Presentation Matters: How to Communicate Science in the NLP Venues and in the Wild

Sarvnaz Karimi, Cécile Paris, Gholamreza HaffariACL 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper highlights a critical gap in NLP/Computational Linguistics training: effective science communication beyond just writing papers. The authors propose an introductory tutorial to equip early-career researchers with essential skills in oral presentations, poster sessions, demos, and social media engagement, aiming to increase research impact.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many early-career researchers in NLP/Computational Linguistics excel at getting their papers accepted into top conferences like ACL. However, the paper argues that the ability to communicate that research effectively – through presentations, posters, demos, and even social media – is equally crucial for impact but often underdeveloped. Existing research methods courses may not adequately cover scientific communication, and they are certainly not always tailored to the specific needs of the NLP community. This leaves many researchers without the necessary skills to translate their technical work into broader understanding and influence.

Methods

The paper doesn't describe a novel algorithm or experimental method in the traditional sense. Instead, it proposes a tutorial designed to address the identified communication gap. The tutorial's "method" is its comprehensive approach, covering a range of communication skills:

  • Writing: While the paper focuses on communication beyond the paper, it acknowledges writing as a foundational skill.
  • Oral Presentation: This includes advice for talks and poster sessions.
  • Demos: Practical guidance on showcasing interactive research.
  • Social Media Presence: Strategies for leveraging platforms to disseminate research.

The key innovation lies in the interactive nature of the proposed tutorial, allowing for real-time questions and clarifications, which is a significant advantage over static reading materials.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Communication is as important as publication: Getting a paper accepted is only the first step; effectively communicating the research is vital for its impact and adoption.
  • A skills gap exists for early-career researchers: Many PhD programs don't adequately train students in scientific communication, especially in NLP-specific contexts.
  • A multi-faceted approach is needed: Effective communication involves more than just giving a talk; it encompasses posters, demos, and leveraging social media.
  • Interactive learning is key: A tutorial format that allows for direct Q&A is more effective than passive learning from written materials.
  • Social media as a research dissemination tool: The authors see potential in using social media to amplify research outcomes, a skill that needs explicit training.

Key Results

As this paper proposes a tutorial rather than presenting experimental results, there are no quantitative findings to report. The "key result" is the identification of a significant need and the proposal of a structured solution (the tutorial) to meet that need.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation, as acknowledged by the authors, is that many researchers lack access to formal training in scientific communication. The paper implicitly suggests that the proposed tutorial is a step towards addressing this. Future work would involve the development and delivery of this tutorial, and potentially its evaluation to measure its effectiveness in improving researchers' communication skills. The authors also mention their ongoing involvement in activities like recruitment interviews, which provides them with insights into tailoring communication skills for industrial settings, suggesting a potential avenue for future specialized training.

Summary updated

Abstract

Each year a large number of early career researchers join the NLP/Computational Linguistics community, with most starting by presenting their research in the *ACL conferences and workshops. While writing a paper that has made it to these venues is one important step, what comes with communicating the outcome is equally important and sets the path to impact of a research outcome. In addition, not all PhD candidates get the chance of being trained for their presentation skills. Research methods courses are not all of the same quality and may not cover scientific communications, and certainly not all are tailored to the NLP community. We are proposing an introductory tutorial that covers a range of different communication skills, including writing, oral presentation (posters and demos), and social media presence. This is to fill in the gap for the researchers who may not have access to research methods courses or other mentors who could help them acquire such skills. The interactive nature of such a tutorial would allow attendees to ask questions and clarifications which would not be possible from reading materials alone.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{karimi2024presentation,
  author = {Sarvnaz Karimi and Cécile Paris and Gholamreza Haffari},
  title = {{Presentation Matters: How to Communicate Science in the NLP Venues and in the Wild}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=cHwVP9JpH2},
}
Figure