TL;DR
This paper investigates the unique "Wenzhou Model" of private sector industrialization in China, revealing how a region with limited initial endowments fostered rapid growth through entrepreneurship, family networks, and a hands-off government approach. The study highlights the critical role of informal mechanisms and learning-by-doing in driving innovation and market discovery, offering insights into a distinct path of economic development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the question of how rapid industrialization occurred in Wenzhou, China, a region characterized by a strong private sector and entrepreneurial spirit, particularly in contrast to other parts of China that relied more heavily on state-owned or township-village enterprises. It seeks to understand the factors contributing to the "Wenzhou Model," which has become a well-known phenomenon, and to shed light on the entrepreneurship, enterprise growth, and the specific mechanisms that enabled this development, especially given Wenzhou's historically poor infrastructure and limited initial resources.
Methods
The study employs a probabilistic firm survey conducted in Wenzhou in early 2006, focusing on three industries: shoes, eyeglasses, and general equipment. Beyond a formal survey, informal questions were used to enrich the data. The methodology involved collecting detailed firm histories, including origins, founder backgrounds, financing methods (start-up and expansion), technology sources, market discovery processes, and explicit government assistance. Additionally, interviews were conducted with managers, skilled workers, and production workers to gather insights into human capital, job acquisition, and working conditions. The data analysis involves descriptive statistics and the identification of key patterns and relationships within the collected information.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this study is from a probabilistic firm survey conducted in Wenzhou in early 2006. This survey covered 72 firms across three industries (general equipment, eyeglasses, and shoemaking) in three areas of Wenzhou. Information was also drawn from a 2005 Intercensus Survey for data on incomes in rural origin provinces.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Wenzhou Model" as a distinct path: Wenzhou's industrialization was driven by private sector dynamism, a stark contrast to the state-led development common elsewhere in China.
- Entrepreneurship as the core: The success is deeply rooted in the entrepreneurial spirit of Wenzhou's founders, who often started with minimal resources and relied on personal drive and ingenuity.
- The power of informal networks: Family ties and friendships played a crucial role in financing, market discovery, and contract enforcement, embodying Professor Hayami's "community mechanism."
- Learning-by-doing and incremental innovation: Firms often started with simple, locally made technologies and improved them through hands-on experience, rather than relying on advanced imported technologies.
- Government's "hands-off" approach: While not entirely absent, the local government's primary role was often one of non-interference, allowing private enterprise to flourish, which was a significant departure from more interventionist policies.
- Labor mobility as a key enabler: The liberalization of migration allowed for a large influx of labor from rural areas, providing a crucial resource for these labor-intensive industries.
Key Results
- Approximately 85% of the surveyed firms were founded after 1990, with almost all starting as private sector entities.
- Over half of the firms are purely family businesses, with 38% having partners or shareholders outside the immediate family.
- 85% of firms had 3 or fewer founders, with 43% having only one founder, often a close relative.
- Founders were typically around 35 years old at the time of founding, with a significant portion having prior farming experience.
- Equity financing from shareholders (largely family and friends) was the primary source of initial funding (74% of firms), with reinvested profits contributing significantly to expansion (36%).
- Formal sector banks were perceived as difficult to borrow from, reinforcing the reliance on informal sources.
- Firms generally adopted ordinary or intermediate technologies, with only 10% using advanced technologies at the start.
- Learning by doing was the most common method for mastering equipment operation, with limited external technical assistance.
- Competition was fierce in terms of both price and quality, with many firms believing their products were lower quality but lower priced compared to national standards.
- About half of the firms export, with eyeglass firms showing the highest export propensity.
- Workers' salaries in Wenzhou were significantly higher (double to triple) than in their rural origin provinces, suggesting a strong surplus labor dynamic.
Limitations and Future Work
The paper acknowledges that the sample of firms existing in December 2004 may not be representative of all firms that have existed over the entire period of industrialization due to firm entry and exit. The study's focus on low-tech, labor-intensive industries means its findings might have limited applicability to future industrialization in China, which is expected to shift towards more sophisticated sectors. The authors suggest that as wages rise in Wenzhou, lower-tech industries might move to poorer regions, and that the "surplus labor" dynamic will continue to be relevant for labor-intensive industries in other parts of China. Future work could explore the dynamics of firm entry and exit more thoroughly.
Summary updated