Price Co-Movement between Electrical Equipment and Metal Commodities—A Time-Frequency Analysis

Xin Cheng, Kailin Ji, Hao Chang, Yang Li, Yaqiong LiuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the prices of electrical equipment used in power transmission and distribution (PT&D) projects move in tandem with metal commodity prices. Using advanced time-frequency analysis, they found that co-movement is strongest in the short and long term, with no consistent lead-lag relationship. Crucially, short-term price synchronization is triggered by rising metal prices, while long-term trends are influenced by broader market movements, especially when metals are key components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The cost of equipment and materials represents a significant portion of PT&D project investments. Recent global uncertainties (trade wars, pandemics) have led to more complex and unpredictable price fluctuations for these essential components. This volatility poses risks to project planning, procurement, and overall investment stability. Understanding how the prices of PT&D equipment and materials are linked to more liquid and widely tracked commodity markets, like metals, could provide valuable insights for better forecasting and risk management. The paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing the dynamic price relationships between specific PT&D equipment and key metal commodities.

Methods

The core of this study lies in its application of wavelet analysis, a powerful technique for examining time series data across different time scales and frequencies. Specifically, the researchers employed:

  • Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT): To decompose time series into their time-frequency components, revealing how volatility and patterns change over time and across different cyclical frequencies.
  • Wavelet Coherency (WTC): To measure the degree of co-movement (correlation) between two time series at different time-frequency scales. This helps identify when and at what cyclical frequencies the prices of equipment and metals move together.
  • Partial Wavelet Coherence (PWC): This is a key innovation. PWC is used to isolate the co-movement between two series by controlling for the influence of a third variable. In this study, PWC was used to remove the effect of the Producer Price Index (PPI), representing the overall market price movement, to understand the direct relationship between equipment and metal prices. A further robustness check used the raw material PPI (PPI_rm).

The use of wavelet analysis allows for a more nuanced understanding than traditional correlation methods, as it can capture non-linear relationships and time-varying dependencies across different cyclical horizons (short, medium, and long term).

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • PT&D Project Data: Historical procurement records from the State Grid Corporation of China (SGCC) spanning June 2014 to December 2020 (78 months). This data was used to identify critical equipment and materials for substation construction, overhead transmission construction, and cable line construction.
  • Metal Commodity Prices: Monthly average prices for aluminum (AL), copper (CU), and deformed steel (RB) from the Shanghai Futures Exchange, also covering June 2014 to December 2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Short and Long-Term Synchronization: The most significant price co-movements between PT&D equipment and metal commodities occur in the short term (1-2 month cycles) and the long term (8-16 month cycles). This suggests that metal prices can offer predictive signals for equipment prices at these horizons.
  • No Consistent Lead-Lag: Despite some instances of metals leading prices, especially during global crises, there's no stable, consistent lead-lag relationship observed across the board. This implies that while metals can be leading indicators at specific times, they aren't a universally reliable predictor.
  • The "Up Phase" Activator: Short-term co-movements are primarily triggered when metal commodity prices are in a continuous rising phase. When metal prices fall or stabilize, this short-term synchronization weakens or disappears. This highlights an asymmetry in risk and benefit sharing between buyers and suppliers.
  • Market Influence on Long-Term Trends: Long-term co-movements are largely driven by the broader market price movement (as captured by PPI). However, this influence is weakened when the metal is a critical, high-importance component in the production of the PT&D equipment. This suggests that fundamental material importance can buffer against general market volatility.
  • Phase Matters: The price movement phase of a metal commodity (up, down, stable, volatile) significantly impacts the strength and presence of co-movements, particularly in the short term.

Key Results

  • Transformers: Showed co-movements with CU and RB in the short and long runs. PWC analysis revealed that PPI significantly influences these relationships, especially in the long run.
  • Shunt Reactors: Exhibited co-movements with AL and RB in short and long runs, and CU in short and medium runs. PWC indicated that overall market movement (PPI) has a wide-ranging impact, particularly on AL and CU.
  • Tower Materials: Primarily showed short-term co-movements, with some medium-term activity. PWC results suggested that PPI plays a role, but RB showed stronger long-term co-movements even after controlling for PPI.
  • Steel Strands: Demonstrated short-term co-movements, with CU and RB also showing medium and long-term links. The study found that RB's co-movement with steel strands was less impacted by PPI, likely because steel is a primary component.
  • Steel-Aluminum Conductors: Showed co-movements in short and long runs. AL had the most remarkable long-term results. PWC indicated that PPI significantly influences AL and CU, while RB's long-term co-movement was less affected.
  • Cable Lines: Displayed short and long-term co-movements, with CU showing stronger long-term links even after PPI control, suggesting copper's importance as a key component.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Scope: The study is based on data from China's State Grid, which might limit generalizability to other regions or market structures.
  • Lead-Lag Consistency: The lack of consistent lead-lag relationships means that while metals can be predictive, it's not a straightforward or continuous signal.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should incorporate broader macroeconomic factors and explore transmission control mechanisms, as prices are highly correlated with overall market trends. They also recommend that academics discuss multi-scale price co-movement and transmission control while accounting for common factors. For practitioners, the study implies a need to redesign buyer-supplier relationships to share risks and benefits more equitably.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rising uncertainty of the global markets has caused the price fluctuation of the equipment and materials in PT&D (Power Transmission and Distribution) projects to be more complicated. As the cost of equipment and materials accounts for a large proportion of the total investment of the PT&D projects, this study investigates the co-movement of the equipment and materials price and metal commodities’ price with the use of wavelet coherency and partial wavelet coherency analysis under a time-frequency framework. Our results indicate that (i) the co-movement manifests mainly in the short term and long term; (ii) there is no clear lead-lag relationship in the co-movement; (iii) the short-term co-movement is activated by the continuous rising of metal commodity price; (iv) the long-term co-movement is largely driven by the overall market price movement, but this effect is weakened when the metal is of high importance in producing the equipment. Our study shed light on the planning and investment in the PT&D projects for both the purchase and production sides.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2022price,
  author = {Xin Cheng and Kailin Ji and Hao Chang and Yang Li and Yaqiong Liu},
  title = {{Price Co-Movement between Electrical Equipment and Metal Commodities—A Time-Frequency Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142013443},
}
Figure