TL;DR
This study investigated the presence and health risks of organochlorine (OCPs) and organophosphorus pesticides (OPPs) in rice and soil from Thailand and China. While OCP residues were found to be higher in Thailand, both countries showed significant levels of common pesticides, with potential for bioaccumulation in rice. Overall, the health risks were deemed within safe ranges, though children remain a vulnerable subgroup.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Rice is a staple food for a significant portion of the global population, and its production relies heavily on pesticide use to ensure sufficient yields. However, the intensive application of pesticides, particularly in developing countries like Thailand and China, raises concerns about their persistence in the environment, accumulation in food crops, and potential adverse health effects on consumers and farmers. Specifically, this paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding the co-occurrence and comparative levels of both obsolete (OCPs) and emerging (OPPs) pesticides in paddy rice and soil from these two agriculturally important regions. Understanding these residues and their potential risks is crucial for informing food safety policies and promoting sustainable agricultural practices.
Methods
The researchers collected 20 rice and 20 soil samples from paddy fields across different regions of Thailand and 10 rice and 10 soil samples from the Yangtze River Delta region in China. These samples were collected after harvesting between 2015 and 2016.
For analysis, OCPs and OPPs were extracted from the rice and soil samples using modified QuEChERS (quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged, and safe) methods. The extracted compounds were then quantified using advanced analytical techniques:
- OCPs: Gas chromatography coupled with an electron capture detector (GC-ECD).
- OPPs: Gas chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (GC-MS/MS).
Statistical analyses, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA), Hotelling's T²-test, and Pearson correlation, were employed to compare pesticide patterns between countries and between rice and soil samples, as well as to assess the relationship between pesticide levels and soil organic carbon. Health risk assessments were conducted using established methods like Hazard Index (HI) and Incremental Lifetime Cancer Risks (ILCRs), comparing findings against European Union guidelines.
Datasets
The study utilized field samples of paddy rice and soil collected from various locations in Thailand and China. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing analytical standards for OCPs and OPPs were purchased from commercial suppliers.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ubiquitous Pesticide Presence: Both OCPs and OPPs are widely present in paddy rice and soil in Thailand and China, indicating ongoing or historical pesticide use.
- Dominant Pesticides: Dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDTs) and hexachlorocyclohexanes (HCHs) were the most abundant OCP residues, while methidathion, carbophenothion, chlorpyrifos, and diazinon were common OPPs.
- Regional Differences: OCP residues in rice were generally higher in Thailand compared to China.
- Bioaccumulation Potential: Bioaccumulation factors suggest that OCPs and OPPs present in the soil can accumulate in rice grains.
- Historical Use of OCPs: Isomeric ratios of OCPs in soil samples strongly suggest historical application rather than recent use.
- OPP Patterns Differ: While OCP patterns in rice and soil showed no significant differences between Thailand and China, OPP patterns did, indicating country-specific agricultural practices or environmental factors influencing their distribution.
- Vulnerable Populations: Children are identified as the most sensitive subgroup for OCP exposure risks.
Key Results
- OCP Levels: The median concentration of ∑22OCPs in rice from Thailand was approximately 2.5 times higher than in China. In soil, China had a higher median concentration of ∑22OCPs than Thailand.
- OPP Levels: The median residue levels of ∑15OPPs in rice from Thailand and China were comparable. In soil, Thailand had a slightly higher median residue level of ∑15OPPs than China.
- Detection Frequency: Multiple types of OCPs and OPPs were detected in over 50% of the total samples.
- Statistical Significance: Relative concentrations of OPPs in rice and soil differed significantly between Thailand and China (p < 0.0083). OCP residues in rice and soil also showed significant differences for HCHs (p < 0.05).
- Health Risks: Non-carcinogenic risks (Hazard Index) for OCP exposures exceeded acceptable levels for some consumer groups, particularly children. However, carcinogenic risks (ILCRs) for OCPs were generally negligible. OPP exposure risks were deemed negligible.
- MRL Exceedances: Some OCP residues in rice from Thailand and China exceeded EU Maximum Residue Limits (MRLs). Similarly, methidathion and phosalone in rice from both countries exceeded MRLs. However, the target pesticides were generally below the MRLs of China and Thailand standards.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study acknowledges that the Pearson correlation might be inappropriate for some OCPs due to extreme values in samples from northeast and south Thailand.
- No cancer slope factor was available for calculating ILCRs of OPPs.
- The study focused on specific regions within Thailand and China, and findings may not be generalizable to all areas.
- Future Work:
- The authors emphasize the need for strengthened cooperation among farmers, organizations, local authorities, and governments to eliminate pesticide residues.
- They suggest that implementing integrated pesticide management and good agricultural practices can contribute to reducing pesticide residues in paddy fields.
- Further research could explore the long-term health effects of chronic exposure to these pesticide mixtures.
Summary updated