Probabilistic Approximations of Signaling Pathway Dynamics

Bing Liu, P. S. Thiagarajan, David HsuCMSB 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to approximate the complex dynamics of biological signaling pathways, typically modeled by ordinary differential equations (ODEs), using dynamic Bayesian networks (DBNs). This approach allows for more efficient analysis of pathway properties through standard Bayesian inference, significantly outperforming traditional ODE simulation methods in terms of computational speed for tasks like parameter estimation and sensitivity analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biological signaling pathways are crucial for cellular function, and their intricate dynamics are often modeled using systems of ordinary differential equations (ODEs). However, these ODE models present significant challenges:

  • Computational Intractability: ODE systems for complex pathways involve numerous variables and parameters, making analytical solutions impossible and numerical simulations computationally expensive, especially for tasks requiring many simulations (e.g., parameter estimation, sensitivity analysis).
  • Parameter Uncertainty: Many rate constants and initial concentrations in biological systems are not precisely known but are often available only as intervals of values. This necessitates Monte Carlo methods to sample from these intervals, further increasing computational burden.
  • Experimental Data Limitations: Experimental data, such as protein concentration measurements, often have limited precision and are collected at discrete time points, making direct comparison with continuous ODE solutions difficult.

The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a probabilistic approximation that captures the essential dynamics of ODE models in a more computationally tractable and interpretable framework.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is the construction of a Bayesian Dynamics Model (BDM), which is a time-variant dynamic Bayesian network. This process involves three conceptual steps:

  1. Discretization: The continuous value space of variables and parameters, as well as the temporal domain, are discretized into finite sets of intervals and time points, respectively.
  2. Trajectory Sampling: A representative subset of trajectories is generated by sampling initial states from a prior distribution and numerically integrating the ODEs.
  3. DBN Construction: The sampled trajectories are then used to construct a DBN that compactly represents the discretized dynamics. This DBN exploits the pathway's structure to encode dependencies between variables and parameters across time slices.

The key innovation lies in using this DBN representation to perform analyses via Bayesian inference, rather than relying on repeated ODE simulations. The Factored Frontier (FF) algorithm is employed for Bayesian inference.

Datasets

The paper uses a model of the EGF-NGF signaling pathway as a case study. This model is described as having 32 differential equations and 48 associated rate parameters, with data estimated from multiple experimental sources. The authors also synthesized experimental time series data for 9 proteins to test their parameter estimation method, mimicking western blot data by averaging 104 random trajectories and adding observation noise.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Continuous and Discrete: The BDM effectively bridges the gap between continuous ODE dynamics and discrete, probabilistic representations, making complex systems more amenable to analysis.
  • Computational Efficiency: By converting complex ODE dynamics into a DBN, the method allows for significantly faster analysis tasks. The BDM construction is a one-time cost, which is amortized over multiple subsequent analyses.
  • Exploiting Pathway Structure: The DBN's graphical structure directly reflects the biological pathway's dependencies, providing a more intuitive representation of the system's dynamics.
  • Probabilistic Inference for Biological Questions: Standard Bayesian inference techniques can be directly applied to the BDM to answer questions about pathway behavior, parameter estimation, and sensitivity analysis, which would be computationally prohibitive with ODEs alone.

Key Results

  • Accuracy: The BDM-simulation profiles (mean values derived from the BDM) showed good agreement with nominal simulation profiles (mean values from ODE simulations) for most proteins in the EGF-NGF pathway.
  • Speedup:
    • For basic probabilistic inference, a single FF inference execution took 0.29 seconds, compared to 386.4 seconds for generating a stable nominal profile via ODE simulation.
  • For parameter estimation, the BDM-based method achieved good agreement with test data.
  • For global sensitivity analysis (MPSA), the ODE-based method took about 22 hours, while the BDM-based method required only 34 minutes.
  • Parameter Estimation: The BDM-based parameter estimation method demonstrated good agreement with both training and test data, achieving a good balance between accuracy and performance compared to other ODE-based optimization algorithms.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The method successfully identified critical parameters in the EGF-NGF pathway, consistent with previous findings, with a dramatic reduction in computation time.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Discretization Choice: The choice of discretization for value and time domains can impact accuracy and computational cost. The paper notes that their method can be extended to non-uniform intervals and time points.
  • Model Complexity: While the BDM is more efficient than ODEs, its construction can still involve significant computational effort for very large pathways.
  • Future Work:
    • Applying the method to a wider variety of pathway models, in collaboration with biologists.
  • Augmenting ODE models with discrete features.
  • Developing methods to abstract the BDM representation into an input-output transducer for modeling larger networks of pathways and inter-cellular interactions.
  • Developing formal verification techniques based on the BDM representation, potentially using probabilistic bounded model checking.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2009probabilistic,
  author = {Bing Liu and P. S. Thiagarajan and David Hsu},
  title = {{Probabilistic Approximations of Signaling Pathway Dynamics}},
  booktitle = {CMSB},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-03845-7\_17},
}
Figure