Privacy-Preserving Bidirectional Data Transmission of Smart Grid Via Semi-Quantum Computation: On Mutual Identity and Message Authentication

Xiaoping Lou, Huiru Zan, Zidong Wang, Jinjing Shi, Shichao ZhangIEEE TDSC 2025 · DOI

Introduction

As the "nervous system" of modern energy infrastructure, the smart grid relies on constant, bidirectional data transmission (BDT) between utility providers and residential smart meters. While this connectivity enables efficient energy management, it also introduces significant cybersecurity risks. Traditional encryption methods, such as RSA, face an existential threat from the advent of quantum computing. However, implementing full quantum cryptography at the household level is currently unfeasible due to the high cost and complexity of the required hardware. Smart meters are essentially resource-constrained IoT devices with limited processing power and memory.

The Semi-Quantum Architecture

To address this gap, researchers have proposed a Semi-Quantum BDT Protocol. This approach leverages an inherent asymmetry in the system: the Service Provider (SP) possesses full quantum capabilities, while the Smart Meter (SM) is restricted to "semi-quantum" operations. Specifically, the SM can only measure qubits in the Z-basis (ZBM) or reflect them undisturbed (REF). This design ensures robust quantum-era security without requiring expensive hardware upgrades for every consumer device.

Architecture of the proposed semi-quantum smart grid system.

Protocol Mechanics and Quantum Principles

The protocol operates through a five-stage process designed to ensure both privacy and authenticity:

  1. Preparation: The SP generates entangled Bell states and inserts "decoy" particles to detect potential eavesdropping.
  2. Eavesdropping Detection: By monitoring disturbances in these quantum states, the system can identify interception attempts by malicious actors.
  3. Mutual Identity Authentication: Both parties verify their identities using a combination of pre-shared classical keys and quantum measurements before data exchange begins.
  4. Semi-Quantum Duplex Communication: This core innovation utilizes semi-quantum teleportation for SP-to-SM transmission, while SM-to-SP data is encoded via specific measurements of entangled states.
  5. Message Authentication: Hash-based Message Authentication Codes (MACs) are applied to guarantee data integrity throughout the transmission.

The security of this exchange relies on the fundamental principles of quantum measurement. When the measurement basis matches the state preparation, the outcome is deterministic; otherwise, it becomes probabilistic, allowing for the detection of unauthorized observers.

Comparison of correct and incorrect measurement outcomes based on the chosen basis (ZBM vs XBM).

Performance and Security Analysis

The proposed protocol demonstrates significant improvements over existing methods. Key results include:

  • High Efficiency: The protocol achieves a remarkable 94.1% efficiency, significantly outperforming traditional semi-quantum and full-quantum identity protocols which typically range between 50% and 60%.
  • Robust Security: Rigorous analysis confirms resilience against Man-In-The-Middle (MITM), impersonation, relay, and de-synchronization attacks.
  • Experimental Validation: Testing on the IBM Quantum Cloud Platform (using the ibmq_quito 5-qubit processor) showed that the protocol maintains over 90% accuracy for identity verification even in noisy, real-world quantum environments.
  • Operational Feasibility: With an execution time of approximately 2.1 seconds on standard hardware, the protocol is computationally viable for near-real-time grid operations.

Conclusion and Future Work

By concentrating quantum complexity at the service provider level, this semi-quantum approach makes high-level security practical for mass-produced smart meters. While the current protocol requires pre-shared classical keys, future research will explore the integration of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) to eliminate classical dependencies. Additionally, as quantum hardware matures, the scalability of handling thousands of simultaneous quantum connections within a single metropolitan area remains a key area for further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lou2025privacy,
  author = {Xiaoping Lou and Huiru Zan and Zidong Wang and Jinjing Shi and Shichao Zhang},
  title = {{Privacy-Preserving Bidirectional Data Transmission of Smart Grid Via Semi-Quantum Computation: On Mutual Identity and Message Authentication}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Dependable Secur. Comput.},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1109/tdsc.2025.3568707},
}
Figure