Probing gravity with the DES-CMASS sample and BOSS spectroscopy

S. Lee, Eric Huff, A. Choi, J. Elvin-Poole, Christopher M. Hirata, K. Honscheid, N. MacCrann, Ashley J. Ross, M. A. Troxel, T. F. Eifler, Hui Kong, A. Ferté, J. Blazek, Dragan Huterer, A. Amara, A. Campos, Angela Chen, S Dodelson, Pablo Lemos, C. Danielle Leonard, Valentina P. Miranda, J. Muir, Marco Raveri, L F Secco, N. Weaverdyck, J. Zuntz, S L Bridle, C. Davis, J DeRose, M. Gatti, J. Prat, Markus Michael Rau, S. Samuroff, C. Sánchez, P Vielzeuf, M. Aguena, S Allam, A. Amon, F. Andrade-Oliveira, G. M. Bernstein, E. Bertin, David J. Brooks, D L Burke, A. Carnero Rosell, M. Carrasco Kind, J. Carretero, F. J. Castander, R. Cawthon, C Conselice, M. Costanzi, L. da Costa, M. E. S. Pereira, J. De Vicente, S. Desai, H. T. Diehl, J P Dietrich, Peter Doel, S Everett, A. E. Evrard, I. Ferrero, P. Fosalba, J Frieman, J. García-Bellido, E. Gaztañaga, D. W. Gerdes, T. Giannantonio, D. Gruen, R. A. Gruendl, J Gschwend, G Gutierrez, W. G. Hartley, S. R. Hinton, B. Hoyle, D J James, K. Kuehn, N. Kuropatkin, O Lahav, M. Lima, M A G Maia, M. March, J L Marshall, F. Menanteau, R Miquel, J J Mohr, R. Morgan, A. Palmese, F. Paz-Chinchón, A Pieres, A A Plazas Malagón, A. Roodman, E. Sánchez, V Scarpine, M. Schubnell, S. Serrano, I Sevilla-Noarbe, E. Sheldon, M. Smith, E. Suchyta, M E C SwansonLA Referencia (Red Federada de Repositorios Institucionales de Publicaciones Científicas) 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new way to combine data from the Dark Energy Survey (DES) and the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS) to test theories of gravity beyond Einstein's General Relativity. By creating a "photometric equivalent" of the BOSS CMASS galaxy sample (called DMASS) within the DES footprint, they achieve tighter constraints on modified gravity parameters than previous methods, primarily by better constraining galaxy bias.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cosmologists are trying to understand the accelerating expansion of the Universe. While the standard Lambda-CDM model (with a cosmological constant) is successful, it has theoretical puzzles. Modified gravity (MG) theories offer an alternative by altering Einstein's General Relativity on large scales to explain this acceleration. Testing these MG theories requires precise measurements of how structures in the Universe grow over time. Redshift-space distortions (RSD) from spectroscopic surveys and weak gravitational lensing from photometric surveys are key probes. However, combining these probes optimally is challenging, especially when surveys have limited overlap. This paper addresses the challenge of maximizing the scientific return from overlapping photometric and spectroscopic surveys by creating a photometric sample (DMASS) that mimics a spectroscopic sample (CMASS), allowing for a more powerful joint analysis.

Methods

The core innovation is the creation of the DES-CMASS (DMASS) sample. This photometric sample is designed to statistically replicate the properties of the CMASS galaxy sample from BOSS. This is achieved by training a selection algorithm on the small overlapping region between DES and BOSS and then applying it to the rest of the DES footprint. This allows researchers to use DMASS galaxies as "lenses" for weak lensing measurements within the DES survey area, effectively extending the reach of CMASS-like galaxy clustering information.

The analysis combines several data vectors:

  • DMASS 3x2pt: This includes angular galaxy clustering, cosmic shear (from DES sources), and galaxy-galaxy lensing (cross-correlation between DMASS lenses and DES sources).
  • CMASS RSD/BAO: Redshift-space distortion and Baryon Acoustic Oscillation measurements from the BOSS CMASS sample.
  • Planck CMB: Cosmic Microwave Background data from the Planck satellite to constrain early universe parameters.

The analysis uses a phenomenological parametrization of modified gravity with two parameters, $\mu$ and $\Sigma$, which modify the gravitational potentials. They employ a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis using the multinest algorithm to derive constraints on cosmological and modified gravity parameters.

Datasets

  • Dark Energy Survey (DES):
    • DMASS galaxy sample: A newly constructed photometric sample designed to mimic the BOSS CMASS sample. It covers 1,244 deg² of the DES Y1 footprint.
  • METACALIBRATION source catalog: Used for cosmic shear measurements, divided into four tomographic redshift bins.
  • Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS):
    • CMASS galaxy sample: Used for redshift-space distortion (RSD) and Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) measurements.
  • Planck Satellite:
    • CMB data: Used to constrain early universe parameters and improve overall model fitting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DMASS as a powerful proxy: The DMASS sample successfully acts as a photometric equivalent to the spectroscopic CMASS sample, enabling a more efficient combination of DES and BOSS data.
  • Breaking degeneracies with shared galaxy bias: A crucial finding is that by sharing and tightly constraining the galaxy bias parameter between the DMASS (photometric) and CMASS (spectroscopic) samples, the degeneracy between galaxy bias and other cosmological parameters (especially modified gravity parameters) is significantly reduced. This leads to tighter constraints.
  • Optimizing survey combinations: The approach of creating photometric equivalents of spectroscopic samples is a promising strategy for maximizing the scientific output of future surveys with limited overlaps, such as DESI and LSST.
  • Modified gravity constraints are competitive: Despite using fewer external data sets than some previous analyses, the DMASS approach yields competitive constraints on modified gravity parameters, comparable to or better than previous DES Y1 analyses.

Key Results

The paper reports the following key constraints on modified gravity parameters from the "baseline + Planck" dataset (DMASS 3x2pt + CMASS RSD/BAO + Planck):

  • $\mu_0 = -0.37 \pm 0.47$
  • $\Sigma_0 = 0.078 \pm 0.078$

These results are consistent with General Relativity ($\mu_0 = \Sigma_0 = 0$). The paper highlights that:

  • The DMASS 3x2pt data improves constraints by 28% for $\mu_0$ and 30% for $\Sigma_0$ compared to using only CMASS RSD/BAO + Planck.
  • Compared to the DES Y1 REDMAGIC sample with the same external data, DMASS provides tighter constraints by 29% for $\mu_0$ and 21% for $\Sigma_0$.
  • The shared galaxy bias parameter leads to an ~80% improvement in its constraint compared to using external data alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-linear scales: The phenomenological MG parametrization is based on linear perturbation theory. To accurately probe smaller, non-linear scales, more sophisticated methods like N-body simulations for specific MG models would be required. The analysis therefore restricts itself to larger scales.
  • Potential systematics: While robustness tests were performed, the paper acknowledges a potential issue with the tangential shear signal from the first source bin being higher than predicted. Although this did not significantly bias the results on the scales used, it warrants further investigation.
  • Future surveys: The authors suggest that this methodology of creating photometric equivalents of spectroscopic samples is directly applicable to future large-scale surveys like DESI and LSST, which have limited sky overlap. This approach will be crucial for maximizing the scientific return from these next-generation instruments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The DES-CMASS sample (DMASS) is designed to optimally combine the weak lensing measurements from the Dark Energy Survey (DES) and redshift-space distortions (RSD) probed by the CMASS galaxy sample from the Baryonic Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey. In this paper, we demonstrate the feasibility of adopting DMASS as the equivalent of CMASS for a joint analysis of DES and BOSS in the framework of modified gravity. We utilize the angular clustering of the DMASS galaxies, cosmic shear of the DES metacalibration sources, and cross-correlation of the two as data vectors. By jointly fitting the combination of the data with the RSD measurements from the CMASS sample and Planck data, we obtain the constraints on modified gravity parameters $\\mu 0=-0.37{+0.47}{-0.45}$ and $\\Sigma 0=0.078{+0.078}{-0.082}$. Our constraints of modified gravity with DMASS are tighter than those with the DES Year 1 redMaGiC sample with the same external data sets by 29 per cent for μ0 and 21 per cent for ς0, and comparable to the published results of the DES Year 1 modified gravity analysis despite this work using fewer external data sets. This improvement is mainly because the galaxy bias parameter is shared and more tightly constrained by both CMASS and DMASS, effectively breaking the degeneracy between the galaxy bias and other cosmological parameters. Such an approach to optimally combine photometric and spectroscopic surveys using a photometric sample equivalent to a spectroscopic sample can be applied to combining future surveys having a limited overlap such as DESI and LSST.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2022probing,
  author = {S. Lee and Eric Huff and A. Choi and J. Elvin-Poole and Christopher M. Hirata and K. Honscheid and N. MacCrann and Ashley J. Ross and M. A. Troxel and T. F. Eifler and Hui Kong and A. Ferté and J. Blazek and Dragan Huterer and A. Amara and A. Campos and Angela Chen and S Dodelson and Pablo Lemos and C. Danielle Leonard and Valentina P. Miranda and J. Muir and Marco Raveri and L F Secco and N. Weaverdyck and J. Zuntz and S L Bridle and C. Davis and J DeRose and M. Gatti and J. Prat and Markus Michael Rau and S. Samuroff and C. Sánchez and P Vielzeuf and M. Aguena and S Allam and A. Amon and F. Andrade-Oliveira and G. M. Bernstein and E. Bertin and David J. Brooks and D L Burke and A. Carnero Rosell and M. Carrasco Kind and J. Carretero and F. J. Castander and R. Cawthon and C Conselice and M. Costanzi and L. da Costa and M. E. S. Pereira and J. De Vicente and S. Desai and H. T. Diehl and J P Dietrich and Peter Doel and S Everett and A. E. Evrard and I. Ferrero and P. Fosalba and J Frieman and J. García-Bellido and E. Gaztañaga and D. W. Gerdes and T. Giannantonio and D. Gruen and R. A. Gruendl and J Gschwend and G Gutierrez and W. G. Hartley and S. R. Hinton and J. García-Bellido and B. Hoyle and D J James and K. Kuehn and N. Kuropatkin and O Lahav and M. Lima and M A G Maia and M. March and J L Marshall and F. Menanteau and R Miquel and J J Mohr and R. Morgan and A. Palmese and F. Paz-Chinchón and A Pieres and A A Plazas Malagón and A. Roodman and E. Sánchez and V Scarpine and M. Schubnell and S. Serrano and I Sevilla-Noarbe and E. Sheldon and M. Smith and E. Suchyta and M E C Swanson},
  title = {{Probing gravity with the DES-CMASS sample and BOSS spectroscopy}},
  booktitle = {LA Referencia (Red Federada de Repositorios Institucionales de Publicaciones Científicas)},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/mnras/stab3129},
}
Figure