Present and possible future implications for mSUGRA of the non-discovery of SUSY at the LHC

P. Bechtle, K. Desch, Herbi K. Dreiner, Michael Krämer, Ben O’Leary, Carsten Robens, B. Sarrazin, P. WienemannarXiv 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Both ATLAS and CMS have published results of SUSY searches putting limits on SUSY parameters and masses. A non-discovery of SUSY in the next two years would push these limits further. On the other hand, precision data of low energy measurements and the dark matter relic density favor a light scale of supersymmetry. Therefore we investigate if supersymmetry -- more specifically the highly constraint model mSUGRA -- does at all agree with precision data and LHC exclusions at the same time, and whether the first two years of LHC will be capable of excluding models of supersymmetry. We consider the current non observation of supersymmetry with 35 pb-1 as well as the possible non observation with 1,2 and 7 fb-1 in a global fit using the framework Fittino.

Introduction

In May 2011, the particle physics community stood at a crossroads. The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) had begun its high-energy runs, and the initial results from ATLAS and CMS were starting to place significant constraints on Supersymmetry (SUSY). This paper explores whether the minimal Supergravity (mSUGRA) model—a highly predictive version of SUSY—could remain consistent with both these new LHC "null results" and long-standing precision measurements from low-energy experiments.

Methodology: Global Fits with Fittino

To evaluate the viability of mSUGRA, the authors employed the Fittino global fitting framework. This approach uses Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling to explore the four-dimensional parameter space of mSUGRA ($M_0, M_{1/2}, A_0, \tan \beta$).

The study's core innovation was the integration of LHC search results into the global fit. The authors simulated SUSY signals using Herwig++ and Delphes, focusing on the "jets plus missing transverse energy" channel. By comparing these simulations to the Standard Model (SM) background, they could translate the absence of a signal into a statistical $\chi^2$ contribution.

Simulated $M_{eff}$ distributions for various mSUGRA benchmarks against the Standard Model background.

Key Insights: The "Flattening" Effect and Parameter Shifts

A primary finding of the study is the "flattening" of the $\chi^2$ surface. As the LHC excludes low-mass regions where the fit was previously very sensitive, the remaining allowed parameter space at higher masses becomes statistically "flatter." This means that while the "best-fit" point shifts to higher masses, a broader range of high-mass values becomes acceptable within standard confidence intervals.

Impact of LHC data on the mSUGRA parameter space, showing the $\chi^2$ profile for $M_0$ (left) and discovery/exclusion contours (right).

Specifically, the best-fit value for the common scalar mass ($M_0$) shifts from approximately 77 GeV (pre-LHC) to a projected 400 GeV if no discovery is made with 7 fb⁻¹ of data. To maintain consistency with $(g-2)_\mu$ and dark matter relic density at these higher mass scales, the model is naturally pushed toward higher values of $\tan \beta$.

Conclusion: The Resilience of mSUGRA

Despite the initial lack of SUSY signals at the LHC, mSUGRA remains a viable and robust model. With 35 pb⁻¹ of data, the model maintains a P-value of ~50%. Even with hypothetical future non-discoveries up to 7 fb⁻¹, the model's agreement remains statistically sound.

The authors conclude that while direct searches for squarks and gluinos are powerful, the ultimate test for mSUGRA may lie in the Higgs sector. The model predicts a light Higgs boson ($h^0 < 135$ GeV), a prediction that was famously validated just a year after this paper's publication with the discovery of the Higgs at 125 GeV.

Summary updated

Abstract

Both ATLAS and CMS have published results of SUSY searches putting limits on SUSY parameters and masses. A non-discovery of SUSY in the next two years would push these limits further. On the other hand, precision data of low energy measurements and the dark matter relic density favor a light scale of supersymmetry. Therefore we investigate if supersymmetry -- more specifically the highly constraint model mSUGRA -- does at all agree with precision data and LHC exclusions at the same time, and whether the first two years of LHC will be capable of excluding models of supersymmetry. We consider the current non observation of supersymmetry with 35 pb-1 as well as the possible non observation with 1,2 and 7 fb-1 in a global fit using the framework Fittino.
BibTeX
@misc{bechtle2011present,
  author = {P. Bechtle and K. Desch and Herbi K. Dreiner and Michael Krämer and Ben O’Leary and Carsten Robens and B. Sarrazin and P. Wienemann},
  title = {{Present and possible future implications for mSUGRA of the non-discovery of SUSY at the LHC}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1105.5398},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1105.5398},
}
Figure