TL;DR
This paper investigates how consumers in the US and Israel perceived price increases during the COVID-19 pandemic. They found that while supply-driven price hikes were seen as more acceptable than demand-driven ones, a significant majority in both countries still found most price increases unacceptable. Interestingly, the perceived importance of a good influenced its fairness perception more in the US than in Israel.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic saw widespread price increases for many goods, leading to accusations of "price gouging." This paper delves into the consumer psychology behind these perceptions, specifically exploring whether price hikes are viewed as fair or unfair based on their underlying causes (market forces vs. opportunistic behavior). It builds upon the "dual entitlement" principle, which suggests consumers expect stable transaction terms and firms to maintain their usual profit margins. The study aims to understand how these expectations interact with real-world price changes during a crisis, comparing these perceptions across two distinct cultural contexts (US and Israel).
Methods
The researchers conducted online surveys in the US and Israel during November-December 2020. Participants were presented with scenarios involving price increases for specific goods (facemasks, hand-sanitizers, toilet paper, chicken, and Dijon mustard in the US; facemasks, hand-sanitizers, eggs, chicken, and Dijon mustard in Israel). For each good, participants were randomly assigned to one of three scenarios: price increase due to increased demand, supply shortages, or an unknown reason. They were then asked to rate the fairness of the price increase on a scale from "completely fair" to "very unfair." After assessing fairness, participants also rated the importance of each good on a scale of 1-5. Statistical analysis, including Wilcoxon rank-sum tests and random effects linear regressions, was used to compare perceptions between countries, across different reasons for price increases, and to examine the relationship between perceived importance and fairness.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from online surveys conducted in the US and Israel.
- US Sample: 904 respondents recruited via Amazon Mechanical Turk (mTurk).
- Israeli Sample: 1,043 respondents recruited via a business-news website and social media forums.
The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather presents the results from its own survey data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dual Entitlement in Action: The principle of dual entitlement holds up, with supply-driven price increases being perceived as more acceptable than those driven by demand or unknown reasons. This suggests consumers are more forgiving when they perceive external factors (like production issues) as the cause.
- Pandemic Price Hikes Largely Unacceptable: Despite the nuances of dual entitlement, a substantial majority of participants in both countries found most price increases unacceptable, highlighting a general consumer aversion to rising prices during the pandemic.
- Cultural Differences in Fairness Perception: Israelis were significantly more likely to find price increases unacceptable compared to Americans, even when controlling for other factors. This points to potential underlying cultural norms or economic sentiments influencing fairness judgments.
- Importance Matters, But Differently: In the US, consumers were more likely to deem a price increase unacceptable for goods they considered more important. This effect was less pronounced in Israel, suggesting that while importance plays a role, it's not the sole or dominant factor in Israeli fairness perceptions.
- The "Unknown Reason" is Problematic: Price increases attributed to unknown reasons were perceived as nearly as unacceptable as those driven by demand, underscoring the importance of transparency in pricing.
Key Results
- Overall Unacceptability: 77.44% of Israelis and 45.51% of Americans found price increases unacceptable across all scenarios and goods.
- Supply vs. Demand: In the US, 45.71% found supply-driven increases unacceptable, compared to 56.27% for demand-driven and 56.90% for unknown reasons. In Israel, these figures were 67.52% (supply), 82.41% (demand), and 82.32% (unknown).
- Product-Specific Unacceptability: In the US, over 50% found supply-driven increases unacceptable for hand-sanitizers (55.30%) and toilet paper (67.67%). In Israel, for all goods, the percentage finding supply-driven price increases unacceptable was always greater than 50%.
- Importance and Fairness (US): A positive correlation was found between the importance of a good and the likelihood of deeming its price increase unacceptable in the US (β=0.03, p <0.00).
- Importance and Fairness (Israel): The interaction term for importance score and Israeli sample was negative (β = −0.02, p < 0.05), indicating that the importance of a good mattered less for Israeli respondents.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the study was conducted in late 2020, a specific period of the pandemic, and perceptions might evolve. They also note that the survey was conducted online, which may introduce self-selection biases. Future research could explore these perceptions in different cultural contexts or over longer time periods. Additionally, further investigation into the specific reasons for the stark differences in fairness perceptions between the US and Israel would be valuable, potentially exploring national economic sentiments or consumer protection regulations. The paper also suggests that understanding how consumers' attitudes towards price increases are related to their importance attached to goods is an area for further exploration.
Summary updated