Primordial power spectra from $k$-inflation with curvature

Zakhar Shumaylov, Will HandleyarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, authored by Zakhar Shumaylov and Will Handley, explores the intersection of two non-standard cosmological ideas: $k$-inflation (where the speed of sound for perturbations is not equal to the speed of light) and spatial curvature (the idea that the universe might not be perfectly flat).

By deriving a generalized version of the fundamental equations governing early-universe fluctuations, the authors reveal how the interplay between sound speed and curvature can explain observed anomalies in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and predict unique "ringing" signatures in the primordial power spectrum.

TL;DR

The authors derive the Mukhanov-Sasaki equations for $k$-inflation in curved universes, providing a new analytical framework to study the early universe. They discover that the combination of spatial curvature and low sound speeds creates a natural low-frequency cutoff and persistent oscillations in the primordial power spectrum, potentially explaining discrepancies in current CMB data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Standard inflationary theory typically assumes a flat universe ($K=0$) and a scalar field with a standard kinetic term, leading to a sound speed ($c_s$) equal to 1 (the speed of light). However, recent observations from the Planck satellite have hinted at potential spatial curvature and "glitches" at low multipoles (large scales) in the CMB that standard models struggle to explain.

While previous work had looked at curvature or non-standard kinetic terms ($k$-inflation) separately, this paper addresses the synthesis of the two. The challenge is that the math becomes significantly more complex when $c_s \neq 1$ in a curved geometry. The authors aim to provide both a rigorous derivation and a practical analytical approximation to see how these factors together shape the "seeds" of all structure in the universe.

Methods

The researchers employed a mix of theoretical derivation and analytical modeling:

  • ADM Formalism: They used the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM) approach to expand the gravitational action to second order, allowing them to derive the Mukhanov-Sasaki (MS) equation for a general kinetic Lagrangian $P(X, \phi)$ in the presence of curvature.
  • Two-Epoch Approximation: To make the complex differential equations solvable without heavy computation, they split the early universe into two regimes: Kinetic Dominance (KD) (immediately after the Big Bang) and Slow Roll (SR) (the main inflationary period).
  • Matching Solutions: They found exact solutions using Hankel functions for both epochs and matched them at a transition time ($\eta_t$). This allowed them to produce a closed-form solution for the primordial power spectrum.
  • Variable Sound Speed: Unlike previous models, they allowed the sound speed to differ between the two epochs ($c_-$ during KD and $c_+$ during SR).

Datasets

The paper evaluates its theoretical models against the Planck 2018 cosmological release, specifically:

  • Planck 2018 TTTEEE+lowl+lowE+lensing parameters for closed and flat universe cases.
  • The authors used the anesthetic software package to handle the Bayesian posterior distributions of these datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Curvature-Sound Speed Interplay: The most striking finding is that in a closed universe ($K=+1$), the effective wave number can become imaginary at large scales. This creates a natural low-wavenumber cutoff ($K_{cut}$), meaning fluctuations below a certain size simply cannot form.
  • Non-Decaying Oscillations: If the sound speed changes abruptly between the KD and SR phases, it triggers "ringing"—oscillations in the power spectrum that do not decay at high frequencies. This is a unique signature of $k$-inflation that isn't present in standard models.
  • Generalization: The authors successfully generalized previous landmark papers (Contaldi et al. and Thavanesan et al.), showing that their new equations reduce to the standard ones when $c_s = 1$ or $K = 0$.
  • Fine-Tuning Relief: By introducing $c_s$ as a variable, the model offers more "knobs" to fit the low-multipole anomalies of the CMB without requiring extreme fine-tuning of other parameters.

Key Results

  • Generalized MS Equation: The paper provides the definitive MS equation (Eq. 22 and 37) for curved $k$-inflation.
  • Cutoff Formula: They derived a specific formula for the power spectrum cutoff in closed universes: $K_{cut}^2 = \frac{3K(1-c_-^2)}{2c_-^2}$. As the sound speed $c_-$ drops, the cutoff moves to higher wave numbers, significantly suppressing large-scale power.
  • Visual Signatures: Figures 2 and 3 in the paper demonstrate how different ratios of $c_-/c_+$ produce wildly different "ringing" patterns in the angular power spectrum, which could eventually be used to constrain the physics of the very early universe.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Instantaneous Transition: The analytical model assumes an instantaneous jump from Kinetic Dominance to Slow Roll. In reality, this transition would be smooth, which might dampen the "ringing" oscillations found in this paper.
  • Numerical Verification: The authors note that while their analytical approximation is powerful for building intuition, full numerical solutions are required to confirm the exact amplitude of the oscillations.
  • Initial Conditions: The choice of initial conditions (e.g., Bunch-Davies vacuum) in curved space is still a subject of debate. The authors used the simplest choice but acknowledge that other "excited" initial states could change the results.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the primordial power spectra for general kinetic inflation models that support a period of kinetic dominance in the case of curved universes. We present derivations of the Mukhanov-Sasaki equations with a nonstandard scalar kinetic Lagrangian which manifests itself through the inflationary sound speed $c_s^2$. We extend the analytical approximations exploited in Contaldi et al [1] and Thavanesan et al [2] to general kinetic Lagrangians and show the effect of $k$-inflation on the primordial power spectra for models with curvature. In particular, the interplay between sound speed and curvature results in a natural low wavenumber cutoff for the power spectra in the case of closed universes. Using the analytical approximation, we further show that a change in the inflationary sound speed between different epochs of inflation results in non-decaying oscillations in the resultant power spectra for the comoving curvature perturbation.
BibTeX
@misc{shumaylov2021primordial,
  author = {Zakhar Shumaylov and Will Handley},
  title = {{Primordial power spectra from $k$-inflation with curvature}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.07547},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.07547},
}

Loading related content...

Figure