Probing the CR positron/electron ratio at few hundreds GeV through Moon shadow observation with the MAGIC telescopes

P. Colin, Daniela Borla Tridon, Alicia Diago Ortega, Marlene Doert, M. Doro, Jonathan Pochon, N. Strah, Tihomir Surić, M. TeshimaarXiv 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The antimatter components measured in the Cosmic Ray (CR) flux are thought as secondary particles induced by the propagation of galactic CRs within the galaxy. Recent results from the PAMELA experiment show an unexpected increase of the positron electron ratio above 10 GeV. There could be different interpretations to explain that result, the most discussed ones being the signature of nearby compact astrophysical source(s) or of dark matter annihilation/decay. Probing the positron-fraction rise above 100 GeV would help to disentangle among different scenarios. Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes (IACT) can extract the cosmic lepton signal from the hadronic CR background between a few hundred GeV and a few TeV and reconstruct energy and incident direction with a very good resolution. In addition, by using the natural spectrometer formed by the Moon and the geomagnetic field, it is possible to measure the positron/electron ratio at the TeV regime through the observation of the CR Moon shadow. Despite the technique is particularly challenging because of the high background light induced by the Moon and the treatment of data, the MAGIC collaboration has performed for the first time such observations in 2010 and 2011. Here we present the observation strategy and the performance achieved during this campaign.

Introduction: The Positron Anomaly

In standard models of cosmic ray (CR) propagation, positrons are produced as secondary particles through collisions between primary CRs and interstellar gas. These models predict a steady decrease in the positron fraction at higher energies. However, data from experiments like PAMELA, Fermi-LAT, and AMS-01 have revealed a striking "positron anomaly": above 10 GeV, the positron fraction begins to rise significantly.

Cosmic ray electron and positron measurements from various experiments, highlighting the unexpected rise in the positron fraction above 10 GeV.

This surplus suggests the existence of primary positron sources, such as dark matter annihilation or nearby pulsars. To distinguish between these competing theories, measurements must be extended into the hundreds of GeV to TeV range. Satellite detectors lack the collection area for such high-energy particles, while traditional ground-based telescopes struggle to differentiate between electrons and positrons due to their identical mass and opposite charge.

Methodology: The Earth/Moon Spectrometer

The MAGIC collaboration utilizes a unique "astrophysical hack" known as the Earth/Moon spectrometer technique to separate these particles. This method relies on two natural components:

  1. The Moon as a Shield: The Moon physically blocks cosmic rays, creating a "shadow" in the isotropic particle flux.
  2. The Earth's Magnetic Field as a Prism: As charged particles approach Earth, the geomagnetic field deflects them. Because electrons and positrons have opposite charges, they are deflected in opposite directions—electrons toward the East and positrons toward the West.
Simulated deflection of electrons in the Earth's magnetic field relative to the Moon's position at different energies, illustrating the formation of the Moon shadow.

The degree of deflection is proportional to the particle's charge and inversely proportional to its energy. For instance, at 1 TeV, the typical deviation is approximately 1.5°. By observing the position and depth of these shadows, researchers can determine the relative abundance of electrons and positrons.

Technical Challenges and Performance

Observing with Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes (IACTs) like MAGIC near a bright Moon is exceptionally difficult. IACTs are designed to detect faint Cherenkov light against a dark sky; the Moon's brightness acts as a massive background noise source. To overcome this, the MAGIC team implemented several hardware and software modifications:

  • Reduced Gain: The high voltage to the photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) was lowered to prevent saturation.
  • Wobble Observations: Telescopes were pointed at alternating sides of the expected shadow to mitigate systematic errors.
  • Aggressive Image Cleaning: New algorithms were developed to filter out the intense Night Sky Background (NSB).

Calibration was performed using the Crab Nebula as a "standard candle." Observations of the Crab under high-moonlight conditions demonstrated that MAGIC could maintain a sensitivity of 1.2% of the Crab flux over 50 hours, with an angular resolution better than 0.1°. The energy threshold achieved after image cleaning was approximately 200 GeV at a 30° zenith angle.

Results and Outlook

The 2010-2011 observation campaigns established the feasibility of this technique. Preliminary estimates suggest that detecting the electron shadow requires roughly 50 hours of observation time, while the rarer positron shadow requires over 100 hours. Given the limited window for these observations (specific Moon phases and low zenith angles), a definitive measurement of the positron/electron ratio will require multi-year data collection.

Looking forward, the next-generation Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is expected to provide an order of magnitude improvement in sensitivity. CTA could potentially detect the electron shadow in under 5 hours, making high-energy antimatter studies a routine part of ground-based gamma-ray astronomy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The antimatter components measured in the Cosmic Ray (CR) flux are thought as secondary particles induced by the propagation of galactic CRs within the galaxy. Recent results from the PAMELA experiment show an unexpected increase of the positron electron ratio above 10 GeV. There could be different interpretations to explain that result, the most discussed ones being the signature of nearby compact astrophysical source(s) or of dark matter annihilation/decay. Probing the positron-fraction rise above 100 GeV would help to disentangle among different scenarios. Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes (IACT) can extract the cosmic lepton signal from the hadronic CR background between a few hundred GeV and a few TeV and reconstruct energy and incident direction with a very good resolution. In addition, by using the natural spectrometer formed by the Moon and the geomagnetic field, it is possible to measure the positron/electron ratio at the TeV regime through the observation of the CR Moon shadow. Despite the technique is particularly challenging because of the high background light induced by the Moon and the treatment of data, the MAGIC collaboration has performed for the first time such observations in 2010 and 2011. Here we present the observation strategy and the performance achieved during this campaign.
BibTeX
@misc{colin2011probing,
  author = {P. Colin and Daniela Borla Tridon and Alicia Diago Ortega and Marlene Doert and M. Doro and Jonathan Pochon and N. Strah and Tihomir Surić and M. Teshima},
  title = {{Probing the CR positron/electron ratio at few hundreds GeV through Moon shadow observation with the MAGIC telescopes}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1110.0183},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1110.0183},
}
Figure