Probing light mediators and (g − 2)μ through detection of coherent elastic neutrino nucleus scattering at COHERENT

M. Atzori Corona, M. Cadeddu, N. Cargioli, F. Dordei, C. Giunti, Yufeng Li, E. Picciau, Christoph A. Ternes, Y. Y. ZhangJournal of High Energy Physics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses data from the COHERENT experiment, which detects coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CEvNS), to place stringent constraints on new physics models involving light mediator particles. By analyzing these CEvNS events, the researchers can rule out or significantly narrow down the parameter space for various theoretical models that could explain phenomena like the muon's anomalous magnetic moment (g-2)μ.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, has some outstanding puzzles. One of these is the persistent discrepancy between the experimentally measured value of the muon's anomalous magnetic moment (g-2)μ and its theoretical prediction within the Standard Model. This difference, known as the (g-2)μ anomaly, hints at the existence of new particles or forces beyond the Standard Model.

Another area of interest is Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering (CEvNS), a process where a neutrino interacts with an entire atomic nucleus. This interaction is sensitive to new physics that might involve light mediator particles (like hypothetical Z' bosons or scalar bosons) that couple to neutrinos and quarks. The COHERENT experiment has provided precise measurements of CEvNS, making it a powerful tool to probe these new physics scenarios. This paper aims to leverage the latest COHERENT data to constrain models of light mediators and see if these constraints can shed light on the (g-2)μ anomaly.

Methods

The researchers analyze the CEvNS event data collected by the COHERENT experiment using both cesium iodide (CsI) and argon (Ar) detectors. They employ a statistical analysis framework, specifically a Poissonian least-squares method, to fit the observed event spectra to theoretical predictions.

The core of their method involves comparing the experimental data to predictions from various extensions of the Standard Model. These extensions include models with:

  • Universal Z' boson: A hypothetical new vector boson that couples universally to all Standard Model fermions.
  • Anomaly-free U(1)' gauge models: These models introduce a new gauge symmetry and a corresponding Z' boson, with specific charges assigned to quarks and leptons to cancel quantum anomalies. This includes popular models like B-L (Baryon minus Lepton number) and variations like B-3Le, B-3Lμ, etc.
  • Lepton-flavor-specific models (Le-Lμ, Le-Lτ, Lμ-Lτ): These models involve Z' bosons that couple specifically to certain lepton flavors, with interactions with quarks arising at the one-loop level through kinetic mixing with the photon.
  • Light scalar boson: A hypothetical new scalar particle that couples to quarks and leptons.

For each model, the paper calculates the predicted CEvNS cross-section and event rate, incorporating the effects of the new mediator. They then derive exclusion limits on the mass and coupling strength of these mediators by comparing the model predictions to the COHERENT data. These limits are also compared with constraints from other experiments and the parameter regions that could explain the (g-2)μ anomaly.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this paper are the experimental data from the COHERENT experiment, specifically:

  • COHERENT CsI data: The latest release from 2021.
  • COHERENT Ar data: The 2020 release.

The paper also references and compares its results with exclusion limits from a wide range of other experiments, including:

  • Searches for dark photons and other light mediators from beam dump experiments (e.g., E141, E137).
  • Fixed-target experiments (e.g., A1, APEX).
  • Collider experiments (e.g., BaBar, LHCb).
  • Rare meson decay experiments (e.g., NA48/2).
  • Invisible dark photon decay searches (e.g., NA64).
  • Global analysis of oscillation data (OSC).
  • Reactor CEvNS experiments (e.g., CONNIE).
  • Muon (g-2)μ anomaly measurements (Brookhaven and Fermilab).
  • Electron (g-2)e anomaly measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CEvNS as a powerful probe: The paper strongly reinforces the idea that CEvNS is a highly sensitive probe for new physics, particularly for light mediator particles that interact with neutrinos and quarks. The precision of the COHERENT experiment allows for significant constraints on these models.
  • Discriminating between models: Different U(1)' gauge models have distinct charge assignments for quarks and leptons. This leads to unique signatures in the CEvNS cross-section, allowing the COHERENT data to differentiate between these models.
  • Loop-level vs. tree-level interactions: The paper highlights the difference in sensitivity between models where the new mediator interacts directly with quarks (tree-level) and those where it interacts indirectly via photon kinetic mixing (loop-level). Tree-level models generally yield stronger constraints.
  • The (g-2)μ anomaly connection: A key motivation is to see if CEvNS data can constrain or rule out models that could explain the muon (g-2)μ anomaly. The paper finds that for many models where the muon couples to the new mediator, the CEvNS constraints are indeed strong enough to exclude the parameter regions favored by the (g-2)μ anomaly.
  • Scalar vs. Vector mediators: The paper also explores a light scalar boson mediator. The interaction of scalar bosons with nuclei is incoherent with the Standard Model contribution, leading to a different spectral shape and distinct constraints compared to vector mediators.

Key Results

  • Stringent constraints on light mediators: The COHERENT CsI and Ar data, both individually and combined, provide significant constraints on the mass and coupling of various light vector and scalar boson mediators.
  • Exclusion of (g-2)μ anomaly explanations: For several models where the muon couples to the new mediator, the CEvNS data, combined with other experimental constraints, exclude the parameter regions that could explain the muon (g-2)μ anomaly. This is particularly true for models with direct quark couplings.
  • Extension of exclusion regions: The COHERENT data extends the exclusion regions in the mass-coupling plane for many models, particularly for lower mediator masses (10 MeV to 100 MeV) and for models where the Z' boson couples directly to quarks.
  • Loop-induced interactions are less constrained: Models where the Z' boson interacts with quarks only at the loop level (e.g., Le-Lμ, Le-Lτ, Lμ-Lτ) yield weaker constraints compared to tree-level models, as expected.
  • Scalar mediator constraints: The analysis of the scalar mediator model also yields strong constraints, significantly extending the exclusion region and ruling out explanations for the (g-2)μ anomaly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical uncertainties: The paper acknowledges that for scalar mediators, the calculation of nuclear scalar charges can have large theoretical uncertainties.
  • Model-specific assumptions: The analysis relies on specific assumptions within each model, such as the universality of couplings or the cancellation of anomalies.
  • Future experiments: The paper implicitly suggests that future, more precise CEvNS experiments or complementary searches for new physics will further refine these constraints and potentially uncover new phenomena. The authors also mention the use of the "darkcast" code for recasting limits, indicating a broader effort to compare results across different experimental searches.
  • Nuance in (g-2)μ anomaly explanation: While many models are excluded, the paper doesn't claim to definitively solve or disprove the (g-2)μ anomaly, but rather to constrain the parameter space of potential explanations.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We present the constraints on the parameters of several light boson mediator models obtained from the analysis of the current data of the COHERENT CE ν NS experiment. We consider a variety of vector boson mediator models: the so-called universal, the B − L and other anomaly-free U(1)′ gauge models with direct couplings of the new vector boson with neutrinos and quarks, and the anomaly-free L e − L μ , L e − L τ , and L μ − L τ gauge models where the coupling of the new vector boson with the quarks is generated by kinetic mixing with the photon at the one-loop level. We consider also a model with a new light scalar boson mediator that is assumed, for simplicity, to have universal coupling with quarks and leptons. Since the COHERENT CE ν NS data are well-fitted with the cross section predicted by the Standard Model, the analysis of the data yields constraints for the mass and coupling of the new boson mediator that depend on the charges of quarks and neutrinos in each model under consideration. We compare these constraints with the limits obtained in other experiments and with the values that can explain the muon g − 2 anomaly in the models where the muon couples to the new boson mediator.
BibTeX
@article{corona2022probing,
  author = {M. Atzori Corona and M. Cadeddu and N. Cargioli and F. Dordei and C. Giunti and Yufeng Li and E. Picciau and Christoph A. Ternes and Y. Y. Zhang},
  title = {{Probing light mediators and (g − 2)μ through detection of coherent elastic neutrino nucleus scattering at COHERENT}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep05(2022)109},
}
Figure