Prevalence of Comorbid Personality Disorder in Psychotic and Non-psychotic Disorders

Qiang Wang, Lei Zhang, Jiechun Zhang, Zhihao Ye, Ping Li, Feng Wang, Cao Yili, Shaojun Zhang, Fang Zhou, Zisheng Ai, Nan ZhaoFrontiers in Psychiatry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This large-scale clinical study in Shanghai reveals that nearly half of psychiatric patients carry a comorbid personality disorder (PD), but the specific "flavor" of that PD depends heavily on their primary diagnosis. While psychotic patients are more prone to paranoid and schizotypal traits, non-psychotic patients (those with depression or anxiety) show significantly higher rates of borderline and obsessive-compulsive PDs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In psychiatry, a primary diagnosis like schizophrenia or major depressive disorder rarely exists in a vacuum. Personality disorders (PDs)—enduring, maladaptive patterns of behavior and inner experience—frequently co-occur, significantly complicating treatment. Patients with comorbid PDs often face poorer prognoses, higher suicide risks, and lower adherence to medication.

Despite the high burden of mental health issues in China, there has been a lack of large-scale evidence comparing how these PDs are distributed across different psychiatric populations. The researchers sought to determine if there is a distinct "comorbidity fingerprint" for psychotic versus non-psychotic disorders, which could help clinicians tailor screening and intervention strategies.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study of 1,497 patients at the Shanghai Pudong New Area Mental Health Center. They employed a robust two-stage diagnostic process:

  1. Screening: Patients first completed the Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire Fourth Edition Plus (PDQ-4+), a 107-item self-report tool.
  2. Gold-Standard Validation: To confirm diagnoses, trained psychiatrists conducted the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis II (SCID-II).

The study compared 531 patients with psychotic disorders (e.g., schizophrenia) against 966 patients with non-psychotic disorders (e.g., depression, anxiety, OCD).

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical population-based dataset specifically recruited for this research between 2014 and 2021.

  • Psychotic Group: $N=531$ (primarily schizophrenia).
  • Non-psychotic Group: $N=966$ (depression, anxiety, panic disorder, social anxiety, and OCD).
  • Exclusions: Patients with organic brain issues (stroke, trauma), severe cognitive impairment, or unclear diagnoses were excluded to ensure data purity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Prevalence is the Norm: Comorbidity isn't an outlier; it’s a major feature of the clinical landscape. 37% of psychotic patients and 46% of non-psychotic patients met the criteria for at least one PD.
  • Diagnostic "Clustering": The study found that PDs tend to cluster with primary diagnoses that share similar underlying pathology.
  • Psychotic + Paranoid/Schizotypal: These PDs share genetic and neurobiological roots with schizophrenia, such as deficits in visual-spatial working memory.
  • Non-psychotic + Borderline/OCPD: Borderline PD often shares the emotional dysregulation seen in mood disorders, while OCPD frequently accompanies anxiety and clinical OCD.
  • Self-Report vs. Interview Gap: Interestingly, self-reported PD traits (via PDQ-4+) were much higher than interview-confirmed diagnoses (SCID-II). This highlights the "screening vs. diagnosis" gap: patients may perceive their traits as more severe than a clinical interview confirms.

Key Results

The quantitative differences between the two groups were statistically significant ($p < 0.001$):

  • Non-psychotic patients were significantly more likely to have:
  • Borderline PD: 16% (vs. 7% in psychotic patients).
  • Obsessive-Compulsive PD: 22% (vs. 12% in psychotic patients).
  • Psychotic patients were significantly more likely to have:
  • Paroid PD: 22% (vs. 11% in non-psychotic patients).
  • Schizotypal PD: 13% (vs. 5% in non-psychotic patients).
  • Overall: The non-psychotic group actually had a higher overall rate of comorbid PDs (46%) compared to the psychotic group (37%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles:

  • Cross-sectional Design: Because the data is a "snapshot" in time, the study cannot determine whether the personality disorder preceded the psychiatric illness or vice versa.
  • Recruitment Bias: Patients with certain PDs (like Schizoid or Avoidant PD) are naturally less likely to participate in intensive clinical studies, potentially leading to an underestimation of those specific types.
  • Medication Effects: The study did not account for the patients' medication history, which could influence how they present during clinical interviews.

Future Work: The researchers suggest longitudinal studies to track how these comorbidities evolve over time and how they specifically impact long-term treatment outcomes in the Chinese healthcare system.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> The burden of personality disorders (PDs) in China is large and the focus on mental health services is increasing. However, there is a lack of sufficient evidence regarding the prevalence of comorbid PD in psychotic and non-psychotic disorders, and whether PDs have different distributions. We aimed to investigate the PD comorbidity distribution pattern between psychotic and non-psychotic disorders using a clinical population-based study. <b>Materials and Methods:</b> We conducted a cross-sectional study of 1,497 patients in Shanghai. PDs were screened using the Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire Fourth Edition Plus (PDQ-4+). All patients were interviewed using the Structured Clinical Interview for Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition (DSM-IV) Axis II (SCID-II). We compared the differences in PD comorbidities classified as the 10 types of PDs in the DSM-IV, in 531 patients with psychosis and 966 patients with non-psychotic disorders. <b>Results:</b> More than one-third (37%) of patients with psychotic disorders met the criteria of at least one PD. Approximately half (46%) of patients with non-psychotic disorders met the criteria of at least one PD. Patients with non-psychotic disorders were more likely to meet the criteria of borderline (χ<sup>2</sup> = 20.154, <i>p</i> < 0.001) and obsessive-compulsive PD (χ<sup>2</sup> = 21.164, <i>p</i> < 0.001) diagnoses compared to those with psychotic disorders. In contrast, patients with psychotic disorders were more likely to meet the criteria of paranoid (χ<sup>2</sup> = 11.144, <i>p</i> = 0.001) and schizotypal PD (χ<sup>2</sup> = 14.004, <i>p</i> < 0.001) diagnoses than those with non-psychotic disorders. <b>Discussion:</b> PD comorbidity is common and comorbidity distribution pattern is varied in patients with psychotic and non-psychotic disorders, implicating the development of specific strategies that could screen and assess PDs in psychiatric clinical practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021prevalence,
  author = {Qiang Wang and Lei Zhang and Jiechun Zhang and Zhihao Ye and Ping Li and Feng Wang and Cao Yili and Shaojun Zhang and Fang Zhou and Zisheng Ai and Nan Zhao},
  title = {{Prevalence of Comorbid Personality Disorder in Psychotic and Non-psychotic Disorders}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2021.800047},
}
Figure