Primordial Features from Linear to Nonlinear Scales

Florian Beutler, Matteo Biagetti, D. Green, Anže Slosar, Benjamin WallischApollo 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that galaxy surveys, specifically the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS), can provide more sensitive constraints on subtle features in the early universe's power spectrum than the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). By developing a novel analysis technique, the authors set new, stronger limits on these "primordial features" and forecast significant improvements with future surveys.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the very first moments of the universe, the inflationary epoch, is a major challenge in cosmology. The "primordial power spectrum" describes the initial density fluctuations that seeded all cosmic structures. Deviations from a smooth spectrum, known as "primordial features," are predicted by many inflationary models and could reveal crucial details about this early epoch. Historically, the CMB has been the primary probe for these features. However, the CMB's sensitivity is limited, and its signal is affected by various complex processes. This paper addresses the question of whether large-scale structure (LSS) observations, like galaxy surveys, can offer a more sensitive and robust way to detect these primordial features, especially those that might be smoothed out or masked in CMB data.

Methods

The authors develop a new analysis pipeline to search for oscillatory features in the primordial power spectrum using LSS data. Key aspects include:

  • Feature Parameterization: They model primordial features as either linearly-spaced (Plin) or logarithmically-spaced (Plog) oscillations superimposed on a smooth power spectrum.
  • Robustness to Nonlinearities: A core contribution is showing that these features, much like Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO), are robust to small-scale nonlinearities in structure formation. They also develop a method to account for the damping of these features by large-scale gravitational effects.
  • Analysis Pipeline: They adapt a standard BAO analysis pipeline to search for these features, carefully marginalizing over nuisance parameters (like galaxy bias and smooth power spectrum components) to isolate the feature signal.
  • Forecasting: They use both Fisher matrix and likelihood-based forecasts to predict the sensitivity of current and future LSS and CMB surveys.

Datasets

  • BOSS DR12: The final data release of the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS) was used for the primary analysis.
  • Planck 2015 CMB Data: Used for comparison and joint analysis.
  • Mock Catalogs: MultiDark Patchy mock catalogs were used to validate the analysis pipeline and test its performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LSS Surpasses CMB: The paper convincingly shows that LSS surveys can be more sensitive than the CMB to primordial features over a significant range of frequencies. This is a major shift in how we probe early universe physics.
  • Robustness is Key: The demonstration that these features are as robust to nonlinear evolution as BAO is crucial. It means we can leverage the full statistical power of LSS surveys, including smaller scales, without being overly limited by complex astrophysical effects.
  • Damping is Calculable: The authors provide a theoretical framework to calculate and account for the damping of these features by large-scale gravitational effects, which is essential for accurate analysis.
  • Future Potential is Huge: Forecasts indicate that upcoming LSS surveys like DESI and Euclid could improve constraints by an order of magnitude, opening a new era for probing inflation.

Key Results

  • New BOSS Constraints: The analysis of BOSS DR12 data yields new, improved upper limits on primordial feature amplitudes, surpassing Planck's sensitivity for a significant range of frequencies.
  • Feature Amplitude Limits: The derived limits are typically at the percent level relative to the primordial power spectrum amplitude.
  • Forecasted Improvements: Future LSS surveys are predicted to improve these limits by up to an order of magnitude, and in some frequency ranges, will significantly outperform even cosmic-variance-limited CMB experiments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Frequency Range: While LSS surveys are becoming more sensitive, the CMB still covers a wider range of feature frequencies.
  • Model Dependence: The analysis focuses on specific oscillatory feature models (linear and logarithmic). Other types of features might require different approaches.
  • Theoretical Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge that future surveys will require more sophisticated theoretical modeling to account for subtle effects, especially at smaller scales and higher frequencies.
  • Future Surveys: The paper strongly advocates for the development of next-generation LSS surveys (like DESI, Euclid, and hypothetical "LSS-CVL") and improved CMB experiments to further push the boundaries of our understanding of inflation. The potential for improved reconstruction techniques is also highlighted as a way to mitigate nonlinear damping effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sharp features in the primordial power spectrum are a powerful window into the inflationary epoch. To date, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) has offered the most sensitive avenue to search for these signatures. In this paper, we demonstrate the power of large-scale structure observations to surpass the CMB as a probe of primordial features. We show that the signatures in galaxy surveys can be separated from the broadband power spectrum and are as robust to the nonlinear evolution of matter as the standard baryon acoustic oscillations. As a result, analyses can exploit a significant range of scales beyond the linear regime available in the datasets. We develop a feature search for large-scale structure, apply it to the final data release of the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey and find new bounds on oscillatory features that exceed the sensitivity of Planck for a significant range of frequencies. Moreover, we forecast that the next generation of galaxy surveys, such as DESI and Euclid, will be able to improve current constraints by up to an order of magnitude over an expanded frequency range.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{beutler2019primordial,
  author = {Florian Beutler and Matteo Biagetti and D. Green and Anže Slosar and Benjamin Wallisch},
  title = {{Primordial Features from Linear to Nonlinear Scales}},
  booktitle = {Apollo},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.17863/cam.48003},
}

Loading related content...

Figure