Preliminary Study on Recontrol Evaluation of a Magnetic Bearing Rotor Falling on Touch-Down Bearings

Kai Zhang, Yang XuEnergies 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the challenging problem of controlling an active magnetic bearing (AMB) rotor that has fallen onto its backup touch-down bearings. By developing a dynamic model and simulating the application of electromagnetic forces, the researchers demonstrate that AMBs can potentially prevent catastrophic rotor whirl and restore stable suspension, even after a failure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Active magnetic bearings (AMBs) are crucial for high-performance rotating machinery, offering advantages like non-contact operation and precise control. However, a critical failure scenario is when the rotor loses its magnetic suspension and falls onto auxiliary "touch-down" bearings. This event is characterized by highly nonlinear dynamics and can lead to severe damage. The problem this paper addresses is how to leverage the remaining capabilities of the AMB system after a rotor drop to mitigate damage and potentially recover stable operation, rather than simply relying on the touch-down bearings to absorb the impact. This is particularly important for applications like flywheel energy storage, where rotor integrity is paramount.

Methods

The authors developed a simplified dynamic model of an AMB rotor system that includes the rotor, touch-down bearings, and their housing. They employed a single-disc rotor model and a two-layer touch-down bearing structure, incorporating Hertz contact mechanics to model the interaction between the rotor and the touch-down bearings. The core of their approach involves simulating the application of a controlled electromagnetic force from the AMB after the rotor has fallen. This force was simplified to have constant damping characteristics. They explored two strategies for applying this damping force: one targeting velocity damping and the other targeting whirl damping. The dynamic equations were solved numerically using the fourth-order Runge-Kutta method in MATLAB.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a simulated model and parameters derived from literature and typical values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AMBs can actively intervene post-drop: The most significant insight is that AMBs, even after a failure that causes a rotor drop, can still exert a meaningful influence on the rotor's dynamics. This challenges the notion that a drop is an unrecoverable event for the AMB system itself.
  • Damping is key: The research highlights that applying a controlled electromagnetic force with damping characteristics is crucial for attenuating the rotor's kinetic energy and preventing destructive whirl.
  • Velocity vs. Whirl Damping: Both velocity damping and whirl damping strategies showed promise in reducing impact forces. Velocity damping appeared slightly more effective in dissipating energy and stopping rotor bouncing within the simulation timeframe. However, whirl damping is noted as potentially easier to implement in practice as it doesn't require real-time rotor velocity measurements, only angular velocity.
  • Force Magnitude Matters: The study demonstrates that a minimum electromagnetic force (around 10 N in their simulations) is necessary to prevent the rotor from entering a destructive backward whirl state.

Key Results

  • Without AMB control, simulations showed significant impact forces, with a maximum radial force of 11.78 kN during a drop.
  • Applying a constant electromagnetic force of 40 N with velocity damping reduced the maximum radial force to 1193 N and the average radial force to 54.61 N.
  • Using the same 40 N force with whirl damping resulted in a maximum radial force of 1490 N and an average radial force of 52.20 N.
  • These results indicate a substantial reduction in impact forces and cumulative damage when AMB control is applied post-drop.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this is a preliminary study based on a simplified model. Key limitations include:

  • Simplified Model: Rotor flexibility, gyroscopic effects, and more complex AMB control strategies were not considered.
  • No Experimental Verification: The findings are based solely on numerical simulations.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Developing more complex models that incorporate rotor flexibility and gyroscopic effects.
  • Conducting experimental validation to confirm the simulation results.
  • Exploring more advanced control strategies for recontrol after a rotor drop.

Summary updated

Abstract

The dynamic control of an active magnetic bearing (AMB) rotor after the rotor falls to its touch-down bearings has always been a difficult problem for applications such as flywheel energy storage. The rotor drop process has obvious nonlinear dynamic characteristics. This paper first discusses the structure of AMBs and the basic principles of their control. Starting from the electromagnetic forces that electromagnets can provide, the problem is simplified to the influence of an electromagnetic force with constant damping characteristics on the dynamic characteristics of a dropped rotor. A dynamic model of an AMB rotor with touch-down bearings was built and the contact force model between the rotor and the touch-down bearings was determined. A constant damping electromagnetic force was applied in two ways to verify the dynamic control feasibility of a dropped rotor through magnetic bearings. The simulation results show that the dropped rotor recovery control is feasible by applying a reasonable electromagnetic force.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024preliminary,
  author = {Kai Zhang and Yang Xu},
  title = {{Preliminary Study on Recontrol Evaluation of a Magnetic Bearing Rotor Falling on Touch-Down Bearings}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/en17143457},
}
Figure