Probing Critical Behavior of Long-Range Transverse-Field Ising Model through Quantum Kibble-Zurek Mechanism

B.-w. Li, Yukai Wu, Q.-x. Mei, Ruixiao Yao, Wentao Lian, M.-l. Cai, Y. Wang, Ben Qi, Lin Yao, Longfei He, Z.-c. Zhou, Luming DuanPRX 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates a quantitative application of trapped-ion quantum simulators by using the Kibble-Zurek mechanism to probe the critical behavior of a long-range transverse-field Ising model. By carefully calibrating interactions and increasing the number of simulated ions, the researchers extract a critical exponent that agrees with theoretical predictions, showcasing the potential for these noisy simulators to yield robust scientific insights.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantum simulators, particularly those using trapped ions, are powerful tools for exploring complex quantum systems. However, current "noisy intermediate-scale quantum" (NISQ) devices are prone to errors, making it challenging to extract precise, quantitative results. While qualitative observations of phenomena like quantum phase transitions are achievable, a key challenge is to find applications that are robust to these inherent imperfections. This paper addresses this by focusing on universal properties, specifically critical exponents of quantum phase transitions, which are expected to be less sensitive to noise. They aim to use the Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM) to quantitatively probe the critical behavior of the long-range transverse-field Ising model, a fundamental model in condensed matter physics, and to do so in a way that is less susceptible to the limitations of NISQ devices.

Methods

The core of the experimental method involves simulating the long-range transverse-field Ising model using a linear chain of up to 61 trapped $^{171}$Yb$^+$ ions. The Ising interaction and the transverse field are engineered using bichromatic Raman laser beams. A crucial step is the meticulous calibration of the coupling coefficients ($J_{ij}$) between ions, ensuring they follow the desired long-range power-law decay ($J_{ij} \propto 1/|i-j|^\alpha$).

To probe the quantum phase transition, the researchers employ the Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM). This involves slowly tuning the transverse magnetic field across the critical point. The KZM predicts that the density of topological defects (in this case, spin configurations not in the ground state) created during this quench scales as a power law with the quench time ($p \propto T^{-\mu}$), where $\mu$ is the critical exponent. The paper explores different quench paths (linear, exponential, local adiabatic) and settles on an exponential path for experimental convenience, particularly for larger ion numbers.

To extract the critical exponent, they measure the spatial spin-spin correlation function $G(r)$ and fit it to an exponential decay to determine the correlation length $R$. This correlation length is then related to the quench time to extract $\mu$. The experiment is performed for increasing numbers of ions to study finite-size effects and extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiment generates its own data through quantum simulation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantitative insights from noisy simulators: The paper demonstrates that even with the limitations of NISQ devices, it's possible to extract robust quantitative information about fundamental physical properties like critical exponents. This moves beyond qualitative observations.
  • Kibble-Zurek Mechanism as a robust probe: The KZM proves to be a valuable tool for probing critical phenomena because the resulting defect density and critical exponent are relatively insensitive to the precise details of the quench and some experimental imperfections.
  • Long-range interactions are key: The study focuses on the long-range transverse-field Ising model, where the interaction strength decays with distance. This is distinct from nearest-neighbor models and is more naturally realized in trapped-ion systems, offering a platform to study phenomena specific to long-range physics.
  • Finite-size scaling is crucial: By performing experiments with varying numbers of ions, the researchers can account for and mitigate finite-size effects, allowing them to extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit and obtain a more universal critical exponent.
  • Ferromagnetic vs. Antiferromagnetic challenges: The paper highlights that while the ferromagnetic (FM) case yields clear signals for KZM analysis, the antiferromagnetic (AFM) case is significantly more challenging due to frustration and a smaller energy gap, making it difficult to extract a critical exponent.

Key Results

  • The experiment successfully simulates the long-range transverse-field Ising model with up to 61 trapped ions.
  • For the ferromagnetic case, a critical exponent $\mu \approx 0.42$ was extracted for ion numbers $N \ge 36$. This value is consistent with previous numerical predictions ($\mu \approx 0.45$).
  • Finite-size scaling analysis suggests a thermodynamic critical exponent $\mu_\infty = 0.39 \pm 0.11$.
  • The antiferromagnetic case showed consistent results with theory but was too weak to fit a critical exponent due to frustration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • SPAM Errors: State preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors, particularly for ions at the edges of the chain due to laser inhomogeneity, can affect results. While the study mitigates this by focusing on central ions for correlation length fitting, the authors suggest composite pulses could further improve accuracy.
  • Coherence Time: The current coherence time of several milliseconds limits the maximum quench time. Future improvements in laser stabilization and system control could allow for longer quenches and potentially more precise measurements.
  • Exploring different $\alpha$ values: The current work focuses on $\alpha \approx 1$. The authors suggest that future experiments could explore other values of $\alpha$ to investigate how the critical exponent depends on the nature of the long-range interaction.
  • Antiferromagnetic case: Further work is needed to overcome the challenges in probing the AFM case, possibly through improved experimental techniques or longer integration times.
  • Theoretical comparison nuances: The paper notes potential discrepancies with some analytical results concerning the critical exponent, suggesting that different methods of extraction or the specific nature of long-range interactions might play a role. Further theoretical and experimental investigation into these differences is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The trapped-ion quantum simulator has demonstrated qualitative properties of different physical models for up to tens of ions. In particular, a linear ion chain naturally hosts long-range Ising interactions under the laser driving, which has been used for various phenomena, such as quantum phase transition, localization, thermalization, and information propagation. For near-term practical usage, a central task is to find more quantitative applications of the noisy quantum simulators that are robust to small errors in the parameters. Here we report the quantum simulation of a long-range transverse-field Ising model using up to 61 ions and probe the critical behavior of its quantum phase transition through the Kibble-Zurek mechanism. By calibrating and verifying the coupling coefficients, we realize the same model for increasing ion numbers, so as to extract a critical exponent free of the finite-size effect. For ferromagnetic interaction, our experimental result agrees with the previous numerical prediction. As for the antiferromagnetic case, signals are too weak to fit a critical exponent due to the frustration in the interaction, but still consistent with the theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023probing,
  author = {B.-W. Li and Yukai Wu and Q.-X. Mei and Ruixiao Yao and Wentao Lian and M.-L. Cai and Y. Wang and Ben Qi and Lin Yao and Longfei He and Z.-C. Zhou and Luming Duan},
  title = {{Probing Critical Behavior of Long-Range Transverse-Field Ising Model through Quantum Kibble-Zurek Mechanism}},
  booktitle = {PRX},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1103/prxquantum.4.010302},
}
Figure