Principle of Maximum Entropy and Quantum Phase Transitions

Jianxin Chen, Zhengfeng Ji, Chi-Kwong Li, Yiu‐Tung Poon, Yi-Jun Shen, Nengkun Yu, Bei Zeng, Duan-Lu ZhouarXiv 2014 · arXiv

Abstract

In this paper, we discuss the connection between two genuinely quantum phenomena — the discontinuity of quantum maximum entropy inference and quantum phase transitions at zero temperature. It is shown that the discontinuity of the maximum entropy inference of local observable measurements signals the non-local type of transitions, where local density matrices of the ground state change smoothly at the transition point. We then propose to use the quantum conditional mutual information of the ground state as an indicator to detect the discontinuity and the non-local type of quantum phase transitions in the thermodynamic limit.

Introduction: The Challenge of Subtle Transitions

In condensed matter physics, phase transitions are traditionally identified by abrupt changes in local order parameters. However, certain quantum phenomena, such as topological phases, lack local order parameters, making them difficult to detect using standard methods. This research addresses a fundamental question: how well can a global quantum state be reconstructed from purely local measurement data?

By employing the Principle of Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt), the authors explore the "Maximum Entropy" state ($\rho^*$)—the most unbiased global state consistent with local observations. While classical inference is typically smooth, quantum systems can exhibit a "jump" or discontinuity in this reconstruction process. This paper establishes that such discontinuities are direct signatures of zero-temperature quantum phase transitions (QPTs).

The Geometry of Quantum Inference

The core of the study lies in the mathematical properties of the MaxEnt map. The researchers categorize QPTs into two distinct types:

  1. Type I (Local): Transitions where local observables themselves change abruptly.
  2. Type II (Non-local): Transitions where local data evolves smoothly, but the inferred global state $\rho^*$ undergoes a discontinuous jump.

This discontinuity is rooted in the geometry of the set of local density matrices, $\mathcal{L}$. When the boundary of $\mathcal{L}$ is not strictly convex—possessing "flat" regions or "corners" (as seen in the figures below)—the mapping from local data to the global MaxEnt state becomes sensitive to infinitesimal changes.

The set of local density matrices $\mathcal{L}$ exhibiting a non-strictly convex boundary with a flat edge.

As shown in the figure above, the presence of a flat boundary indicates that a single set of local measurements could potentially correspond to multiple global configurations, or that a slight shift in local data forces the MaxEnt inference to jump across a gap in the state space.

Visualization of the MaxEnt inference map near a non-smooth boundary, illustrating the discontinuous behavior of the inferred global state.

These "reconstruction gaps" signal the existence of long-range irreducible many-body correlations. This information is inherently global and cannot be reconstructed by simply piecing together local parts, a hallmark of both topological order and standard symmetry-breaking phases.

Detecting Phase Transitions via QCMI

To practically detect these transitions in large-scale systems where full MaxEnt calculation is infeasible, the authors propose using Quantum Conditional Mutual Information (QCMI), denoted as $I(A:C|B)$. This metric measures the correlations between two distant regions ($A$ and $C$) mediated by a middle region ($B$).

Key Findings:

  • Symmetry-Breaking as Non-Local: Surprisingly, standard symmetry-breaking transitions (like those in the Transverse Ising Model) are revealed to be "non-local" in this framework. The MaxEnt inference is discontinuous at the critical point ($\lambda=1$), where QCMI curves for different system sizes intersect.
  • Topological Phases: The Toric Code model confirms that topological transitions are inherently Type II. Local density matrices remain smooth, but the global topological order shifts, a change captured by the discontinuity in the MaxEnt map.
  • Quantum Error Correction: The study notes that non-local transitions occur when the ground state space functions as a quantum error-correcting code, protecting global information from local probes.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This information-theoretic approach provides a robust, unified framework for identifying diverse quantum phases. While calculating QCMI is more efficient than full state reconstruction, it remains computationally demanding for complex 2D and 3D systems. Future research will focus on applying these tools to more exotic phases, such as spin liquids and many-body localized systems, and further exploring the behavior of these signals in the thermodynamic limit.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we discuss the connection between two genuinely quantum phenomena --- the discontinuity of quantum maximum entropy inference and quantum phase transitions at zero temperature. It is shown that the discontinuity of the maximum entropy inference of local observable measurements signals the non-local type of transitions, where local density matrices of the ground state change smoothly at the transition point. We then propose to use the quantum conditional mutual information of the ground state as an indicator to detect the discontinuity and the non-local type of quantum phase transitions in the thermodynamic limit.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2014principle,
  author = {Jianxin Chen and Zhengfeng Ji and Chi-Kwong Li and Yiu‐Tung Poon and Yi-Jun Shen and Nengkun Yu and Bei Zeng and Duan-Lu Zhou},
  title = {{Principle of Maximum Entropy and Quantum Phase Transitions}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1406.5046},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5046},
}
Figure