TL;DR
This paper tackles a challenging class of optimization problems: maximizing the probability of an event occurring under uncertainty. The authors introduce a novel method to transform these problems into a convex optimization framework and develop a new algorithm, r-VRSA, that offers guaranteed convergence and rates, outperforming existing methods in preliminary tests.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Many real-world problems involve making decisions under uncertainty, where we want to maximize the likelihood of a certain outcome. This is often framed as a "chance-constrained optimization problem," where we aim to maximize a probability like $P(\zeta \in K(x))$, subject to constraints. The challenge lies in the fact that this probability function is often non-convex and difficult to optimize directly, especially when the underlying random variable $\zeta$ has a complex distribution or the constraint function $c(x, \zeta)$ is non-linear. Existing stochastic approximation (SA) methods struggle because they require unbiased gradient estimates, which are hard to obtain for these probability maximization problems. This paper addresses this gap by developing a method to convert these problems into a tractable convex form and a new SA algorithm that can handle the inherent biases.
Methods
The core of the paper's contribution lies in two main areas:
- Convex Representation: The authors show that the probability $P(\zeta \in K(x))$ can be expressed as the expectation of a suitably defined function $F(x, \xi)$ with respect to a Gaussian-like density $\tilde{p}(\xi)$. This is achieved by leveraging recent findings on non-Gaussian integrals of positively homogeneous functions. By composing this expectation with a smooth convex function $g$, the original probability maximization problem is transformed into minimizing $g(E[\tilde{p}][F(x, \xi)])$, which is a convex optimization problem. They explore two specific settings for the constraint function $c(x, \zeta)$:
- Setting A: $c(x, \zeta) = 1 - |\zeta^T x|^m$ (e.g., portfolio optimization).
- Setting B: $c(x, \zeta) = Tx - \zeta$ (e.g., set covering).
- Regularized Variance-Reduced Stochastic Approximation (r-VRSA): Since the transformed convex problem involves expectations of potentially non-smooth functions, standard SA schemes fail due to the lack of unbiased gradients. The authors propose a novel r-VRSA scheme that combines:
- Variance Reduction: To mitigate the impact of noisy gradient estimates.
- Iterative Regularization: To handle the bias introduced by the approximation of the expectation and the non-smoothness.
This r-VRSA scheme is designed to provide theoretical guarantees on convergence and convergence rates, which are often missing in existing SA methods for such problems.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and uses synthetic examples for numerical evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging Probability Maximization and Convex Optimization: The paper demonstrates a powerful technique to transform complex probability maximization problems into a convex optimization framework, making them amenable to modern optimization techniques.
- Handling Bias in SA: The r-VRSA algorithm is a significant advancement in stochastic approximation, as it effectively addresses the bias issue that arises when dealing with expectations of non-smooth functions, a common problem in chance-constrained optimization.
- Theoretical Guarantees for a Challenging Class of Problems: The authors provide the first known scheme with asymptotic convergence and rate guarantees for a class of non-trivial probability maximization problems, which is a crucial step for practical applications.
- Minkowski Functionals as a Key Tool: The paper effectively utilizes Minkowski functionals to characterize the feasible sets and derive the convex representations.
Key Results
- Convex Representation: The probability $P(\zeta \in K(x))$ is shown to be representable as $E_{\tilde{p}}[F(x, \xi)]$, leading to a convex optimization problem of minimizing $g(E_{\tilde{p}}[F(x, \xi)])$.
- r-VRSA Algorithm: The proposed r-VRSA scheme achieves:
- Almost-sure convergence guarantees.
- A convergence rate of $O(1/k^{1/2-a})$ in expected sub-optimality (where $a > 0$).
- A sample complexity of $O(1/\epsilon^{6+\delta})$ (where $\delta > 0$).
- Numerical Performance: Preliminary numerical results on portfolio selection (Setting A) and set covering (Setting B) problems show that the r-VRSA scheme competes well with naive mini-batch SA and integer programming approximation methods.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Complexity: While the scheme achieves convergence guarantees, its sample complexity ($O(1/\epsilon^{6+\delta})$) is noted to be worse than the canonical $O(1/\epsilon^2)$ for problems with unbiased oracles. This is attributed to the lack of access to unbiased oracles.
- Assumptions on Distribution: The paper assumes uniform distribution of $\zeta$ on a compact and convex set $K$. Future work aims to extend this to log-concave measures.
- Generalizations of $c(x, \zeta)$: The paper focuses on two specific forms of $c(x, \zeta)$. Extensions to more general forms are mentioned as future work.
- Chance-Constrained Regimes: The framework is also being extended to handle chance-constrained problems with additional constraints, which remains a challenging area for future research.
Summary updated