. Bertou, Peter L. Biermann, P. Billoir, F. Blanco, C. Bleve, H. Blümer, Teresa Bister, Denise Boncioli, C. Bonifazi, R. Bonino, Nataliia Borodai, J. Brack, I.m. Brâncuş, P. Brogueira, W. C. Brown, P. Buchholz, A. Bueno, Mario Buscemi, K. S. Caballero‐Mora, B. Caccianiga, Lorenzo Caccianiga, M. Candusso, L. Caramete, R. Caruso, A. Castellina, G. Cataldi, Lorenzo Cazon, R. Cester, S. H. Cheng, A. Chiavassa, J. A. Chinellato, J. Chudoba, M. Cilmo, R. W. Clay, G. Cocciolo, Roberta Colalillo, L. Collica, M. R. Coluccia, R. Conceição, F. Contreras, M. J. Cooper, S. Coutu, C. E. Covault, A. Criss, J. Cronin, A. Curutiu, R. Dallier, B. Daniel, S. Dasso, K. Daumiller, B. R. Dawson, R. M. de Almeida, Manlio De Domenico, S. J. de Jong, G. De La Vega, W. J. M. de Mello, A. De Roeck, I. De Mitri, V. de Souza, K. D. de Vries, L. del Peral, O. Deligny, H.-p. DembinskiPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the radio emission from cosmic ray air showers, specifically focusing on the polarization of the emitted radio waves. By analyzing data from the Pierre Auger Observatory, the researchers found evidence for a second emission mechanism beyond the previously understood geomagnetic effect, which is radially polarized and consistent with Askaryan's charge-excess model. This work helps refine our understanding of how cosmic rays interact with the atmosphere and produce detectable radio signals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When high-energy cosmic rays strike Earth's atmosphere, they trigger a cascade of secondary particles known as an air shower. Understanding the properties of these primary cosmic rays (energy, direction, composition) relies on accurately detecting and interpreting the signals produced by these showers. While the geomagnetic emission process, where the Earth's magnetic field influences charged particles in the shower front, has been a well-established source of radio emission, there was evidence suggesting other emission mechanisms might be at play. This paper aims to disentangle these different emission processes by analyzing the polarization of the radio signals, seeking to confirm or refute the existence and characteristics of non-geomagnetic emission components.

Methods

The study utilizes data from the Pierre Auger Observatory's Auger Engineering Radio Array (AERA). The radio-detection system employs dual-polarized logarithmic periodic dipole antennas (LPDAs) sensitive to radio signals around 56 MHz. These antennas are oriented to capture signals along the North-South and East-West directions. The researchers employed a sophisticated data analysis pipeline that involved:

  • Coincidence detection: Ensuring that registered radio signals were indeed correlated with air showers detected by the observatory's surface detector (SD).
  • Signal cleaning: Removing interference from narrow-band transmitters using linear prediction and Fourier transform methods.
  • Hilbert transformation: Used to reconstruct the analytic signal and determine the electric field vector.
  • Polarization analysis: Calculating the polarization angle (φp) and a parameter 'R' which quantifies the deviation from pure geomagnetic emission. This involved defining a rotated coordinate system (ξ, η) to separate the contributions of geomagnetic and charge-excess emission.
  • Comparison with simulations: The experimental results were compared against predictions from various simulation codes (CoREAS, EVA1.01, REAS3.1, SELFAS, ZHAireS, MGMR) that model different aspects of air shower development and radio emission.

Datasets

The study used two datasets:

  • AERA24: Data collected during the commissioning phase of AERA, consisting of 24 radio-detection stations.
  • AERA prototype: Data from an earlier prototype setup of AERA.

Both datasets were correlated with data from the Pierre Auger Observatory's surface detector (SD) to identify air shower events. No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing data in conjunction with established simulation models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Geomagnetic Emission: The most significant finding is the strong evidence for a second, radially polarized electric field component in the radio emission from air showers, in addition to the expected geomagnetic component.
  • Askaryan's Model Confirmation: This radial component aligns remarkably well with the predictions of Askaryan's model, which describes radio emission arising from a negative charge excess in the shower front.
  • Polarization as a Diagnostic Tool: The study highlights the power of polarization measurements in disentangling complex emission mechanisms in astrophysical phenomena. Different emission processes have distinct polarization signatures.
  • Model Performance: The comparison with various simulation codes reveals that models incorporating the charge-excess mechanism significantly improve the agreement with the measured data, underscoring its importance.

Key Results

  • The radio emission from air showers is dominated by the geomagnetic emission process.
  • A significant fraction, on average (14±2)%, of the radio emission is attributed to a radial component consistent with the charge-excess mechanism.
  • The inclusion of the charge-excess mechanism in simulations substantially improves the correlation coefficients (e.g., Pearson correlation coefficient increased from 0.82±0.04 to 0.93±0.03 for the AERA24 data) and reduces the reduced χ² values.
  • The analysis of the prototype data also supports these findings, with a radial component strength of (11±7)% and a reduced χ² value of 0.11±0.07.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Completeness: While the inclusion of the charge-excess mechanism significantly improves agreement, the models do not fully describe the present data set. This suggests that further refinements of the models might be necessary.
  • Systematic Errors: The authors suggest that an underestimate of systematic errors in the data or the effect of strong atmospheric electric fields could contribute to the discrepancies.
  • Future Directions: The paper implies that further investigation into the modeling of emission processes and a more precise understanding of systematic uncertainties are needed. The authors also mention that the comparison between model calculations and prototype data is presented in Appendix C, indicating a broader scope of analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

The emission of radio waves from air showers has been attributed to the so-called geomagnetic emission process. At frequencies around 50 MHz this process leads to coherent radiation which can be observed with rather simple setups. The direction of the electric field induced by this emission process depends only on the local magnetic field vector and on the incoming direction of the air shower. We report on measurements of the electric field vector where, in addition to this geomagnetic component, another component has been observed that cannot be described by the geomagnetic emission process. The data provide strong evidence that the other electric field component is polarized radially with respect to the shower axis, in agreement with predictions made by Askaryan who described radio emission from particle showers due to a negative charge excess in the front of the shower. Our results are compared to calculations which include the radiation mechanism induced by this charge-excess process.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aab2014probing,
  author = {A. Aab and P. Abreu and M. Aglietta and M. Ahlers and E. J. Ahn and I. F. M. Albuquerque and I. Allekotte and J. Allen and P. Allison and A. Almela and J. Alvarez Castillo and Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz and Rafael Alves Batista and M. Ambrosio and A. Aminaei and Luis A. Anchordoqui and S. Andringa and T. Antičić and C. Aramo and F. Arqueros and H. Asorey and P. Assis and J. Aublin and M. Ave and M. Avenier and G. Ávila and Alina Mihaela Badescu and K. B. Barber and R. Bardenet and J. Bäuml and C. Baus and J. J. Beatty and K.-H. Becker and Jose A. Bellido and S. BenZvi and C. Bérat and X. Bertou and Peter L. Biermann and P. Billoir and F. Blanco and F. Blanco and C. Bleve and H. Blümer and Teresa Bister and Denise Boncioli and C. Bonifazi and R. Bonino and Nataliia Borodai and J. Brack and I.M. Brâncuş and P. Brogueira and W. C. Brown and P. Buchholz and A. Bueno and Mario Buscemi and K. S. Caballero‐Mora and B. Caccianiga and Lorenzo Caccianiga and M. Candusso and L. Caramete and R. Caruso and A. Castellina and G. Cataldi and Lorenzo Cazon and R. Cester and S. H. Cheng and A. Chiavassa and J. A. Chinellato and J. Chudoba and M. Cilmo and R. W. Clay and G. Cocciolo and Roberta Colalillo and L. Collica and M. R. Coluccia and R. Conceição and F. Contreras and M. J. Cooper and S. Coutu and C. E. Covault and A. Criss and J. Cronin and A. Curutiu and R. Dallier and B. Daniel and S. Dasso and K. Daumiller and B. R. Dawson and R. M. de Almeida and Manlio De Domenico and S. J. de Jong and G. De La Vega and W. J. M. de Mello and A. De Roeck and I. De Mitri and V. de Souza and K. D. de Vries and L. del Peral and O. Deligny and H.-P. Dembinski},
  title = {{Probing the radio emission from air showers with polarization measurements}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.89.052002},
}
Figure